I don't think any of us will defend AAFES having the best prices or being there "for us, err profit". But lets look at some of the specific complaints you mentioned.
-They stop taking stamp cards at the food court and theater.
Most CONUS fast food establishments don't give you stamp cards anymore. In fact, the stamp program at Subway continued for years over here after it was demolished stateside.
-They mark down all clearance electronics over $200 from %25 off now its only %10 off.
Just because an item was returned but otherwise in perfect condition, what warranted 25% off? 10% off a $1100 laptop is still over $100 off, for what could of simply been opened but never used. Once again, I don't know of a CONUS store that offers automatic 25% off.
With that said, I did take advantage of this with a Kindle last year - box was opened but device was still brand new with the plastic wrap around the device in place and never taken off. 25% off simply because someone else ripped the box. Score!
-Their gas prices are priced at the most expensive U.S. average.
I gripe about this too, but there isn't much around it unfortunately. Overall, we still have an outstanding gas program. We typically have the cheapest gas in Europe (not that it's saying much), and unlike those in the UK, we can purchase gas at any ESSO station in the country. In the UK, the gas card is only available for "official travel" such as to/from work, and they claim to monitor what stations you use for abuse (so you can't fill up the tank during that family vacation to Scotland...).
And, there's always higher priced gas in the States. In the news currently is a downtown-LA gas station priced at $5.09/gallon.
Now, once again - not saying AAFES doesn't suck. But you do have to remember that they do have more difficulty than a typical Best Buy/Walmart store in the states - longer supply lines, being the only store to carry American items means huge demand that isn't always predicted, etc.
Think of it this way - years ago, AAFES was under fire because they only carried "crap" clothes and merchandise. So they branch out and offer sections ranging from Vera Bradley to Coach to high-end clothes. Now everyone complains because they cater to the "officer" crowd.
When you have to please a community of 50,000 at once, you won't ever be able to make everyone happy.
-They mark down all clearance electronics over $200 from %25 off now its only %10 off. I had something in my hand with the %25 sticker when they were changing them and she walked right up to me trying to sticker it... didn't happen... lol
I try to avoid that place at all cost and will continue to do so lol.
Do you really think that they will be able to make everybody happy? Considering how much business they get, I'm thinking there are probably quite a few happy customers.
I do remember when there were some really odd brands and the quality was horrible, kids clothes were awful and there was about 95% girls clothes, 5% boys clothes, especially for babies. It was horrible.
It has gotten a lot better. I don't care for a lot of their practices, but the organization as a whole needs an overhaul. The ordering manager is a stateside entity. They don't decide what gets ordered locally, it's ridiculous. WTF are we going to do with 3 or 4 aisles of 110v kitchen appliances?
-They stop taking stamp cards at the food court and theater.
True. However, if you use Military Star for your food court purchases, you get an automatic 10% off of your purchase. This is much simpler, and no stupid punch card has to be carried around.
I participated in the AAFES secret shopper program recently. Trust me, AAFES got crappy reviews, and deservedly so.
My wife pointed out that they also switch their prices from one BX to the next. Even if the BX's are right across the street, they will have a higher price at one and lower it at the other and then switch. The commissary also does the same thing.
During the holiday season we had a good laugh over a "clearance" item from $9.99 to the good ol' price of $9.99! They went through all that trouble to print out a piece of paper to tell you that you would save $0.00.
During the holiday season we had a good laugh over a "clearance" item from $9.99 to the good ol' price of $9.99! They went through all that trouble to print out a piece of paper to tell you that you would save $0.00.
This isn't an AAFES phenomenon. Read www.consumerist.com and you'll find this happen all over, especially at Target/Walmart. You'll also find people complaining about every issue we have with AAFES, but with "regular" stores.
Let's not even compare DeCA with AAFES. DeCA has much, much better prices than grocery stores in the U.S.
The commissary has some excellent deals. I sure wasn't complaining last week when the 24-pack of 20 ounce Coke Zero was on sale for $6.99 and the Lay's 45 singles variety pack was on sale for $5.
If you buy things like laundry detergent (as an example) from AAFES instead of DeCA, you'll see how much more AAFES charges.
By the way, the same case of Coke was on sale at AAFES for $18!
Why do people read more into something then what is said? I said the commissary also does the same thing. It's true, seen it myself. I didn't bash either place, I've just seen these things for myself and thought I would add on and let people make up their own minds.
Deca is great I agree. I got there pies for 5 cents after Holiday Season. Where else can you buy that. As for the gas it is still better then off base.
Not debating the merit of having U.S. goods easily available, they are good for that. It comes down to AAFES treating the Military community like just any other place, no more perks for serving with Uncle Scam.
Do they pay taxes on goods they sell, dont think so: The AAFES is immune from direct State taxation and State laws and regulations that would interfere with AR 2158/AFI 34211(I) 30 July 2008 1 AAFES performance of its Federal functions. Pursuant to Section 104, Title 4, United States Code (4 USC 104).
So in saying this, they get crap already at a discounted price but sell it to Servicemen at full retail price, thanks for nothing AAFES!
Oh and using your Star Card for food discount? pure profit for AAFES, you save 10% yet they make over 12% in interest over the long run.
Pure greed and treating Military customers like the hobos that walk into a Wal-Mart!
Oh and using your Star Card for food discount? pure profit for AAFES, you save 10% yet they make over 12% in interest over the long run.
Only if you are fiscally irresponsible and spend more than you can afford to pay. I've got no problem with saving 10% on my food purchases. Also 10% at the movie theaters.
Also 10% at the movie theaters. Oh well now Id rather spend way more money and go to the Kino where its peaceful, I about killed somebody the first and only time we went to the movies on base lol!
So in saying this, they get crap already at a discounted price but sell it to Servicemen at full retail price, thanks for nothing AAFES!
I'm confused. AAFES gets "crap" at the same price as any other store. By being immune from local tax, that doesn't lower the price they pay to the manufacturer- that is why "Walmart" will charge you the additional 5% or whatever the appropriate tax rate is for that area.
Example - Apple iGizmo (price/tax rate guesstimated)
Also lets remember that AAFES is charged by Congress to make a profit - not to necessarily give us a good deal.
From their corporate profile:
AAFES is charged with making a profit, but returns every cent of its earnings to customers. The only Congressionally appropriated money spent in AAFES comes in the form of utilities and transportation of merchandise to overseas exchanges and for military salaries. A nonappropriated fund activity (NAF) of the Department of Defense, AAFES funds 98% of its operating budget (civilian employee salaries, inventory investments, utilities and capital investments for equipment, vehicles and facilities) from the sale of merchandise, food and services to customers.
More than 70% of AAFES earnings are paid to Morale, Welfare and Recreation (MWR) Programs. In the past 10 years more than $1.93 billion has been contributed by AAFES to the Army and Air Force to spend on quality of life improvements for soldiers, airmen and their families--libraries, sports programs, swimming pools, youth activities, tickets and tour services, bowling centers, hobby shops, music programs, outdoor facilities and unit functions.
Yeah, I thought of that. MWR get the brunt of the money.
But, where or how is all that MWR money spent? In all of my duty stations, over the last 10 years, I have seen functions put together from MWR that looked liked they cost a couple of hundred bucks to put together, nothing that would justify almost 2 Billion dollars!
"How (and where) AAFES dividends are spent are left to the discretion of the services," he said.
Earnings also are used to build new stores or renovate existing facilities without expense to the federal government, AAFES said in a news release. Funding comes entirely from sales.
Earnings also are used to build new stores or renovate existing facilities without expense to the federal government, AAFES said in a news release. Funding comes entirely from sales.
Gee, just like every other private business. How special is that?
AAFES in reality is no different to any other retail selling outlet (other than the fact most retail outlets don't sell `end of line' & `discontinued' stock as their main product range). The mistake AAFES make is their claim to be `Supporting the soldier'. This, in my opinion is what causes their problem. With a statement saying they `support' their troops, people expect them to go further and be better. This is not the case (as it's not with the majority of retailers), AAFES, just like the other outlets don't care who they sell to, how much they sell for, and how you feel about it. They are there to make money, as a business should. They `go where you go' in order to maintain the captive market they hold (how else can you obtain US items immediately when stationed overseas)? When ever possible I purchase my items on line via Amazon, as the majority of the time they are cheaper, and I am given a greater choice. Until AAFES has any real competition it will continue to serve the soldier the way it currently does, and we all know AAFES has been given the monopoly of selling to the military. It will be interesting when AAFES take over from DECA at our commissaries - I imagine the German economy will receive quite a boost.
I remember a time when AAFES actually had competitive prices back in the early-mid 90's. I remember the gas always being significantly cheaper. I remember the food courts being of higher quality. I also remember a time when you could find a men's sized small or medium in just about anything. Now it's all XL-XXXL. So apparently not only have people gotten fatter, but we've also become consumers of convenience; we accept higher prices out of convenience instead of being good consumers and going elsewhere. The commissary used to be a great place especially for buying beef. Now I no longer use the commissary because the beef is putrid. Next time you have a chance, buy a pound of German beef and a pound of Commissary beef and smell them side by side raw, you'll see what I'm talking about, the meat is bad, the results are repeatable for the past several years.
All and all ever since BRAC the military has been slowly converted to a commercial operation instead of a military operation.