HA, have you guys ever seen Idiocracy???
what kind of jobs can they get when they are adults, and what kind of discipline will they have to go to college or have a career??
well ok i have to make a comment LOL...ok I am all for children learning differant ways..everyone is differant but there still needs to be guidelines...I mean alot of stuff we learn in school we need to know...but I would not let my kid take it in his own hands because we all know his day would consist of videogames etc...all for learning in fun ways but not for the child to choose what he or she studies...those guidelines are there for a reason.........
ok i just can't continue to wrap my head around this.............just baffles me ...no discipline no nothing.....how are they to work? this just reminds me of my SIL that sits at home sleeps all day and eats junk food and sit on the computer....*sigh* what the heck is the world coming too?
but I would not let my kid take it in his own hands because we all know his day would consist of videogames etc...
my kids too!! I wonder what kind of careers they could get? I am interested to hear more about them in the coming years and what they decide to do with themselves. I am all for homeschooling and do plan on homeschooling mine. I am way to scared to let them go to school past 5th grade. but i will let them decide. I just wont be doing the 'unschooling'
Very "smart" also when she said that if she ever wants to go to College, she´ll just pick up a book and start studying.
Really, you are going to teach yourself x years worth of school material?
And, the parents can´t really have any goals for their children. Even if you work as a cashier you need to know basic math, but with them, I doubt they even know what comes after Monday.
Letting a 7 year old make such a decision is just dumb. Not even immature or naive, just straight up dumb,and that´s what you are keeping your children with that decision-----dumb!
it really seems like lazy parenting, they can probably learn a trade, like hairdresser, basic car mechanic, things like that. but it would be extra hard because they obviously have no discipline. what about the more important things to consider. people raised thinking rules dont apply to them and ones that act on impulse are the ones who are in and out of jail their entire adult lives.
i am scared to let my kids to school but I would not ruin their lives basically. I have watched idiocracy..I mean my story is way differant...my dad was letting his wife beatme after 14 years i got sick of it,moved in with my mom, and well had issues in school my mom sends me back to my dad because he divorced this women but well he changed for the worse....he was violent put video tapes in front of my door etc, was called a whore every single day..i ran away was sent to my mom by social services after they investigated my dad (mind you this was at 16) well I started back up at school was doing well straight A's etc..then one day my principal calls me to his office to tell me I will not be able to graduate because my dad refuses to draw me out of school in cali...hired a lawyer everything...since i technically was still going to that school I got 6 months of tardies...so yeah thanks dad...my mom homeschools me and instead of worrying about my education she starts drinking ends up getting kicked out of her place...i had to take care of myself...everyday I resent my parents for them ruining my education life...people don't know how hard it is if you didn't go to school..now at almost 21 I have it underwraps but i still have people calling me stupid just because I had to do it a differant way and later in life all cause my parents..I would NEVER do that to my kids...at least I know as a parent IF THEY DID want to be a lawyer or whatever they would be ready and have the skills to acheive that goal.
It is proven that if you never learned discipline and all the tasks that go along with it, you won´t function in a regular working world.
Not even discipline, just having a SCHEDULE!!!
And also, they don´t have any social interaction with children their age at all, and THAT is going to be just as much of an issue for them later on in life, their lacking social skills.
I can not watch videos on this computer so I really did not get to see what was going on in this one, but did you know that Abraham Lincoln did not complete more than one year of formal education? He taught his self. Jane Austen was also taught in an unschooled way when her dad could no longer afford to send her to school =) You would be surprised how kids can grow if they are able to grasp the basics.
I am very interested in unschooling and there have been cases of unschoolers going to Ivy Leage schools and becoming very successful. There is always bad that goes with the good so you can not judge this method of learning by seeing a few people and how they handle it
=)
There might be people that handle it different, that´s why I specifically talked about that one particular family on there.
There´s always that one out of a million, but, Lincoln became President, so he MUST have had some goals he wanted to achieve.
And there are always "cases", but the vast majority is not going there and statistics are the norm.
I know several families that are homeschooling, and their children are all advanced. But unschooling, I don´t see a child benefiting from it.
that is just aweful ashml, Im sorry the ones that were supposed to protect and teach you did not :(
i am interested in where this is going, seeing a 5 min video probably wasnt enough for me to understand it, this is the first ive heard of it. I think homeschooling is great and I'm definitly considering doing that for my kids, in a disciplined way. but i see my oldest wanting to play video games all day if i gave him that kind of freedom!
donuts and letting them eat what they want?? hello childhood obesity! and no higene??? that should be considered neglect! not caring for their health! it is a health issue!
You know, about the unschooling subject, even if your child was to become something crafty, how is he or she going to know how much cloth he/she is going to need to sew a bag this and that size?
Or build anything without knowing math/algebra?
And how is the kid going to know how much to sell it for to be able to support itself?
i believe a child should be given a choice but to an extent (guidelines) I am all for fun learning etc but children NEED discipline and some kind of structure and guidance thats why parents exist..
You have to wonder if this started with parents who really were just too lazy to do the work of homeschooling.
These parents went to school so they were able to teach their kids ways to learn certain things. What about these kids' kids? Can these kids sit down and be able to teach their kids the fundementals the proper way? What if these kids don't want to know anything about math but their future children do? Are those kids out of luck since mom and dad don't know anything about a subject?
I mean I do believe it takes a a special kind of kid to really get it going. Not all kids/families can do it. The kids I have read stories about started to pick up on reading and basic math at a very young age and then were given endless supplies of books in whatever subject they chose. They picked lots and lots of hand on projects and their parents just followed the lesson plans the kids picked. There was a "school" kind of like this back where I am from, and "kindergartners" could pick zoology as a subject if he/she chose and they would not stop it, they would encourage anything the child wanted to learn.
A lot of unschoolers who go to college do keep portfolios of all of the work they themselves do, since it is hard to get in without having some kid of grade records... so it is not impossible, it just takes a very dedicated kid. I can tell ya if I had been allowed to study anything I wanted, I would have been a VERY VERY dedicated kid, I used to go to the library on my own in middle school are read non-fiction like there was no tomorrow. My dad taught me to build solar powered cars/robots/radios and taught me horticulture. I always wondered what else I would have learned if I was not wasting time filling my head with crap I would never need to know, and instead spent all my time learning things that actually interested me, maybe less people would settle for jobs they did not like if they could spend their whole young lives learning what they really wanted to learn =)
maybe not even homeschooling or unschooling but a style of school where the kids guided their teachers in the direction they wanted to learn, not the other way around!!
Robin, the kids in the video do nothing but watch TV and play video games all day long, have no tasks to do in the house, and they haven been living like that for seven years.
I know what you mean about the filling your head with stuff you´ll never need, but you never know if you´re not going to end up on "Who wants to be a millionaire?" to put it to use! HAHA
i said i can not see the video, so i am taking about unschooling in general. there are cases that are successful, this video really may be neglectful parents trying to pass it off as unschooling to feel better about themselves
=)