So, my best friend and I have had this discussion before and I am kinda interested to see what other people say about this... it is a VERY off the wall, not something you want to think about question... but the different answers and reasons could be very interesting...
If you HAD to choose between your spouse leaving you for another woman or dying, which would you choose and why?
leaving me for another woman, i'd rather him happy than dead. no matter how much it would hurt me, we've been best friends for so long that I'd rather be angry at him for leaving me than spend the rest of my life living without him in the world at all...
lmao... rooroo...
I pick die too... selfish but true.
I think it would be easier for me to deal with mentally [i mean who want's to deal w/ their hubby leaving them for another woman, geeze], and easier for me to explain to my kids...
It would kill me to see him with someone else... especially since I'm the first girl he ever kissed, and he is the only guy I've ever "been with"... just too much for me to deal with.
Hmmm...I think I'd rather he left me than die...although if he left me for another woman I might want to kill him! ;)
But seriously...I'd rather know he was alive and well on this earth because even if he wasn't my husband any longer he'll always be my kids Daddy and its hard not having your Daddy at any age
i think i'm gonna puke just thinking about him dead (i think that watermelon i had for breakfast was starting to turn because surely i can't be this nauseous just from thinking...LOL!). i definitely say i'd rather see him with another woman. well, not SEE him... but i'd much rather know he was alive!
lol-- This is actually hard--- I'd like to say I'd rather he die than me see him with another woman, but then my daughter suffers! So I guess another woman but I dare him!
well, what about this... (now this is really off the wall, so feel free to ignore me completely)... david carradine... if you were his wife, would you rather it were suicide or AEA?
ok... here is mine...
I would rather he die. My reason is because I would much rather explain to my children that he had NO choice in his leaving us than to tell them that he chose another woman over his family. Now, I am sure if it ever happened, he would be in their lives, but...
my dad left my mom for another woman and I still, to this day, don't understand it. I still feel like he chose her over us. So... guess I would just rather my kids not have to feel that way...
robin that is so sweet but im selfish like rooroo so i'd rather have him six feet under than with another woman. just like lori if i see him with another woman i might want to kill him. actually i'll kill em both! lol
And how good would that be for the kids, a daddy who left their mommy, and a mommy who went off the deep end, and ended up in jail for murder... lol :]
Like I said, better mentally to just have him die of other reasons rather then the wrath of mommy.
actually i probably dont have what it takes to kill. i told him if he leaves me i will not have second thoughts of killing myself. i will jump off this balcony but i thought of a better idea. i told him i'll smash his xbox and guitar to a million pieces! lol
Eh.... Niether. Either way I'd be miserable and he would be dead to me. BUT my son loves his daddy and he NEEDS his dad in his life... And if my husband wasn't happy with me what's the point of us being together.... His life shouldn't have to end because of me, whether it be him dying or staying with me even tho he didn't love me anymore. I think its selfish to rather your husband die than leave you for another woman... And kinda morbid! lol!
I don't really think its selfish for me at all... my dad was in my life when he left my mom, but I still feel like he chose her over me and my sister... so I don't want my kids to experience that feeling... I would rather neither of course too, but I would prefer him not leave me for another woman...
and I am not saying it because I wouldn't want to see him with another woman, I just would rather explain to my kids that it wasn't HIS choice to leave...
My answer to this is...I would rather him die. Like flips hunny said I would feel he chose the woman over our family. My dad did the same thing to my mom and did choose the other woman and her kids than be with my mom or me and my brother so I would NEVER want him to leave my children like my dad did me. Still to this day I dont see/talk to my dad. He would rather be with her children.
Yah my mom and dad split when I was young too. But I saw how much happier he was w/out her so I was happy for him.... I'm just an all around not selfish person so I'd never want my happiness to come before someone else in my familys
see, my dad and I don't have a great relationship now because of certain things, but he was there and did make some effort to see us... all her kids were grown, so that wasn't even the issue... but now I still resent my dad for leaving
Nope not me. I am selfish and I would rather visit him at his grave then see him with another woman. LOL
soooo funny but I would rather him die as well than to see him with someone else...The thought of that just breaks my heart!
I don't wish my hubby dead... I would NEVER wish that on him... And I don't even know how the conversation came up with my best friend, but we talk about some of the strangest things together... and this was something we discussed...
and I wouldn't want my hubby to stay with me if he isn't happy here... if it ever came to a day that he decided he didn't love me, then I would rather him leave me than to stay and be miserable...
but the question was meant to be which of 2 extremes and to see why people would prefer one over the other...
my best friend would rather her husband leave her period... whether for another woman, man or anything... she doesn't care why he leaves her, just as long as he is alive...
where, I don't feel that way...
although... in some aspects, I would rather him alive... my children do NEED their father, and that makes it very tough for me... but I would truly hate it if my kids ever felt about him the way I do about my dad...
Thats what I am saying, Even if he decided to leave or I had a choice for him to die, I would never wish him dead, I would rather him be happy with someone else
ok... the question wasn't asking if you wished him to die... that is not what its intended meaning is... like I said, I would never actually WISH my hubby dead, even if he did leave me...