Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Reopening Search for Nazi War Criminals Good or Bad

who's talking here?

Mojo 7
Fran 6
angel2009 4
Bob 16
Rachel 1
Melinda 1
Kristen 13
CMS 5
Texan 9
DOGTRAINER 1
Everton 1
Cloudless 1
Wonderson 1
dipthong 1
Maniac4Europe 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Bob --- 15 years ago -

i read an article at:

http://www.foxnews.com/world/2011/10/05/hundreds-nazi-cases-reopened/

stating that they are going to reopen the search for nazi war criminals. the youngest of these people are in their 80s. this means that money that could be used for something more pressing will be spent looking for people who could very probably die before they are found. many of them are already probably dead.

the other side of this is they will be trying and convicting people for crimes that they have no evidence that they commited. all that is known is they worked at a specific camp.

after all this time it seems like this is more of a hate trial than war crimes trial.

i believe in justice and i believe what was done back then was entirely wrong. but i also believe this will prove to be a huge waste of both time and money and that if any of these people are caught and tried there will be innocent people put to death. this will lower us to the same level as the people this case is looking to bring to justice.

let's keep this at a calm discussion level. no need for name calling or random insults. 

dipthong --- 15 years ago -

It is a wild goose chase designed to waste more money. Even if someone did admit to being guilty, what would we do to punish such an old person? Take away his/her Geritol? 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

where will this money come from? 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

this is the german government chasing these people.

one thing i forgot to mention in the first post is the german taxpayers will be paying to look for this person, take care of him while he is on trial and then pay to keep him till he dies. even if the person is found guilty, germany doesn't have a death sentence.

the part that really bothers me is the fact that they are willing to spend all this money to find people that they have no evidence comitted any crime. 

Melinda --- 15 years ago -

I think they should just let it be. The ones they'd be looking for now were the ones who were just following orders (more than likely out of fear). They have probably spent their lives feeling guilty and trying to forget. As a Christian I believe God will judge them when that time comes. Let them live in peace until then. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

They are still finding people that were commanders and in key positions in the concentration camps.

I see both sides on this; on one hand, let sleeping dogs lie. On the other hand, entire family lines were completely eradicated by the genocide, and there are people alive who still remember this. Germany is still living under the shadow of the Halocaust, and I think this is an attempt to ensure all remaining parties involved are brought to task.

I firmly believe that a lot of them are still quite okay with what they did. Hitler would not have become so powerful if he did not have followers. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

since all the guards were ss members i don't think there was any fear or feelings of guilt. they were all brain washed and fulfilled their duties willingly.

as far as just following orders, yes they probably were but this is the type of thing they signed up in the ss to do, kill people no matter who or how. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Look at the villages surrounding the concentration camps. They KNEW what was going on, and did nothing. They let it happen. I feel like they are just as guilty. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Look at the villages surrounding the concentration camps. They KNEW what was going on, and did nothing. They let it happen. I feel like they are just as guilty. 


They talked about this when we toured Sachsenhausen. As stated in one of the prior posts that was surely due to fear also. Either way it was awful. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

I've googled this but couldn't find an answer.

Why were the railroads built to transport the Jewish people to concentration camps
never bombed or destroyed during WWII? 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

I don't know, good question. I know that one we went on is still used. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

the allies were worried that the nazis would figure out that we broke their code if we acted against the camps.

we knew about everything from intellence reports and from people who escaped the camps. some were able to provide detailed maps but we still did nothing. i honestly think the allies didn't act on the information because they didn't care.

i have read some accounts that state that there are those who feel that both churchill and roosevelt hated the jews even more than hitler. i've never been able to find a reliable source and i did a lot of research on this for a paper i did in college. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

Nevermind, found it. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

Bob, there was a thread about this before. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

i believe in justice and i believe what was done back then was entirely wrong. but i also believe this will prove to be a huge waste of both time and money and that if any of these people are caught and tried there will be innocent people put to death. this will lower us to the same level as the people this case is looking to bring to justice.

For a change in perspective, think about the money our government has spent, and will continue to spend, hunting down those associated with 9/11. Keeping in mind the total numbers of victims, what cost is too high? When is enough, enough? Rhetorical questions that I don't actually expect answered, but something to think about.

Oh yeah, and this definitely applies as well, especially to the recent murders of Al-Awlaqi and others:

the other side of this is they will be trying and convicting people for crimes that they have no evidence that they commited. 

Maniac4Europe --- 15 years ago -

I am probably in the minority here but I think it's worth it. I say, round them up and leave them all in a small 8x10 cell where they can rot for their remaining years. It's too bad Germany doesn't have the death penalty. I know I am a "bleeding liberal" but I do believe in the death penalty.

So let's do the next best thing...round 'em up and lock 'em up. And I don't care if they're 80ish, they had a part in the mass murder of MILLIONS of people and now it's time to pay the piper.

I think we're feeling a little too sympathetic for the wrong people. I just hope the poor souls that were tortured, starved, raped, humiliated and ultimately killed...I hope they're at peace. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

@maniac4europe, it has nothing to do with sympathy, i just think it's stupid to go after a bunch of people who are most likely dead by now. why waste the money? i could see the idea if it were even 10 years ago because the chances of finding more of them alive. if we were going to find that many of them we would have already succeeded.

the other main issue here is they have no evidence that any of these people did anything. yes, it's true that the "probably" did take part but we have no proof. proof is the basis for law. proving beyond a shadow of a doubt. all the cases would create nothing but doubt. this all points to an act of vengence instead of justice. 

Texan --- 15 years ago -

How much of this has to do with German guilt? That is a part of their history that would like to erase and try and do anything possible to distance themselves from.Do I think it should be done? If some one in my family was murdered and the murderer was never found but, knowing that the search continues ,would bring some comfort.the ones in hiding know this as well so they are stressed out and looking over their backs wondering,after all these years,when the hammer is gonna fall. 

Maniac4Europe --- 15 years ago -

Where's the line between justice and vengence? 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

My maternal grandmother's family escaped from Poland shortly before they would have been sent to a camp. Not all of the family was able to make it out. They tried to emigrate to the US. Sadly, at that time, the US was not taking anymore immigrants that were jewish. Thankfully, they were able to go to Canada where a few members of the family already were. Eventually, as Canadian citizens, they were able to move to the US and become citizens. The members of the family that did not make it out did not survive to be liberated from the camps. For those survivors who did make it out, they are also always looking over their shoulders. That kind of cruelty and torture is something that a person never forgets. I don't think it is wrong to continue to search for those who perpetrated these injustices, who were responsible for the deaths of millions. That is just me, though. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

i'd like to thank everyone for keeping this on a civil level. i understand and respect everyone's viewpoint.

i don't think this is something that really has a right or wrong answer. it's difficult to stay objective when such strong feelings are attached to a subject.

this subject has pros and cons on both sides, that's why i brought up the topic. i hope more people will decide to contribute. 

Texan --- 15 years ago -

This is what our board should be about,discussions and answers to questions.

Their really is not a right or wrong answer to this.I think to some,like CMS,who it personally touches,then "hell Yeah get the !@#$" some may see it as wasteful or vengeful,But the civility of the discussion is a breeze of fresh air here. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Even a broken clock is right twice a day! 

Maniac4Europe --- 15 years ago -

My maternal grandmother's family escaped from Poland shortly before they would have been sent to a camp. Not all of the family was able to make it out. They tried to emigrate to the US. Sadly, at that time, the US was not taking anymore immigrants that were jewish.

Whoa CMS, this hits really close to home for you.

So Bob, what are your thoughts of my earlier question? I know you think it's just vengence but I don't agree with that. EVERYONE deserves closure and justice. And not just talking about this but families who have to deal with murder victims, rape victims and so on...

Read this...

We're talking 2 decades...and people thought this guy would never get caught. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

maniac4europe, as i said before...when you go after someone with no evidence that he/she did anything wrong it's vengence. you want to find someone to put the blame on even if you can't prove the person did anything wrong.

i believe in justice for those who suffered through this but i'm very doubtful that anyone else will be found let alone tried.

as far as the person being caught after 2 decades, that's only 20 years and they had dna evidence linking the guy to the crime. it's been 66 years since the end of wwii and there is no evidence linking any of the remaining people to any crime which makes this a very different situation. 

Texan --- 15 years ago -

I understand what your saying Bob.I think they may have some new info from some old documents.I say they follow every lead they have to either declare the person innocent,dead or bring them to justice.I feel the same way about our death penalty,follow every shred of evidence before you end someones life.

I am not trying to argue with you,I may just be naive,but I don't think they would go through all of this with out some credible info,maybe info gleaned from the last guy.Who knows.

That being said I pray they do not prosocute any innocents if they do find someone.I hope the evidence is indefensible. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

texan, i keep going back to this portion of the article:

"It was the first time prosecutors were able to convict someone in a Nazi-era case without direct evidence that the suspect participated in a specific killing."

the key words there are "without direct evidence". i'm not a lawyer but in my mind without evidence you have no case. they will be prosecuting someone because somebody said he was there.

the other part is they think...let me say that again think there may be about 1000 of these people still alive. out of those they MIGHT be able to prosecute 40. this is a huge shot in the dark and it stinks of vengence as i keep saying.

you mentioned in an earlier post about german guilt, this is part of it. i believe another bigger part is international pressure. the germans have to activally persue this issue or the current government and young people will be accused of sympathising with the nazis.

i keep saying that i'm all for justice especially in this case but spending the time and money to go after somone who MIGHT have commited a crime but there's no evidence and MIGHT be alive, and MIGHT be healthy enough to stand trial...that sounds more like vengence.

i'd like to think the judicial system works better than that. i know in the states you can arrest someone for probable cause and maybe that's what they are doing in this case. i just hope that IF they do find anyone who can stand trial they don't end up convicting someone falsely because of spite.

if they do get the right people and it helps bring closure to families who suffered then it's worth it.

personally, i wouldn't want to take the chance an innocent person is put in prison just to ease my own pain. there are just too many ifs and no evidence.

oh, this isn't an argument, this is a discussion on a touchy subject. i like discussing things like this especially when people keep things at a civil level like has happened here. we will never all agree on this but it's good to look at the different points of view. 

Texan --- 15 years ago -

That part of the article is scary.could their interpretation of no direct evidence be the same as our Cicumstantial evidence.It all means no direct proof "BUT,it could have happened."That is supposed to sound like a lawyer talking to a jury.

I can see where German guilt would make them to hunt until they are all gone less look to be sypathetic but doesn't Israel already do that?why not share the info and let them continue the search.Sharing of info shows your not protecting anyone.Just a thought,why don't they work together.shared info shared cost shared credit.How better to deal with the shame and build a better outlook than to work with and help those you wronged. 

Texan --- 15 years ago -

sorry that was circumstantial 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -


oh, this isn't an argument, this is a discussion on a touchy subject


agreed and I can see both sides 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground