Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Ban on Fighting Dogs

who's talking here?

Mojo 6
paulaaaaaa 2
Bob 7
WitnessProtectionProgram 6
Rachel 1
ashml 4
doddlebug 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Bob --- 16 years ago -

what do you think about the current and proposed bans on fighting dogs? agree?? disagree?? why?? personally i think it's good because there are too many cases where the owners don't raise them properly and can't control them. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

I think it's akin to banning guns because they kill people. Doesn't really address the true problem, and until they put legislation in place to control irresponsible breeding practices, this will be a problem regardless of what other laws they put in place. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Well, they have this kind of ban here in Germany, and the one on guns...and neither is a "problem." 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

Agreed, and putting a potentially dangerous dog in a bad owner or ignorant owners hands, is like giving them a loaded weapon...certainly not the poor dogs fault, but the end result usual is a child gets hurt, the dog gets put down and the owner gets a slap on the wrists...while I hate the idea of restricting breeds....very big brother..in this case I think its wise..... 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

They do have gun laws here, and people still get shot. Breed specific legislation does nothing but cause people to be secretive backyard breeders, and encourages people to not seek out trainers and do things to make their dogs productive members of society. Putting restrictions on the owners, and harsher penalties for the owners, are what is needed. Until then, this will always be a problem. You ban all the dogs on the dangerous breed list now, and then all the dogs that are considered "Safe" become popular and all of the sudden, they're the dangerous ones. People are a lot more likely to report an attack by a "Dangerous" breed, than they are by a lab or a retriever because they're considered "Family" dogs, when they could be just as dangerous. There are a LOT of misconceptions when it comes to dangerous breeds. Also, up until the early 80's, pit bulls were considered the family dog of choice. They became so popular that they were popular for poor breeding practices, and fighting rings, and that's why they are "Dangerous" now. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Imagine being in England. During the new comers briefing, you can't have any type of weapon in your home except kitchen knifes or unless a sword is mounted and dull and therefor unusable. No locking knife in your pocket or in your vehicle at any time. Even carrying around a bat is considered a weapon if you didn't just come home from a baseball game or going to. They'll stop and question you. You can be (and they have) put in jail for causing "too much harm/killing" a burglar who broke into your home. We were literally told by the police officer that the "british don't want to hurt you, they just want your goods". 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

That said, I am wary of dogs that are known for attacking other living things. Especially pitbulls. Its not as if I have ever said anything but I will seperate the space between the dog and my child. Even unknown fighting dogs have a higher statistic of harming children/adults than other dogs. So Im more watchful when I see one. That said, Im on the fence if they should be banned. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

you can make any dog a fighting dog yes more breeds tend to be seen more, but my mom worked with NC animal rescue and they came upon a farm where they had fighting dogs and they where every type of dog there not just specific breeds..its disgusting period...its not the animals fault but yet they are the ones that get punished 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

pitbull Pictures, Images and Photos 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

btw ANY dog can potentially become dangerous, if it can over power you its dangerous..i haven't seen the "list" but I know plenty of dogs not considered "fighting" dogs that can you take you down pretty quickly if they wanted too...its not just pitbulls, or rotts...if they are trained to attack or live in harsh environments they will attack 

paulaaaaaa --- 16 years ago -

I am against it. I had and raised a blue nose/Razors edge pit bull and LOVED him. He was the sweetest dog in the world. It all depends on how they were raised. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

ok i googled it and I got this website discribing what is to happen when this ban is in play and that is cruel to put a muzzle on a dog for over extended period of time...(i know i will be skinned alive for this) the poor dogs!!! Everyone talks about oh don't sell your dogs find them new homes..and so many people are quick to judge other people about their animals but amazingly no one steps up for these breeds....it depends on the owner...if they start banning these dogs guess what...other dogs like german shepards and labs etc will be used for "fighting" or show major aggression they need to punish the owners not the breeds...jesus...... 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

"We in Germany do as much as possible against this new crazy politics, but we need also help as much as possible. Today the county Hessen announced they will kill about 5000 "fighting dogs" soon... Of course there was no accident with one of these dogs in this county."-this just angers me more and more....i think its time to get off this site for today LOL 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

There are plenty of people stepping up for these breeds. Unfortunately, the fear mongering that goes on in the form of "Dangerous breed" lists and breed-specific legislation, as well as people just believing the stereotype that any dog on the list MUST be bad, well, it just creates a bigger problem. And in the end, the irresponsible owners are the ones who screw it up for everybody. Anybody remember Ace the Dalmation? YOu think that dog got that way on his own? You think any dog starts out mean and aggressive? No, it's the people who put them into situations that set them up for failure, when they can't handle the dog, don't socialize the dog, and don't bother to train the dog at all. If everybody took time to learn their dogs signals, and how to read their body language, and actually PAID ATTENTION to the signals a dog gives out, there would be a hell of a lot less dangerous breeds out there. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

I also believe that backyard breeding should be outlawed, and that dog breeding in general should be heavily monitored. There are a lot of unethical breeders out there, who don't pay attention to any health problems or genetic issues that could come up between dogs, and just breed the puppies to make a buck. There are many instances of incest with backyard breeding, and consequently, dogs that end up with all kinds of neurological issues that manifest as aggression. Don't even get me started on how the AKC standards have ruined breeds. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Very true Marissa. English bull dogs and weiner dogs....nature would have never created such dogs for a specific reason. 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

indeed, the inbreeding to make dogs show standard for the KC and AKC is criminal, King Charles Spaniels with brains too big for their skulls, basset hounds with premature arthritis, German Shepard with back problems due to the fashion for sloping hind quarters, British Bull Dogs with breathing problems due to foreshortened snouts...the list goes on...I find breeding to create a fashionable characteristic extremely prominent very cruel, and from so called animals lovers...they shorten the animals life and cause it unnecessary pain. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

http://animals.change.org/blog/view/are_dog_bite_statistics_reliable These relatively few fatalities offer the only available information about breeds involved in dog bites. There is currently no accurate way to identify the number of dogs of a particular breed, and consequently no measure to determine which breeds are more likely to bite or kill. http://www.cdc.gov/HomeandRecreationalSafety/Dog-Bites/dogbite-factsheet.html An often-asked question is what breed or breeds of dogs are most “dangerous”? This inquiry can be prompted by a serious attack by a specific dog, or it may be the result of media-driven portrayals of a specific breed as “dangerous.”12,13 Although this is a common concern, singling out 1 or 2 breeds for control can result in a false sense of accomplishment.14 Doing so ignores the true scope of the problem and will not result in a responsible approach to protecting a community’s citizens. Dog bite statistics are not really statistics, and they do not give an accurate picture of dogs that bite.7 Invariably the numbers will show that dogs from popular large breeds are a problem. This should be expected, because big dogs can physically do more damage if they do bite, and any popular breed has more individuals that could bite. http://www.avma.org/public_health/dogbite/dogbite.pdf 

Bob --- 16 years ago -

the idea of comparing a ban on fighting dogs and a gun ban isn't actually correct. a gun left alone and unloaded can't do anything. a pit bull that is not raised properly and left alone can attack and kill a person. blaming the problem on breeding pratices misses the mark as well. the owners need to be aware of what is necessary to meet the needs of the dog they want to get. for instance, all the breeders i know who breed german shepherds won't sell their males to anyone who doesn't show a certain degree of knowledge about raising the breed. i even know one who does an interview to try to establish what kind of personality the individual has. if you can't establish yourself as a strong alpha leader then this is not the type of dog you want. this goes for all the dogs they classify as fighting dogs. the issue is these types of dogs are known for having dominate personalities. if you can't establish your position as the alpha leader then you won't have complete control of the dog. Marissa is right when she points out that it is not the breed. In the right hands a pit bull or mastiff of any kind can be a huge baby. they have to have the confidence that you will be the leader and have trust in you. i just spent most of yesterday with about 105 german shepherds, a dog that people have argued should be on the banned list, and they were all like puppies playful and gentle and approachable by all. after i got home my neighbor's german shepherd tried to attack me. the difference? the owner. it's not the breed. i do agree the ban is a good thing but not because i think the dogs are bad. you need to learn the breed and then learn your dog as marissa said. and never take anything for granted. you can have the best dog in the world but if another dog comes at it in an aggressive manner there will be trouble. bottom line, research the breed you are thinking about BEFORE you buy it. make sure you know what you need to do to give it what it needs. if you don't have a very strong personality or a lot of time do not get one of the dogs on any list of banned dogs. any good site about dogs will point out if it is a dominate type or will point out that a strong alpha is needed to make sure you have a banalced dog. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

When it comes to pittbulls/rottweilers, their muscular build and jaw is not something nature would have created. The bad part about pittbulls is that if they do turn, they have an instinct to not let go and shake while attached. But again, they were bred this way though. I did read something pretty interesting... "No single, neutered household pet pit bull has ever killed anyone." Karen Delise, Founder and Director of Research for the National Canine Research Council, and Author of The Pit Bull Placebo: The Media Myths and Politics of Canine Aggression (Anubis Publishing). 

Bob --- 16 years ago -

that's interesting. i know that neutered dogs are supposed to be calmer and less territorial but i didn't realize it made that much of a difference. i wonder if this is true for all dogs or just the pit bulls. i'm not sure about your comment about the muscular builds not being something nature would have created. i've never researched the origins of the breeds you mentioned. i don't see why it couldn't be a natural occurance just like the massive size and strength of the caucasian mountain dogs. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

I had to look this dog up, holy cow what a huge beast! I've only ever seen one and that was here in England. I can't imagine living in a small british house with one! You're right, we may never know what nature had intended for the dogs. What we do know is that they are bred that way for certain reasons for humans and most of the time, its causes problems for them. Even these moutain dogs may be much larger then when they first evolved since they have bred for quite some time too. I read that they can react with lightening speed. That was pretty funny to read since the dog that I saw was let loose and chased a football (which it dwarfed!) and it looked like a quick walk more than a run. It doesn't look by the dog's structure that it can run very fast at all. 

Bob --- 16 years ago -

i saw a documentary on the mountain dog that was an eye opener. the dog is very strong willed so you have to be able to establish yourself as the alpha but once you do it accepts you as the leader. this is both good and bad because the dog will attack anything it sees as a threat to you, itself, or it's territory. during an interview with one owner the dog attacked a retro mustang and broke a huge piece out of the back bumper! there are stories of these dogs fighting bears and winning! 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

I thought that dog was a bear when I first saw it! I really thought a mastiff was the biggest a dog could ever get. 

Bob --- 16 years ago -

i think the largest dog ever recorded was a mastiff named hercules. this may be wrong because until the fall of the wall we didn't know that much about the caucasian mountain dogs because they are from cacaus region of russia. they are a monster of a dog and will end up on the banned lists because of their nature. it will be another case of owners not raising the dog correctly but the results will be deadly in just about every case. granted, the mustang didn't die but i'll bet it cost the owner a lot to have the car repaired. 

Bob --- 16 years ago -

here's a site that about sums up the dog: http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://windowseat.ca/images/caucasian_mountain_dog.png&imgrefurl=http://windowseat.ca/item.php%3Fid%3D478&h=363&w=268&sz=188&tbnid=ELGTToVxNpgxFM:&tbnh=121&tbnw=89&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dcaucasian%2Bmountain%2Bdog&hl=en&usg=__FmJDxaBY3rs6A6SwwasFfyKiMz0=&ei=tJLeS4ntDZGtOJnuqLIH&sa=X&oi=image_result&resnum=1&ct=image&ved=0CAYQ9QEwAA 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

I LOVE the caucasian mountain dogs. totally not realistic, but still wookit da big smooshy face. Mastiffs, rottweilers, st. bernards, all of those dogs all descended from a roman war dog breed. They are an ancient breed, not something that was recently created. The breeds are literally thousands of years old. Yes, the AKC standards have screwed up the breeds in the states with the stupid requirements for huge heads, big heavy bodies, short legs, etc, but if you get away from that and see the breeds in other countries, you'd be surprised at how beautiful and proportionate they are. Our rottweiler is a german bred dog, and my god is she beautiful (I may be a bit biased). She is proportionate, her head is perfect for her body, her body isn't huge, her legs are longer and she can hold her weight. She is what the breed SHOULD look like. The funniest/saddest part of that is that she isn't considered AKC "Breeding stock" because...wait for it....she has shaggy fur. She's a "Working Stock" dog and is made for physical work, not for looking big and mean. She's also been described as a giant marshmallow, because her personality is so goofy and sweet. If you want a perfect example of a dog that has lived for thousands of years with little/no human intervention, look at the alano espanol.....they have zero known health problems because they have always been bred for health, not for looks. 

Bob --- 16 years ago -

marissa, you hit the nail on the head when you mentioned the akc standards messing up the dogs. this causes a lot of inbreeding and leads to many of the problems seen in fighting dogs and other dogs as well. i've read up some on the rottweiler the last while and you dog sounds like a pretty stable, normal example of the dogs from germany. you mentioned it is goofy, i've read comments on many sites about the rottweiler being a real clown. the germans have different standards. rottweilers and other working dogs are bred differently than in the states. they are bred to be the way nature intended them to be and not modified to look pretty. working dogs are supposed to be big, strong, loyal, and good natured. in my opinion, dogs like this are far more appealing to the eye than the things they make in the states. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground