Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Exchange Rate

who's talking here?

geologic 3
just a girl 3
GaryKenyon 1
Bob 1
nicole 1
Brittney 1
rmitchell248 5
Euro Maker 9
CMS 2
Dani 1
Kevin 1
Abe 1
PC11 1
Sarah 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Anyone know what the deal is with the exchange rate. KA is usually posting the rate by two days behind for some reason. Not sure why they can't keep up.

Plus, the rate appears to be wrong, unless I am not understanding something.

Two days ago, the rate was sitting at .74xx rounded to .75.

KA shows the rate on the 25th being .77.

0

Is there a different rate that I don't know about? Is AAFES rate different than the 'real' rate? Is KA just wrong?

Trying to figure this out because I am paying for a cruise. A few cents turns out to be a lot of money when dealing in several thousand dollars.

TIA 

nicole --- 16 years ago -

That depends. I went to the bank on Sunday and they couldn't exchange euro coin, but they told us that we could take it to the bx in customer service. They also told us that the bx takes a little commission- kinda like coin star in the states. 

just a girl --- 16 years ago -

AAFES and the banks on base usually have a 2 euro cent difference than the international rate.
The KA gives the International rate, and if you go to and ATM off base you will always get a different rate. Also the rate on AFN is from the bank on base as well. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

So, what you are saying is that it is possible to get a better rate off base? If that is the case, why would anyone bother doing an exchange on base?

When I was in Paris a month ago, the rate on the street was 4 cents better than on base. There was a small fee to make the exchange, but I exchanged enough money to more than make up for the fee.

I can understand that in order to operate, businesses need to make money, but geez... Give us a break somewhere. I feel like AAFES is the giant without a heart, sometimes.

I wonder if the rate at some of the local banks is better? I mean like in the villages in which we live. 

just a girl --- 16 years ago -

yes it is better to go off base!! Usually your bank will charge you a 1% foreign currency exchange and a surcharge, but after all that you still get a better deal then on base.
if it is 20 euro it doesn't really make a huge difference but if you need a large amount you can save quite a bit.
the problem can be when you need a large amount and you have a daily limit on your card. We pull our rent out in 2 days. Our bank pays back the ATM fees so that doesn't matter.
I pull it from the bank in our village also. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

I am not worried about a card. I can walk into the bank and do unlimited transactions.

I am trying to take as much business as I can away from AAFES. I am going to go down to the bank in my village and see what the deal is there.

Thanks!! 

CMS --- 16 years ago -

http://www.x-rates.com/calculator.html

This is the official rate given by both the EU bank and the US govt. The rates at the banks on base and through AAFES are always different. 

geologic --- 16 years ago -

when pulling out Euro's I always get it off base as the rate is always better! The base banks take a commission just as AAFES does when you do Euro conversion.

Offbase is always better for pulling out Euro! 

geologic --- 16 years ago -

here is what I found on the Currency converter for Dollar to Euro rate.

As of: 2010.07.27 (27 Jul 2010) 11:11:00 UTC


http://www.xe.com/ucc/convert.cgi?Amount=1&From=USD&To=EUR 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

I just got .75xx at the bank. The rate at your link is 1.00 USD = 0.767569 EUR

In this case, not that far off. 

just a girl --- 16 years ago -

ha, maybe they are getting smart on base and not ripping people of (so much). in any case i hate going there, to AAFES or the KMC in general. 

CMS --- 16 years ago -

Two cents is two cents, especially when pulling out large amounts of money! 

Bob --- 16 years ago -

the exchange rate that is usually the amount that the money is trading for. the exchange rate on base includes a charge for exchanging the money. it is normaly 5 cents so if the at to buy is 1.25 you pay 1.30 and if the exchange is the other way you should get 1.30 you only get 1.25. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Those fargin' iceholes at AAFES! I feel like I need an institutional size jar of KY every time I exchange money with them.

I am going to try off base and see how it goes.

Thank you, everyone, for all of the input. 

rmitchell248 --- 16 years ago -

The best way to exchange money and pay your bills that I have found is through a USAA debit card pulling money out of a Volksbank ATM machine in branch.

In response to the two trips to the ATM for payment of rent by "just a girl" if you are using USAA like I mentioned above you can call them and have your limit raised to 3000.00 USD for 24 hours then you can pull it out in one transaction.

Today I pulled out 1645 euro off my ATM card in one transaction. $2,152.67 after the exchange.

This comes out to .7641 or 1.3086. The market rate on the Euro to Dollar today (1000 hours) is .7651 or 1.3069 . Today Community bank is charging 1.3414!!! I saved 53.93 dollars today alone by not letting Community Bank pay my rent.

Essentially I am paying .0013% I dont think you can beat that one tenth of a percent

Now you go and open a Volksbank account for 1.50 Euro per month (you only need your US passport ot open the account) and deposit your utility money into this account. First you take it out of the ATM as I mentioned above. Then walk it over to the counter and deposit it into your German account. Now when your gas, electric, phone, internet, cell companies ect take your monthly bills out you no longer pay the 2-3% that you will be paying through Community bank or Service CU.

If you are paying 2800 per month in bills that comes out to $33,600per year. If you save 2.5% that comes out to $840 savings per year by eliminating the exchange rate. Now add on all of the times you hit the ATM for quick cash and you are saving more than 1000 dollars in a year.

Now the benefit on the other side to doing this is that not only are you getting charged 2-3% on debits out of your account in Euro by these banks. When your gas or electric company gives you your rebates at the end of the year for reconciliation you will be paying this 2-3% again! Not if you do what I laid out above. If they owe you 800 Euro at the end of the year you will get 800 Euro in your account.


One more cool thing you may or may not have noticed. If you look at your LES you will have your OHA that includes your housing allowance and your utility allowance. If you add up your allowances and convert them to the current market exchange rate you will see that every month they tack on that 2-2.5% to cover the fees that these banks are going to charge you. So with a little work you now get to put that money in your pocket.


The key things here are use your USAA ATM to get your cash out of the ATM do not let any actual bank tellers make the exchange for you because that is when the hefty percentages get added on.

USAA and Volksbank is the best combination that I have found. Using my "other" ATM card I pay the full 1% So i set up a Volksbank account and walk from the ATM inside the branch to the teller and deposit my Euro that I just paid one tenth of a percent on. Also you will not pay an ATM fee for the transaction.

I hope this helps somebody :)

Robert 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Awesome info!

I am definitely going to be looking into this on Monday.

Thank you. 

geologic --- 16 years ago -

would've been great to know 4yrs ago. At any rate thanks for the info. Will have to keep that in mind if we get stationed in Europe again following our soon to be 4yr oconus tour in a few months. 

Kevin --- 16 years ago -

Doesn't USAA charge a "foreign transaction fee" when withdrawing from a foreign ATM? 

Brittney --- 16 years ago -

They do but you get those ATM Fees get reimbursed at the end of the month. 

rmitchell248 --- 16 years ago -

I have not been charged one dime from USAA yet when dealing with Volksbank. At some of the other banks ATMs we get charged an International fee but as said above those get reimbursed at the end of the month.

And even if they charged a $2 fee(which they dont) I would not care because just in my 1 transaction today I saved $52.00 

GaryKenyon --- 16 years ago -

The exchange rate always fluctuates. The banks off base will adjust for any movement in rates, while the banks on base lock in their rates at 1600 at the end of the EU trading day. 

rmitchell248 --- 16 years ago -

Yes then they add a little over 2% to that amount that they locked in the day before the final number is based off a contract that they have with the DOD. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

I am trying to find where USAA will deal with civilians. From what I gather, civilians can't deal with USAA. I could be mistaken. 

rmitchell248 --- 16 years ago -

hmmm.. I dont know the answer to that

Deposit your pay into an account that I will set up for you and I will only charge you .005% LOL what could go wrong? 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Deposit your pay into an account that I will set up for you and I will only charge you .005% LOL what could go wrong?

Your not a Nigerian banker are you? 

rmitchell248 --- 16 years ago -

No but I am stuck in cambodia and could use a plane ticket home..... 

Abe --- 16 years ago -

JOFTAA I seem to recall if you have a third cousin twice removed or closer in the military from the Civil War on, you qualify for an account.

I exaggerate a bit but it seemed pretty loose the last time I checked. You may have to use a military family member to sponsor you or something along those lines. 

Dani --- 16 years ago -

USAA is awesome. We are civilians and have it but also prior active duty. IF you can find a way to get in you wont regret it. We have everything through them, banking, car insurance.. ect. 

PC11 --- 16 years ago -

All I can say is save. Let's just hope for the best to happen. 

Sarah --- 16 years ago -

JOFTAA - USAA have recently changed the criteria for membership. DOD civilians are now eligible to use their services. We are getting ready to transfer everything over to them. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground