Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Poll: What is the appropriate age?

who's talking here?

VeggieGirl 4
AshleyH 3
Gomez 13
Lara 10
Toni 5
justdawn 3
Karen 1
JessicaS 1
TabbyCat 4
jamieR 3
Nikki 1
Deborah 1
paulaaaaaa 8
LAJA 1
Angela 3
geologic 1
Amber 3
Tanya 1
Tea Baby 1
Amanda 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

TabbyCat --- 17 years ago -

for "the talk"? i didnt have "the talk" with my oldest until she was about 13ish. but seems my youngest one who is 9 is already asking! for one, she happen to walk in while oprah was on and that little 10 year old was getting the talk on natl tv! second, she says all the kids at school are talking about "things". so, i have my own thoughts about this and that is that maybe ill tell her some of it but not alllllll of it?? its not that i mind having the talk but i just feel she is a bit young for all THAT info. maybe some, but not all. what do you guys think????? what is the appropriate age and how much to tell???? 

Toni --- 17 years ago -

i never had "the talk" when i was younger lol 

justdawn --- 17 years ago -

Tabby, I would just sit her down and answer any question she asks you. Don't volunteer anything...just tell her what she wants to know. I think that your honesty will keep the lines of communication open which (as you are well aware) will be a Good Thing, later;) 

TabbyCat --- 17 years ago -

thats a good idea, thanks justdawn. 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

TabbyCat: I agree with Toni I didn't but then again my mom didn't either. I had Health Ed in public school. I think since she's asking maybe you should go with approach of "What do you know about 'things'?" It could be just period stuff you never know. I know a girl told me about it whne I was in 3rd grade about her age range. Depending on what she knows I think you should really be honest with her and spill the beans. Like you said maybe not tell her ALL of it but what she's curious about. Then from there you just tell her she can ask you those 'things' because she might not get the correct or accurate info. ex: my hubby (who went to private school and didn't get the "talk")thought you couldn't get prego if it as your first time (virgin). I knew you could because I was educated in that area. And 9 months later there was my proof. We all make our own choices just my opinion. Good Luck! 

justdawn --- 17 years ago -

Sure thang:) 

JessicaS --- 17 years ago -

My daughter is 9 and in 4th grade, and I am so not looking forward to that. I was wondering the same thing when I saw the girl on Oprah. 

geologic --- 17 years ago -

I agree with JUSTDAWN. Let her ask the questions and you answer truthfully and to the best of your knowledge. ~~I would rather have had the talk from my parents instead of finding things out on my own and then getting the third degree that my parents gave me. ~~ At 9yo they are at the age to hear about most of the birds and the bee's but may want to skip some till she is older. Beter to have a heart to heart then something happen down the road, ya know?? 

Karen --- 17 years ago -

my daughter is 12 and what I have learned is this...she started her period at 11. Her friends started anywhere from age 9 to 12. Seems like nowadays the girls are starting earlier than we did. Waiting until 13 might be a little late. Just remember a girl can ovulate and get pregnant before she ever has her first cycle. I would err on the side of caution and discuss it. Chances are she knows a lot more than you think. TV doesn't leave a whole lot to the imagination, and kids are "active" much younger than when we were little. Just my 2 cents... 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

that episode of Oprah was super helpful for me, I will def. remember those things when mine gets older! haha 

TabbyCat --- 17 years ago -

yeah i thought the talk on oprah was well put. i just was kinda "eh" about the age. but it is very true that tv doesnt leave much to the imagination, i dont know how many times i have to change the channel sometimes b/c shes in the room and i didnt know a sceny scene was coming up. i know shes going to get her period sooner than the oldest one did b/c she already has boobs (well buds) lol i think ive really got it coming with my youngest, she is so different than the oldest. eh.... 

justdawn --- 17 years ago -

My oldest daughter started in 5th grade and was asking questions by 3rd. I think we would be shocked at what our kids know! I would rather them hear all of the sordid details from me than someone else. 

Gomez --- 17 years ago -

That girl was way to mature for her own good. That girl needs to be at a playground instead of interviewing and giving advice about sex to grown up. Times are different then we were younger. Also, being overseas is different than being stateside. If you really know your child, then you will know when the time is right. 

Angela --- 17 years ago -

My oldest daughter started in 5th grade Yeah, that was about the same time I started. A year before I had to find out because when I went to a Doc appointment he asked if I started my "period" and I had this confused look on my face. My mom said "no" very quickly. Then I tried to ask about it and she didn't want to talk. I think it's because she only knew hear say and didn't want to miss inform me. Funny enought she came with me when the school had our 'talk' with the youngsters (4th grade).(I knew girls in 3rd grade who know about the period) 

Tea Baby --- 17 years ago -

ok... let me start by saying I never got "the talk" either... my mom felt if she never told me about it I would never know... I started having sex at 14, and other than what I heard around school and stuff, I didn't get the good and bad of it. I also had other things happen to me at younger ages so, I know this won't be what other people decide to do, but this is what my mentality is for "the talk" I believe all kids, no matter the age, should be talked to about certain things. My 2 year old already knows that no one should touch his "pee pee". When I change him, he cleans himself, and in the tub, he washes himself. I do this because I want to make sure that if ANYTHING ever happens to him, he knows that it is wrong and will hopefully tell someone... he also has the habit of playing with it. I know its normal for them to be curious of it at this age, so I tell him that it's not nice to play with it in front of people and if he wants to then he needs to go to his room. I do that because I don't want him to think its not okay or gross, just that he should do it in private and not for everyone to see... And as he gets older we will add a little more that I think would be age appropriate for him... And when it comes to talking about "the birds and bees" my boys will not only have a talk with their dad, I will talk to them too. I think all kids, when possible, should get both sides versions of sex. I think it would be healthy for my boys to know what their dad thinks and what their mom thinks. But, like I said, I know that there aren't going to be too many people who feel this way, but thats how I am planning to do it myself... 

VeggieGirl --- 17 years ago -

My mom never had the talk with me. In 5th grade we had a puberty education at the catholic school I was at. My stepmom ended up giving me a bunch of books the summer after 5th grade but I was really embarassed and uncomfortable talking about those kinds of things with grownups. I had no idea when to have the talk but had to have one recently with my soon to be 7 yr old daughter and believe me, I was hyperventilating! She was asking questions and had some friends who wanted to play house with what I would consider adult themes. My daughter is in 1st grade and one of her friends was a kindergartener... I was sooo upset so I started doing research. I polled a bunch of friends to see when they had the talk and it turned out, for me, that about half and half had already talked to their kids by the time they were 6/7. I bought some books and borrowed some other from the library. One was called "From Diapers to Dating" and it explains how and what to discuss with your child at age appropriate levels and was at the Bookmark. The other that I read to her was "It's not the Stork!". I borrowed that one from the library. I read through them myself first and was reading the stork book while getting a bowl of cereal one morning and when i read the part about the penis entering the vagina I dropped the box of cerreal all over the floor! LOL! I couldn't imagine telling my daughter that! I was super nervous so I read the book to her in parts. I let her ask any questions she had even though it was sometimes hard for me. I feel that I did the right thing for my family and I think that by talking to her at a young age it might help her feel more comfortable coming to me in the future with any questions rather than just believing what other kids on the playground have to say. We have also discussed that this is not something we talk about at school and if kids ask her questions or try to tell her things she needs to tell them that those are things you need to discuss with your mom or dad. 

VeggieGirl --- 17 years ago -

Another things that happened with my daughter is that she came home a month or so ago telling me she was a mistake because I was not married to her daddy when she was born. :( I was so upset and hurt that another kid would tell her that! I told her that she was a surprise but never a mistake! I think it's important to tell kids that sex happens between adults who love eachother and not stress that only people who are married do it. Yes of course it would be nice if that was the case but the truth is that many, many children are born out of wedlock. You can explain that those are your beliefs but don't set it up so that your kids go back to school asking other kids if their parents are married and telling them they are a mistake if they aren't/weren't. :( Oh and I asked my stepmom at what age she started telling my step and half brothers & sisters. She said they always knew and you know what... they started having sex a lot later than me and my brother who were raised by my mom. Don't know if having the talk early really helped but it was interesting to see how different we grew up to be since we really had no relationship from the time I was 6th grade until now. 

LAJA --- 17 years ago -

I have three daughters. My mother never told me anything about the birds and the bees. When i started my P my mother told me that is what I will have from now on every month. I, at first, thought I was going to die. When my girlfriend started her P she thought she was pregnant. Never had a boyfriend befor. I went to a catholic school with nuns,our sex education was a prist came with a record and played it in class. That was the reason why made sure my daughters were educated. just answer what she asked you. 

Lara --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Amber --- 17 years ago -

I agree with justdawn. I think you should answer anything she asks and make it as comfortable as possible for her. If she feels comfortable having this talk with you she may feel more comfortable to tell you "other things" in the future. Thats how my mom and I were and still are. We're very close because of it. 

Gomez --- 17 years ago -

Lara, As the saying goes. @ssholes are like opinions. Everybody has one. Including this one. 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

Gosh Gomez, you need to pull the stick out of your butt and quit harassing everyone you possibly can! Just leave it alone! 

Gomez --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Amber --- 17 years ago -

Hey Paula, go f*ck yourself. I didn't say sh1t to anyone on this topic That was a bit harsh =[ 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

hah its okay amber, i think hes just bored. you know how we get when we are bored! 

Gomez --- 17 years ago -

Amber, Not to me. Do you want in on this deal? It goes way back and not just with me. I have played nice with here and others. I do not make catty comments or make silly comments just for the hell of it. I am just honest with my questions, answers, advice and comments. I can not be silly here as it will and has been misunderstood. I do not hold a grudge. I just have a half way decent memory on how people treat me. Also, I do not play well when someone bad mouths about me and/or my profession out in the open. 

Amber --- 17 years ago -

I do not hold a grudge. I just have a half way decent memory on how people treat me. Also, I do not play well when someone bad mouths about me and/or my profession out in the open. So I'm guessing there is more to this than just this thread...gotcha. 

Tanya --- 17 years ago -

la la la la la :~D Ne-waaaaays back 2 the topic/thread!! I had the *TALK* dun dun dun w/my son when he wuz 7 1/2 yrs old...Cuz he came home 1 day & asked tons of questions...Cuz his friends were talking all about it...& he didn't ask just 1 or 2 ?'s it wuz like he had written them down haha So just sit down w/ur child & allow ur daughter/son ask ne-& all ??'s & u answer as honestly as possible...Like many peeps on here have said, *Don't tell, just listen & answer*...Ok mayb peeps haven't said that, but its similiar 2 what sum have said (I think...then again its bad 2 think, Well 4 me that is!!) LoL :~}} 

Gomez --- 17 years ago -

Amber, Thank you for understanding. I really try not to be mean. I have always been misunderstood. When that happens, they get one free pass maybe 2 or 3. 

paulaaaaaa --- 17 years ago -

okay I cant think of one thing i did wrong to you in the past gomez, but if you have a problem with me i prefer you dont address it in a public forum. Thanks. And I dont know what youre talking about with the whole it goes way back comment. Weird. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground