Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Finder's Fees?

who's talking here?

Emilee 1
Annette 1
N!cole 1
JessicaS 3
rooroo 13
Mommy of 3 1
Fran 12
*jess&neil* 1
*Robin* 1
Madam Kelly aka Natashia 2
just a girl 5
Lars 1
Victoria 1
Out of here! 1
::Lara:: 9
Darin 1
Morgan 1
Gary 1
Rie Rie 22
allen 1
fran 5
LLLLindsay 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

Is it legal for a landlord to charge a finder's fee of about one month's rent when we found out about the house through a friend? He wants 1600 Euro for doing absolutely nothing. Our friend is friends with the military family PCS'ing out, and that's how we found the house. I hear this is typical but is it legal? I'm just happy I found this house and will pay it... but feel everyone does the same thing and that's why it still goes on.  

*Robin* --- 17 years ago -

I don't know the law, but if YOU found the house why should you have to pay? He did not find it for you........ 

Victoria --- 17 years ago -

Call housing and find out for sure...but from my understanding the only way they can charge you is if you hired them. Like they are a realtor basically. But I know housing will know the answer for sure! 

Fran --- 17 years ago -

we had a realtor here from our bank trying to sell our appartment, and he said if we found someone to buy it before him, they wouldn't have to pay him the fee. If he wasn't involved in the process and you didn't sign an agreement he has no legal right to demand it. 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

We did ask housing. The German lady there said that it was typical of landlords to ask for one month's rent as a finder's fee. At first he wanted 1740 Euro and she said that was too high, it should only be a month's rent, which in our case is 1640 Euro. BUT... the lady who manages the temp. house off base we are living in told me that a few years ago housing was shut down because there were German people working there who were making business with others on the side. I am so confused about this. He wants this money but said it was negotiable after I mentioned how high it was. I don't want to piss him off too much seeing that he will be our landlord for possibly 3 yrs but also hate being taken for a naive fool. It is true that the German economy would be pretty much non-existent if it weren't for all of us and the bases here. That doesn't mean I want to put up with the "normal" schemes. 

Fran --- 17 years ago -

Are you sure he wasn't talking about a DEPOSIT in case of damages ect. and not a finder's fee? Because THAT is normal and actually Germans are being charged two months rents as a deposit. 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

I am positive about the deposit vs finder's fee. We have to pay first month's rent, a deposit, last months rent AND a finder's fee (which goes straight into HIS pocket). That house was a target for many but I had first dibs and sure did have to fight for it anyway. The current tenant had to go up to bat for me too. This is why I don't feel like making a stink about it... but if it isn't legal... then daaannng, that's a lot of $$$$ that I just don't want to pay. We need new furniture and also have things to set up like phone, cable, etc. Everyone knows all this....haha 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

I am positive about the deposit vs finder's fee. We have to pay first month's rent, a deposit, last months rent AND a finder's fee (which goes straight into HIS pocket). That house was a target for many but I had first dibs and sure did have to fight for it anyway. The current tenant had to go up to bat for me too. This is why I don't feel like making a stink about it... but if it isn't legal... then daaannng, that's a lot of $$$$ that I just don't want to pay. We need new furniture and also have things to set up like phone, cable, etc. Everyone knows all this....haha 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

I am positive about the deposit vs finder's fee. We have to pay first month's rent, a deposit, last months rent AND a finder's fee (which goes straight into HIS pocket). That house was a target for many but I had first dibs and sure did have to fight for it anyway. The current tenant had to go up to bat for me too. This is why I don't feel like making a stink about it... but if it isn't legal... then daaannng, that's a lot of $$$$ that I just don't want to pay. We need new furniture and also have things to set up like phone, cable, etc. Everyone knows all this....haha 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

I am positive about the deposit vs finder's fee. We have to pay first month's rent, a deposit, last months rent AND a finder's fee (which goes straight into HIS pocket). That house was a target for many but I had first dibs and sure did have to fight for it anyway. The current tenant had to go up to bat for me too. This is why I don't feel like making a stink about it... but if it isn't legal... then daaannng, that's a lot of $$$$ that I just don't want to pay. We need new furniture and also have things to set up like phone, cable, etc. Everyone knows all this....haha 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

OMG! so sorry about accidentally posting the same paragraph 4 X's. It was going slow so I kept clicking on "add comment" Oops! 

Fran --- 17 years ago -

I guess since he has so many people interested, he feels like making some extra bucks for nothing. I've never heard anyone paying last months rent though, that is ridiculous, he seems like a very shady landlord! Too bad he seems to rent out an awesome house lol 

Madam Kelly aka Natashia --- 17 years ago -

we were told by housing that they are not allowed to charge finders fees. 1rst month rent and deposit is ok but a finders fee, no! you need to contact legal about that. 

Madam Kelly aka Natashia --- 17 years ago -

i have not heard of last months rent also, i deff say for this bypass housing (they can have some shady people) go to legal and see what they say. then from there go to housing and get them to contact your landlord 

Fran --- 17 years ago -

you should have this man taken off of the list IMO, call and report him, because NO German would ever fall for these shady demands he seems to have found poor Americans to fall for his crap. 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

My husband said the same thing. He is going to do that tomorrow. I'll let y'all know what they told him. Thank you all for taking time out, reading, and replying!! :) 

Fran --- 17 years ago -

Oh and a realtor over here needs a license, soooo since he is claiming the money, I'd be curious if he possesses one. Given the fact that it costs 1500 Euro I highly doubt it. Mh, I'd like to call him and scare him. Yes, I'm evil haha 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

Haha, Fran!! The lady here (manager for temp house off base) said the same thing. She wanted his name, info, etc. She said a licensed realtor has to pay 50% and she's sure he isn't. She said he wasn't supposed to charge that anyway. The problem is, if I said something up front about not paying, I wonder if he would've conveniently let someone else sign for it first?? We actually had that happen the day before we signed on this house but the other lady backed out because of the current tenant telling her to. It's a long story with all sorts of craziness. It's a jungle out there, at least this time of year for this neighborhood/schools, etc. Whew! 

just a girl --- 17 years ago -

I thought only realtors could charge finders fees. If you can pay 1640 euro for a house you will find a good one w/out all the hassle. I would keep on going. 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

But I'm not sure if he is a realtor per se. He is acting as landlord for the owner of the house. Does that make a difference? 

Fran --- 17 years ago -

Sometimes owners hire people to maintain their properties when they live out of town, doesn't have to be a realtor...If the lady said she is sure he isn't a realtor, he is actually doing something pretty illegal. But I agree, for 1600 you will find awesome houses around here. I wonder though if the REAL owner knows about the business this guy is doing. 

Fran --- 17 years ago -

hey, you could go ahead and call the owner and explain to him that you didn't find the house through him, maybe he'll work something out with you 

Gary --- 17 years ago -

We were working with our immobilien today, and he was talking about this some. If he is a property manager, then he cannot charge a finders fee; however, our immobilien said most will not be property managers because of that. Most maintain their license as immobilien, and then do the same job as a property manager. This relieves them of the responsibility, and lets them collect a finders fee. If this guy is not the owner of the house, he is probably an immobilien (just ask him, he'll tell you if he is). If that is the case, then I think it is legal to charge you the fee. However, if he is just some Joe off the street that is acting in place of the landlord - then the previous advice about getting them removed from the approved housing list was good -- report him. BTW, this is our 3rd time dealing with the housing office here in Ramstein, and we have never had any problems whatsoever. Maybe we just got lucky, but they have always been the most helpful office we have had to deal with in this area. 

Out of here! --- 17 years ago -

I always thought (i know that does not matter unless it is true) that they could only charge a Finders Fee if they advertised it off base. If they advertised it in the KA or something and that is where you found it. But, if you found it off the housing list or by other means, then there is no Finders Fee. We were desparate for a house when we moved here, we paid a fee of 1200 euro to a german man who said he represented the Land lord who lived far away. Well, 6 months in that DUMP and we moved ourselves to a new house. We did not mind paying it, until it occured to us that the place was a sh*t hole, and everytime the company put new people in the duplexs they got paid 1200 euro, nice living huh. We went to housing and they told us that the complaints were mounting, not just against the LL but the agent as well. So, just becareful. I would hate for anyone to lose money and not be happy in there new home. BTW, that was 3 years ago for us and we are so happy with the place we are in. I think your house really can make the difference in your tour here. I can only imagine if we stayed in that place, i think sometimes I would have packed up and went home. It was that bad! 

Rie Rie --- 17 years ago -

The house is brand new. The family living in it now are the first renters and they've been surprised with a short-notice PCS after only being here for 17 months! So, the house has been lived in for 17 months only. It has so many 'conveniences' and I love it. Supposedly, this landlord has been great other than this finder's fee, but he is a business man. I hear there are many who do this, but I will talk him down from this fee as it is too high. We are already signed up to take the house, I don't fear him taking it from under us or anything. I'll post the outcome here later. :) We'll see.... 

Annette --- 17 years ago -

I have never heard of landlord asking for a finders fee. I am German and the only one ever got money from me as in finders fee was a morgage person. I would call leagal just to see if that correct. 

Fran --- 17 years ago -

Sometimes they're also more some sort of janitors, that are hired to fix possible damages or like I said, maintain. Or a friend of the owner. Just ask him for his license. 

Mommy of 3 --- 17 years ago -

Almost 12,000 us dollars to move in?Wow must be some house! 

::Lara:: --- 17 years ago -

Don't pay it!!! We got tricked with that also. Just say you're not going to pay it, if he b****es, say you're moving out. Sad to say but Germans DO take advantage of unknowing americans here. 

Lars --- 17 years ago -

DONT PAY!!!! BE AWARE, HE JUST WANTS TO RIP YOU OFF! ALSO THE DEPOSIT HE IS SUPPOSED TO GIVE YOU BACK - FULLY!!! TELL HIM YOU WONT TAKE IT IF YOU HAVE TO PAY THE"FINDERS FEE"... THIS IS SO DISGUSTING PEOPLE DO THIS KINDA SH.T!!! RATHER WAIT A WHILE! GOOD LUCK LArs 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground