So a friend of mine just bought a dog off of RYS today. She paid for the dog in full has all his papers etc. only thing is they haven't gotten the dog transfered into their name at the vet. Anyway the people called her tonight saying they want their dog back, and the lady hasn't stopped crying since she left their house and sold the dog. My question to you is what would you do in this situation. Give the dog back or keep him??!
Why did they get rid of the dog in the first place?
If they are ABLE to have the dog and just got rid of him just b/c then of course I would not give him back.
If they can't have the dog or are moving or something I wouldn't give it back either b/c he will just go to ANOTHER family.
So most likely I would keep him.
Perhaps there is different reason they got rid of him though?
Oh wow, that's a really tough situation, and ridiculously unfair of the previous owners to do that. They should have made sure that they were ready to let go of the dog before posting it for sale. Wow, is all I can think of at the moment. I'm not really sure what to do. How does your friend feel about all this?
Gosh, a hard one...
I suppose it depends on why they gave the dog up and also if there are kids involved, on either side...
If the family who gave the dog away had kids, I'd give the dog back out of goodwill towards the children rather than the previous owners...if I was the one with the kids and had just introduced the new dog to them, I'd say sorry we are keeping it.
If the reasons they gave the dog away were lack of time to look after it, or moving...that wont change and id say sorry we are keeping it.
Tricky one, i geuss it depends on all the details.
I'd keep it. They sold it. They should have thought through their decision more thoroughly. They wanted to sell it for reason. Who's to say that if your friend gives it back that they won't sell it again to someone else in a week or two.
Maybe they want MORE money for the dog. Maybe they got another offer for the dog and are trying to sell it to someone else. I wouldnt do it. Id keep the dog. they OBVIOUSLY had SOME reason to get rid of it. What has changed?
They were re-homing him because they were moving from a huge house off base in to a stairwell on base. And she thought it would be too overwhelming. I personally thinking she's putting her own emotions in front of the dogs well-being, but whatever.
Both sides have kids.
My friend is confused by the situation. She thinks if she doesn't give it back she's being a bad person. But their whole family is in love with the dog and she doesn't want to break her kids' heart. She's torn. She said she feels like if she doesn't give him back Karma will come back to her some how. I tried to tell her the family should've been prepared for this though and none of it is her fault and she should keep the dog. It's just a hard place to be in :(
She was thinking money could be the culprit as well. They paid 500euro for him but they told her they paid 700euro so she said maybe they though they could have gotten more or something. My friend has another dog too and she mentioned something about how the dog sleeps in the kennel at night and said they (the people selling the dog) had got upset about that and said well your not going to put our dog in the kennel are you? So she thinks maybe they didn't like her or something? But in that case they never should've taken her money and sold her the dog. IDK lol
They made their decision by taking your friends money. deal is done. i still would keep it. If they really loved the dog that much they woudln't have sold it in the first place, imo.
Wow, that's just ridiculous that they are putting your friend in this situation. I mean they should have made sure that they were 100% positive that they wanted to get rid of the dog before posting it, and def. before they actually got rid of it. I would keep the dog. Talk about Karma, it's not your friend that should worry about that it's the previous owners for putting her in this situation. Making her feel like the bad person.
Oh and as for your friends dog being crate trained, there are a TON of benefits on crate training a dog, and it's not like she's being cruel. Tell the previous owners to look up the benefits. All the trainers that I have encountered for my dog said the same thing about crates. I understand that it's not for everyone or every dog, but its not a bad thing at all. That's all I have to say about that lol.
UPDATE: Her husband is at work until late tonight (which she told the guy) and she was planning to let her husband talk to him about it (which she also told the guy) So she stopped answering his calls and he just showed up at her house with the money saying he needed the dog back. CRAZY!
Though your friend may have an issue getting the microchip info switched over. I know that I did. When I got our dog, I renamed him and his previous owners apparently didn't like that and wouldn't respond to my emails or phone calls when I needed their signature to transfer over my dog's microchip. The vet told me even though I had all the paperwork for my dog I still needed that signature to being him into the vet. Well long story short apparently when you chip your animal you also have to log onto the website and enter your personal information. Well the previous owners never did that and I was able to take my dog's microchip number and set up the account myself, and then I didn't need their signature. Hopefully they will cooperate with your friend if she decides to keep the dog. If not tell her to look into that.
Angel- I get where you are coming from but my thoughts keep going to the fact that if she was really heart broken she wouldn't have given the dog up in the first place.
Emily- WOW!!! REALLY? Oh my gosh! What did your friend do??? I wouldn't give it back now. These people seem kinda crazy!
he just showed up at her house with the money saying he needed the dog back. CRAZY!
So this guy showed up KNOWING her husband was not there? Maybe he thought he could bully her into giving the dog back. What a bunch of CRAZIES!!!
if she was really heart broken she wouldn't have given the dog up in the first place.
AGREE!!!
I'm gonna play bad guy here....
The family that sold the dog did not decide just like that to sell the dog. They did not just find out they were moving...they have known for at LEAST a week or perhaps more...that gave them PLENTY of time to talk about this decision they were making. They talked about what they were doing and agreed on it...1505 you decide to seel that dog, 1520 someone agrees to buy the dog 1545 you want the dog back...pump your brakes...there was a monetary transaction that took place, the dog now has a new home. Sorry...you should have thought about that OUT and OUT before you decided to sell the dog...sell your clothes and jewelry....LOL
i don't think the paperwork for the transfer of the chip is a problem like Just Lauren said. this information is just to be able to track the owners if the dog gets out. i'm not sure what i would do in this situation. this basically fits into the category of thinking things through completely BEFORE you do something. now you have two families in a bad situation.
Bob- have you ever gotten a dog from a previous owner that didn't want to cooperate when it came to the paperwork?
Hopefully they won't have this problem, but I did! I know exactly what happened to me and the Pulaski vet WOULD NOT see me until I had this info switched over. Maybe an off base vet would see me, but since I was NOT the owner that was on his records I could NOT bring him in.
Well guys - its was me. I am the one who bought the dog. I am absolutely in love with him. It was a rough start with getting the dogs to be friends but now they are the best of friends and won't leave each others side. My kids adore him to the fullest. I truely believe if this dog could cook and clean and do laundry then I would be out the door cause my hubby loves him so much, lol. At the same time I do feel really bad for them. I talked to the lady last night for hrs on the phone about getting him. I told her having a dog in stairwell housing was very difficult but I had seen it done - that I had done it myself but it was difficult, especially with 2 small kids.(hers are 4 and 3 and mine are 11, 6, and 2) I told her that she needed to decide what her limitations were and if this exceeded them then she had to do what was best for her and the dog. She repeated over and over that this was what she wanted to do. She was even prepared to have my husband come over at 1am to get him. My husband decided not to because of road condidtions and so we made the exchange for today. The exchange occured this afternoon at 1pm then at 7pm he was calling wanting the dog back. I have already spent over 100 dollars on him for treats and a new mattress and toys. He called and I said I would talk to my husband - we talked it over and decided no. We don't want to put our kids through it and we love him. I can't believe after such a short time that we are already so attached. When I stopped answering his calls he showed up at my home with money in hand - I won't lie I feel really bad for him but it did kinda freak me out. He now wants to talk to my husband and I told him when my husband would be home - I then called my husband to tell him and he said Oh well - they sold him and we bought him. He claims he wants to talk to my husband because (in his words) something has to be done - 500 euro is not enough to put his family through this. I really do agree - 500 euro isn't enough to put his family through this but at the same time he shoulda thought about that before hand and now he is putting my family through it. I feel so bad and it breaks my heart to tell them no but at the same time it will break my heart more to give him back. Now I am worried about the vet - what if this guy refuses to relinquish ownership through the vet? He is not microchipped but I have all his papers saying he is purebred and his medicine (he had an ear infection). What do I do - how am I suppose to trust my dog outside with this guy moving on the same base as me? I feel so bad but at the same time I am mad as hell.
I'd tell them go to suck it. It's their loss.
As far as the vet, just bring him in. Get him microchipped. If his ear infection flares up again, then you can take him and and get him the meds then.
If he's not chipped then I don't think you will have any problems, especially if you have all of his paperwork. When I got my dog, the Pulaski vet said that I would have no problem registering him with them if he didn't have a chip and I had the paperwork, so you should be fine. But unfortunately mine did have a chip, but luckily I found another way around that.
I agree, I would be extremely cautious if I were you especially if this guy is showing up at your house and is saying things need to be done... what the heck does that mean?? I would also print out any emails that you two sent to each other as proof that you bought the dog. Proof enough should be that you have paperwork but I would prepare just in case. I mean he sounds desperate enough to call the police and say that you stole his dog. I agree with you, I mean like I stated before, if they really cared they wouldn't have put him up for sale at all... but that's just my opinion :) Good luck with this whole terrible ordeal and keep up posted about what happens please! :)
Get the dog microchipped ASAP. Otherwise if he tries to tak it you won't have any proof that it's the exact dog should they suddenly get "another" dog that looks just like yours.
Keep all emails and if the ad is still around, print that out too. This guy sounds like a nut coming to your door like that. Good luck and congrats on the new dog.
I bought a chocolate lab. I am very aware I got quite the deal - he is only 7 months old. My husband emailed him only once and it was through RYS. They have also deleted the post. We have contacted RYS to see if they can retrieve the email or the post and are waiting on a reply. They guy has called and called and when my husband got home he talked to him and told him that we are sorry about the situation they are now in (missing the dog) but he is ours now - we are attached to him and will not return him. They guy told my husband that he was going to go to legal on Tuesday. My husband told him to do what he felt he had to do but we would not give the dog up without a fight. He then put a guilt trip on my husband saying that one of his daughters was crying so hard she wasn't watching where she was going and fell and put her 2 front teeth through her bottom lip - the guilt trips just went on and on. When my husband stuck with saying no, the guy hung up on him. Then 10 minutes later the wife called, she was crying and claiming that we were being unreasonable. She told my husband that she wanted what was best for the dog and with us being "harsh" that she feels he went to the wrong home.
Now I say to you all (correct me if I am wrong) but if I was willing to give him up so easily after getting attached to him - introducing him to our other dog and most of all letting my kids get attached, to me that would say she put him in the wrong home. She and her husband even offered us 100 euro on top of giving us a full refund for him and my husband, being very patient but firm, said maam it is not about the money. We have been lucky enough to get the dog we have been looking for for 15 months and he was within our price range, he then again told her we will not give him up and she got nasty and said they were going to legal to see what could be done and hung up.
WOW - I say again - WOW! I cannot believe this is happening. I can see why they are being like this (in a way) cause he is a great dog. I couldn't have asked for better if I personally designed him myself. At the same time, they sold him and we are keeping him. I told them when they sold him to us (because they were crying) that they could feel free to come buy and see him anytime. When my husband was on the phone with them they said they wanted to come over tomorrow and see him. I have news for them - I think I have been way too nice and beat myself up enough over this and I have retracted the invite. I don't want them any where around me. Its not ok for them to hurt over a choice they made of their own free will but its ok to disrupt my kids and break my kids' heart - I DON'T THINK SO! I am so done with this. As of right now they haven't broken any laws but I swear if they call again or come by I am telling them the deal is done and they need to move on and don't call or come back. I cannot believe this is happening. I don't wanna have my phone in the house - I swear I am 2 seconds from giving the phone to the dogs and letting them bury it in the backyard, lol.
ide probably give the dog back but in saying that if i was the only 1 involved ide say ok whatever stop crying here is the dog back. but the fact all the kids are attached and they sold it to you yeah just stick to your guns and tell them the dog is great where it is has a good home and they shud move on. take the cash and start over get some fish or a hamster whatever. what else can they do really. get the dog in your name and there isnt anything else to it :)
You could always just take the dog off base. There are some wonderful vets off base, ours usually sees us the same day if we call, instead of waiting 2-3 weeks like Pulaski.
just lauren, no, i have never dealt with anyone in this type of situation. i a person who likes puppies so i can raise them form the start. i got my last dog before the chips were available. it sounds more like a policy from the base to prove ownership and determine the dog and owner can use the base vet clinic. people actually try to get military members to take their dog to the base vet to save money. i've had it happen to me. anyway, my dog was chipped off base but the vet on base saw her too and her chip was never checked. is this something they started doing recently? i really hope things work out. i was a little curious about the situation when i saw the dog listed on RYS.