Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Doctors...what do they know?

who's talking here?

VeggieGirl 1
Rosa 1
Jacki 1
Amanda 1
just a girl 1
Mama 4
Wendy 2
Tonya 1
GaryKenyon 1
S 3
JessicaC. 2
Gary 2
fran 1
Bob 2
PapaSmurf 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

S --- 17 years ago -

So I'm sitting at my desk enjoying my coffee looking thru Yahoo news and my phone rings. My sister in law is calling me crying. My brother and her are stationed at Ramstein. She went to the Dr. for a pap and to ask the Dr. questions about fertility. Apparenty the Lt. who "helped" her out was also very rude and unprofessional. My sister in law we call her KiKi, is 5'7 190lbs. She's a big girl but she's not obese however she is over weight. She said the dr. was telling her that her weight could be affecting her fertility blah blah blah same stuff we googled the other day. Well she asked the doc if he could refer her to a nutritionist and the Doc said "sure, 185 is a huge mountain to climb to get to your goal weight, I'll get you an appt at the HAWC tomorrow." Kiki has a job interview tomorrow here at the landstuhl hospital. I referred her to HR and they have a position for her. She told the Doc. about the interview and asked for a later time. He replied " kirsten stop making excuses for yourself, it's time you take responsiblity for your weight, we both know you didnt gain all that weight over night. Your parents pointed you down the wrong path. wouldn't you like to look at yourself in the mirror and be happy? not want to feel ashamed of it all?" She said she held back her tears but she was completely shocked and felt belittled. She's a nice 19 yr old girl who doesn't need to feel bad about herself. She's cried because she didn't think she looked bad but the doctor made her feel like she was at a point where it was almost impossible to do anything on her own. It made me so angry knowing he hurt her like that. She refused to give me his name, but she got off the ph still crying thinking she's looked at herself being 5'7 190 as not too bad and now she feels like everyone sees her as the Doc did....i know the Doc was doing his job, but he didn't have to be cold about it. I'm 5'9 148 i have rolls and i work out regularly...if someone called me fat it'd still hurt eventhough I'm ok with how i look. Ugh! I hate weight issues. It's like no one can be healthy unless their running and eating celery all day everyday.  

JessicaC. --- 17 years ago -

Wow..that was really rude of him. He could have been nice about it. I think he just went way to far. I guess some people just never really think about how there actions can hurt others. Not everyone can have a body like some model! 

S --- 17 years ago -

yea, she was seriously hurt...i called her back and she didnt want to talk about it...she said she was planning on going to breakfast at JR rockers but after what he said she couldnt bare looking at food. If he thinks shes fat then fine...so be it but say it in a respectful manner. he was way out of line. we're real women not celebrities with $$ who can afford trainers, personal chefs, etc. 

PapaSmurf --- 17 years ago -

Advise her to talk to the patient advocate at the hospital. If that is what was said to her she appears to have a valid complaint about her treatment by the Lt. If she fails to say anything about how she was treated, chances are the Lt. will continue to treat patients/persons the same as he treated your SIL. His behavior needs to change! 

JessicaC. --- 17 years ago -

I agree with papasmurf..she should do something about it. He was way out of line and someone should stop him. 

S --- 17 years ago -

Yea, I told her she should but shes reluctant to talk to about it...she doesn't even want my brother to find out. I'm seeing her at dinner. I'm def. going to try and get her to complain, but i don't want to push her either if she doesn't feel comfortable. 

Mama --- 17 years ago -

S, wow that was horrible what was said to her. I am much more overweight than I used to be. I'm hard enough on myself about that, let alone, if a Dr. would have been so rude to me and said what he said to your SIL. My cholesterol and other blood work is all really good, except my HDLs need to come up. All a Dr. has said to me, and in a respectful way, is that "HDLs can be raised by exercise". I appreciated that that's all the Dr. said to me. I KNOW I am more overweight than I used to be. And I KNOW I need to change that. I certainly don't need a Dr. preaching to me about it and belittling me. I can't imagine what those kind of comments could do to someone's self-esteem. I am sooo sorry for what happened to your SIL. PLEASE try to convince her to file a complaint about him. Maybe if she thinks about how much it hurt her feelings, she wouldn't want the rest of us to have to go through that same pain if we got that same a**hole Dr. Good luck! 

Bob --- 17 years ago -

S...first, i am definately not siding with the doctor. second, i am not judging your sister in law in any way so please do not take my comments the wrong way. your perception of your sister in law's weight is incorrect. the following chart shows the recommended weight for both males and females: http://ccrf.hhs.gov/ccrf/HTWT.htm#FEMALES according to this chart your sister in law is obese and this can affect many different things. take it from a person who knows. i've struggled with obesity for years. the doctor was right about weight affecting fertility, here is a just one web site that addresses the connection between being overweight and infertility: http://www.gynob.com/obesovul.htm i just want to stress that i DO NOT agree with the way the doctor handled the situation. military doctors are some of the rudest people you will run into especially if you are not the military member. i urge you to convince your sister in law to consider the possibility that her weight may be a factor in her struggles. it would be a shame for a person to miss out on the joy of children just because some military doctor is an idiot. i know this post will result in a lot of negative replies but i believe you sister in law really needs to consider the possibility that the doctor could be correct. i also hope she will be able to overcome the unprofessional, ignorant, and inhumane manner in which the doctor treated her. please believe me, i am on her side. i've incountered many rude, unprofessional military doctors and i really do know how hurtful it can be. 

Mama --- 17 years ago -

Yes, weight does effect fertility. I have PolyCystic Ovarian Syndrome, which makes it harder to lose weight and makes it difficult to conceive. I was thankful to be blessed with my son. But I know many other people that struggle with infertility, some of which is weight-related. However, I don't agree with the BMI index for our height (5'8")...I think it is by far unrealistic to consider someone overweight if they are 165 pounds and 5'8" (the BMI cut off is 164 for that height)...I just think that's crazy for women to go off of that chart. However, like Bob said, the weight can be effecting things. The Dr. absolutely had NO right to address it the way he did with her though. I definitely agree that the military Drs. are by far the most polite and well-mannered Drs. I have met before. I wish your SIL much luck! 

Rosa --- 17 years ago -

off topic : why is S in the Ice Box ? 

fran --- 17 years ago -

Doctors are weird. When I was pregnant my fat doctor told me I was getting too fat. 

Mama --- 17 years ago -

Rosa, I don't know. I hadn't even noticed. I don't even remember S saying anything for the ice box. Maybe I missed something! 

Tonya --- 17 years ago -

She called me the c word and a fn b.Thats why shes in the ice box. 

Amanda --- 17 years ago -

S, have her feel out an ice card. You can do it online and you can do it anonymously. I'm sorry that he was so rude. Some doctors are just rude like that and don't care. I have heard of more than 1 person tell me that a doctor called them fat. It doesn't matter if they really are or not, the doctor doesn't care! 

Mama --- 17 years ago -

ohhh Tonya, I definitely missed THAT post! I see. Amanda, yes that's a good idea to do it anonymously...that way she won't get nervous or embarrassed having to tell someone in person. 

Wendy --- 17 years ago -

Hi There S I am really sorry about what happened to your SIL. Bob not to be mean (I know people say that before they are about to be mean, but I really don't mean to be) those charts are so far off. They want us all to be bean polls for a healthy woman with muscles you could never weigh within the measures of the chart. I think each person knows when they get to the good weight each person same weight and height will differ. I know being a person who use to be over 200lbs that yes weight can be a factor of infertility, but it sounds like he didn't even bother to do a work up of your SIL he looked and her and made a judgment about her weight being the reason she cannot conceive. He is her Dr. Not God and he never should have spoken to her in that manner. Everyone is correct he will continue to belittle people until someone puts him in his place. He had no right to treat her like that. I really hope she puts in a complaint. She is 19 years old and she still has a while to have a baby. I really hope she will consider taking off some pounds before she gets pregnant because with each baby adds more weight. I am now just close to my goal weight when I look back at my pregnancy pictures... I can't even tell I was pregnant which kind of makes me sad. It is a wonderful experience and I wish for her to enjoy it to her fullest and maybe if she focuses on losing weight instead of getting pregnant she will get pregnant and she won't need that mean old doctors help anyways. I wish her the best! 

GaryKenyon --- 17 years ago -

Sometimes the truth can be taken as being rude. 

Wendy --- 17 years ago -

Gald to see you back Gary I would say the truth hurts. \\ The doctor was plain rude! 

Gary --- 17 years ago -

First, unless this guy was Navy, there aren't any doctors at Landstuhl that are Lieutenants -- sounds like she was talking to either a PA or a nurse. Second, If that is the exact statements that the person made, then I don't see anything rude about it. He was direct, truthful, and it sounded very caring, (although how something sounded is hard to tell just reading the words.) When she tried to make excuses and back out, he applied a little "tough love" and "shocked" her out of her complacency. It wasn't belittling, it was truthful. The fact that she decided to skip her trip to Johnny Rockets was her first step in the right direction. Tell her to keep it up. :-) Unfortunately, most people don't want to hear the truth, they just want their ears tickled, and when they don't hear what they want to hear, they cry and complain until they find someone to tell them what they want to hear. For instance, my father is 5'11" and he weighs about 265 -- that's fat in anyone's book. Unfortunately, he went from 200 (slightly overweight) to almost 300 (quite obese) over time, and every time he saw his doctor, the doc said he was the "picture of health". It was only after he started experiencing life-threatening health problems that the doc suggested that it might be weight related. By this time he was quite obese and has struggled with weight loss for over 10 years now. I really wish he had had a doc like your sister has, who would have told him the truth when he was younger, instead of telling him what he wanted to hear. Neither I nor my mom could convince him to lose weight as long as the doc was telling him that his weight was OK. Sounds like your sister has a good doc. She can respond the right way, and do herself a favor, or she can go find another doc to tickle her ears. Either way, the doc should be praised for having the nerve to say what needed to be said. 

just a girl --- 17 years ago -

i have a good friend who was around the same wieght/hieght. her dr. was very blunt, he told her she was very over wieght and if she did not do something now she was going to die. it shocked her into really looking at herself. the next day she started walking, every day walking a lot. then running and running. now she runs marathons i mean whole marathons. she would have already ran 13 mi. as i was leaving for work at 8 am. if her dr. had not been so blunt, she may just have died due to wieght problems. 

Bob --- 17 years ago -

first let me say i'm surprise i haven't be raked over the coals for my comments. i agree with gary that sometimes it takes some very blunt comments to get people to realize a change is necessary. i didn't have to suffer that but i didn't realize how far i let myself go till i saw a picture of myself at an angle that showed how fat i really was. it's not difficult to fool yourself. as far as the one comment made about doctors expecting people to be bean poles, that's a comment that is usually made by a person who is at least a little overweight. i come from a family of large people and i can promise you that none of us will ever be bean poles but that doesn't mean that we should let ourselves go either. an great example of a person who tries to sugar coat her situation is my sister. she's convinced herself that everything is ok for so long and besides she's cute as far as she's concerned that she can't sit in a normal chair with arms anymore. with the history of heart and blood pressure problems in our family she will not live to be 50. i don't mean to sound rude, remember i'm fighting the same battle but sometimes people need to take off the rose colored glasses and face reality. but i must stress again that that doesn't mean that anyone should make rude comments to you. hurting someone is not the way to help them. blunt is blunt, rude is rude and it is always wrong. 

Jacki --- 17 years ago -

Bob, i dont think you got raked over the coals because your comment was true and honest without being hurtful. i think we all agree that it was fine for the doctor to tell her she was over weight and that might be causing her problems and that they needed to work on it. But he said some things that were rude which you also agreed to. "wouldn't you like to look at yourself in the mirror and be happy? not want to feel ashamed of it all?" That is the part that got me. He is telling her to be ashamed and such... yes she needs to work on her weight but it is not his place to make her feel ashamed or ugly. which is what he did. which, (gary) was more than the truth, it was just being hurtful. 

Gary --- 17 years ago -

Jacki, I guess without having been there, it is hard to say. In my mind, that sounds pretty mild. A hurtful thing to say would be, "You should be ashamed when you look in the mirror!" or "How can you be happy when you are so fat?!?" Putting it like he did, probably made some false assumptions, but it wasn't as harsh as he could have been. And it doesn't seem to me that he was intentionally being hurtful. He was probably just being his usual self (most guys are ogres when it comes to figuring out women's sensitivities) - but in his mind he was being very nice. Most medical people don't like bringing this stuff up with their patients, for this very reason. Put yourself in the doctor's shoes for a second. You have a young girl with her whole life ahead of her that is starting to have medical problems because of a weight problem that she refuses to acknowledge. How would you handle it? If you didn't care, you just wouldn't say anything. But you do care, so you have to say something -- as awkward as it may be and knowing you'll probably end up hurting her feelings, you still have to say something.... Hopefully she gets over her hangups and takes the medical advice, regardless of how well it was delivered. 

VeggieGirl --- 17 years ago -

I'd like to know what the HAWC had to say. Do they have special fitness and counseling programs for the overweight or do they just tell you that you should eat this and not that? I think people know what they shouldn't be eating, it's finding the power to control portions and cravings that at times seems impossible to control. 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground