Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

spanking

who's talking here?

Kaylee 1
Jessica 12
paulaaaaaa 14
just a girl 1
Q.T. 1
Victoria 1
GaryKenyon 4
Out of here! 8
Sandra 3
JessicaC. 2
fran 2
Bob 4
Deborah! 4
ahgoodtimes 7
Ashley L. 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Out of here! --- 17 years ago -

know this is a hot button topic, and i do not want to start anything, but I am really upset. My sister and I were abused growing up dad and abandoned at 2/4 by our mom,by our we were beat with sticks, belts, switches, etc. Anyway, one thing that I always thought was that she and I would be smarter than to use questionable methods in discpline. I have no children yet, I am 30 and I have been struggeling to be sure I am ready to have kids. My sister has 3 girls and one on the way. She was on the phone with me today and she was yelling at the girls, one of them sprayed purfume, but would not fess up to it. She said "I am about to go get the belt". I started to cry and say how sad that makes me that she spanks with the belt,she stated that you can no longer spank with your hand, you will get arrested (dumbest thing I ever heard BTW) so she uses a belt. She hung up on me while I was crying. I guess it just breaks my heart. I used to look at my sister and think think that there was hope after abuse, that we could be good parents despite our pasts. Now I see her in a different light and wonder if I too will fall from grace when it comes to parenting. It was watching her as such a good mother that made me think I could be a mom one day too, and I admired her courage. Now, I just fear my own ability to parent. She is verbally harsh on her oldest too, calling her names, instigating her and belittling, all things my dad did out of frustration. Please help shed some light on this, how does this happen? I how can I help her without being instrusive? 

Victoria --- 17 years ago -

First off I want to start with how sorry I am that you are having to deal with something like this. Trying to discuss this topic with your sister will be absolutely difficult, because no matter who you are or who is doing the talking, if someone tries questioning your parenting skills you will become defensive. Personaly I think you should maybe just bring up the past to her, maybe remind her of how it felt...but don't push what you think on her. Cause no matter what she will raise the way she sees fit, and you don't want to lose the contact with her. Now for your sake (spelling???) on having children...you can be strong enough not to hit them. Yes it is a proven fact that children who come from abusive homes can have the same problems when it comes to their own children, you can over come this. My mother was abused, and I remember one time specifically I had did something wrong and she had me down in the corner pulling me up by my hair and getting ready to hit me...my dad walked in and stopped it, from that moment on she never physically disaplined me again. I don't know if my parents had a talk about it or what...now my dad did spank me, and I know a lot of people don't believe in this but I do. Not crazy spanks, but you know spanks on the bottom. What I meant by the story is maybe when you have children you can discuss your fears with your husband and kindly tell him to watch out for things like that, so if they surface he can talk to you about it. Kind of set your self up so if he brings it to your attention you won't get defensive about it. Maybe that's another way to go about it with your sister, talk to your bro in law about, see what he says (if you two can talk like that). I hope this makes sense to you, and it's not a bunch of rambling : ) 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

to be honest i was abused as well but I dont think spanking is abuse. Not if you do it the right way. It sounds like she may be reflecting some of the things done to y'all as children on her own but I think if you were to say anything at all she would get very angry with you. 

Ashley L. --- 17 years ago -

I was abused for 13 years by my step mother and not just spanked with switches etc, I was hit in the head with pans, forced to starve for days on end and nails dug into my arms the whole nine yards. People need to realize the differance between abuse and disciplining. I haven't hitten my child (hes also only 13 months old) and I don't plan on doing it but sometimes I think its ok..but not spank even a pop on the behind (lightly) will startle a kid enough to say oh shouldn't do that. But people trying to completely terrorize parenting is starting to get bad....you can't even speak sturnly at your child in public without someone calling social services...now I have seen the women that spank their kids because they do something kids always do and I always step in.. i really kinda biased..i think some times some cases some children its needed. I think people really do need to descipline their kids because children these days are really disrespectful (not all) 

Kaylee --- 17 years ago -

i think that spanking is okay as long as it is done the right way and not in an abusive way. different people discipline different ways though too 

Out of here! --- 17 years ago -

I will clarify, I beleive in spanking, as Paula said, "done correctly" (by hand, calm, etc). But what is "right" about using a belt on little girls? Even if she spanked lightly, I do not think a belt is the way to do it. What was done to me was abusive. Verbal and physical abuse was a daily part of life. My heart aches for you who have suffered, but you all give me hope as well. I know people say we do not have to trade stories, but, I am ok hearing your stories if you want to share. Victoria, I know that you are right. I will proabally lose my over this. Those of you who pray, please pray for her. her name is Krista. 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

I was spanked with a belt by my grandmother [who later adopted me ] but I dont see that as abuse. It wasn't very hard. And afterward she would ask me if I knew why she did it and we would discuss it and she would hug me and tell me she loves me. I believe thats the right way to do it. 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

I was burned with cigarettes, drug by my hair, slammed against random objects [all done by my mothers husband] but she knew and didnt do anything which was just as bad! I am ONLY sharing my story on here to help out others. I am afraid to post personal things on here but I felt it needed to be said 

Ashley L. --- 17 years ago -

yeah true abuse is physical and sometimes emotional...i have met kids that think they are whores, ugly, fat so on so forth because thats what their parents say to them and that is down right wrong. I think people need to recongnize that too as abuse because from experiance both hurt just as bad...and kids feel worthless and unloved either way. I just think some people really shouldn't have kids but all i can say for advice is to talk to your sister...if its really bad. I thinking spraying purfume isn't a bad enough deed to be spanked...(maybe if they dumped the whole bottle but even then) I think talking/time outs are good for first warning and if they do something again then they should be descipline properly... 

Jessica --- 17 years ago -

My kids get three warnings. If they don't listen, then they get a time out. Time outs usually work with ours, or me say "do you want me to tell your daddy?". LOL 

Jessica --- 17 years ago -

Paula, why are you afraid to post personal stuff on here? You shouldn't feel afraid. It seems like a nice community on here, for the most part. 

Out of here! --- 17 years ago -

Thanks Paula, You might be right. I guess I cannot look at discipline with objects as normal, because of my past. I do not want these babies to get hurt. To me, physical discpline is not to hurt to make associations, that is why I beleive you should only spank with your hand and not objectss. But, regardless, the problem I have is with her, and after all that was done to us that she could still pick up a belt and use it on her kids. Like me, I cannot even here the noise a belt makes or a whip crack without vomitting. I was tramatized and maybe that was good, maybe for me that means I will not do that to my children. I just thought she was on the same page as me. When we were little, she would beat me with object, hit me with dog chocker chains and throw objects. I know that she did it because she was mad, but I used to tell her I felt sorry for her kids (we were 9 and 11 maybe) that she would be as mean to them as she was to me. Since she has had her kids, I have not seen this part of her ever return, and she apologized tons to me for what she did. But, now, she has just changed, she is angry. She yells at the kids saying "I am going to beat you to a pulp" or threatens "whip their a$$'s" She screams at them. I am not there to help either. But thanks Paula for pointing that out. Just because it sounds harsh, doesn not mean that she is beating them with the belt, like I envisioned 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

I am sorry Susan. ((hugs)) Maybe she is just going through a rough time? Hopefully theyre just verbal threats even though those are awful as well. Jessica- it is a nice community but some people tend to get mad and use your personal info to make fun of and ridicule you. Lets hope that doesnt happen, here. 

Ashley L. --- 17 years ago -

still i think it will be wise to at least talk to her because she shouldn't be yelling at her kids like that (even though most of us are guilty of doing it at least once or will be in the future) Anger is a bad emotion to tango with....and it can turn into very bad outlets I know... 

Q.T. --- 17 years ago -

Susan, I am sure your not near your sister so the 1st part of this may not help at this time. I think counseling for you both on this issue might help. Secondly, it is sad that she might be frustrated and reverting to the same behavior that was used on you both as young children. Maybe there is something else that you might need to get to the bottom of before you talk with her about why she is spanking and talking to her children in that manner. I dont think spanking is wrond when you do it in the way that lets the child know your getting disciplined for something you did wrong and you talk with them afterwards. Maybe some books about the subject would help and you writing a letter to her about how you feel about what is going on. She probably feels like you may be judging her in a way. I wish you the best but you have to understand those are her children and she might not want you to butt in. Not trying to sound harsh. Good Luck! 

Out of here! --- 17 years ago -

 

Out of here! --- 17 years ago -

Yes, I think i will talk to, but not for a few days. She got very upset with me. Now we are close, (only because and ocean separates us) but we both a close with our dad now. Maybe he can help. He see his errors, and knows he made those because of the stress from my mom taking off and leaving him unprepared with 2 girls. He did the best he could, but she, she knows better. I will talk to my Dad and then to her. Thanks for all the advise. Paula, screw them. If they are that childish, screw them. This is real life and you have a lot to share :-) 

JessicaC. --- 17 years ago -

I feel really sad about what kind of things happened to some of you. Personally, I don't believe in spanking at all. I feel that you can talk to your child and let him/her know when they are doing something wrong. This is how I was raised and I have a very good relationship with my parents. I'm not saying that I think it's bad if you spank a child. Some ppl think they have spanking under control and they might spank harder than they think. I have seen this ( again..not saying any of you ladies would do this) This is just why..I don't like to spank. I use time outs or try talking. 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

Yep, everyone has different methods. I am not to sure of what I will be comfortable with, seeing as that my son is only almost 3 months old but who knows. 

Jessica --- 17 years ago -

Just so it's clear, there are two different Jessica's on here. 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

Yes, stokes and you. I am not positive if I have met you, though 

Jessica --- 17 years ago -

Not yet, but you are on my FB & Myspace page. 

Jessica --- 17 years ago -

I thought Jessica Stokes was jessicaS on here. 

JessicaC. --- 17 years ago -

Hmm..maybe I should try to change my name to jessica c. sorry about that. I didn't notice 

Jessica --- 17 years ago -

LOL It's ok. It's a very common name. 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

wtf! Im confused i thought jessica stokes was jessicaS 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

so are you jessica with the new baby? 

Jessica --- 17 years ago -

I thought she was jessicaS. I'm the Jessica with Chubbs, the chinchilla. I was Jessie on the KMC Underground. 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

Ooooh lmao thanks for clearing it up! 

Jessica --- 17 years ago -

You're welcome. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground