Originally put together as a fact check against/for some political claims....those points are uninteresting at best....main interest is with the legal process and intent.
Fact-checking the claims about 'anchor babies' and whether illegal immigrants 'drop and leave'.
Pregnant women from Mexico and other countries can come to the U.S. to deliver their babies. Voila! Under the 14th Amendment, the babies are instant citizens!
That's become a popular talking point for critics of illegal immigration, who have dubbed the children "anchor babies." The implication often is that the baby U.S. citizens act as an anchor that that helps parents and other relatives obtain citizenship and other benefits.
Several Republican senators, including Jon Kyl, R-Ariz., John McCain, R-Ariz., Jeff Sessions, R-Ala., and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., have called for hearings on whether the 14th Amendment, which was adopted in 1868, needs to be rewritten to curb automatic "birthright citizenship."
The most prominent voice pushing that concept is Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., who proposed amending the Constitution to make clear that babies born in the U.S. do not automatically receive American citizenship.
In a July 28, 2010, interview on Fox News' On the Record with Greta Van Susteren, Graham said that "there's another problem we have in this nation that I think is novel and needs to be fixed. If you come across the border illegally and you have a child in America, automatically, that child becomes an American citizen. Under the 14th Amendment, three court cases says there's a constitutional right to that. I would like to deal with the 12 million (illegal immigrants) firmly and fairly. You can't stay here on your own terms. You have to learn English. You have to pay fines. You have to get in the back of the line if you want to be a citizen. But I may introduce a constitutional amendment that changes the rules if you have a child here. Birthright citizenship, I think, is a mistake, that we should change our Constitution and say if you come here illegally and you have a child, that child's automatically not a citizen."
Later in the interview, Van Susteren asked Graham, "How realistic is it that you will introduce a constitutional amendment?"
Graham replied that he had to because "people come here to have babies. They come here to drop a child. It's called 'drop and leave.' To have a child in America, they cross the border, they go to the emergency room, have a child, and that child's automatically an American citizen. That shouldn't be the case. That attracts people here for all the wrong reasons."
In a later interview with Van Susteren on Aug. 3, Graham once again referred to a "problem where thousands of people are coming across the Arizona-Texas border for the express purpose of having a child in an American hospital so that child will become an American citizen, and they broke the law to get there."
We've dealt with one aspect of this issue before, when we checked a claim by Fox host Glenn Beck that "we're the only country in the world" that offers birthright citizenship. (We found that 33 others do, so we rated Beck's statement False.)
This time, we were curious about Graham's statement that "people come here to have babies. They come here to drop a child." He portrays it as such a big phenomenon that it warrants changing the U.S. Constitution. But is the problem as big as he suggests?
Limited benefits
It's important to note that having an "anchor baby" won't do much to help a Mexican mom become a U.S. citizen. Because citizen children cannot sponsor their parents for citizenship until they turn 21 -- and because if the parents were ever illegal, they would have to return home for 10 years before applying to come in -- having a baby to secure citizenship for its parents is an extremely long-term, and uncertain, process.
However, having a citizen child can produce some short-term benefits, said Marc Rosenblum, a senior policy analyst for the Migration Policy Institute. Pregnant women and nursing mothers could be eligible for certain benefits under the Women-Infants-Children (WIC) program, which provides food and nutrition vouchers, and their children could enroll in Medicaid, although the undocumented parents could not. Having a child can also help an undocumented parent qualify for relief from deportation, but only 4,000 unauthorized immigrants can receive such status per year, and the alien has to have been in the U.S. for at least 10 years. That means very long odds, Rosenblum said.
Most of the benefits of citizenship accrue over the much longer term. The child will be able to work here legally once he or she is old enough, said Roberto Suro, a communications and journalism professor at the University of Southern California who specializes in Hispanic issues, and when they're ready for college, they'll qualify for in-state tuition at most public colleges. "It is a hell of a lot of deferred gratification at best," he said.
Mixed evidence
When we contacted Graham's staff, they could not provide any specific data on mothers who "drop and leave." But they sent us several news accounts about the large number of undocumented immigrants who give birth to children in the United States.
Graham is right on that point. According to a report by the Pew Hispanic Center, a think tank that has done extensive research on immigration policy, 3.8 million undocumented immigrants have at least one child who is a citizen. "Most children of unauthorized immigrants -- 73 percent in 2008 -- are U.S. citizens by birth," the center says. That's up from 63 percent in 2003.
These statistics suggest not only that the number is large, but is also growing.
To offer a concrete example, we found a 2006 article from the Dallas Morning News about Parkland Memorial Hospital in Dallas, a safety-net facility for poor residents. As many of 70 percent of the roughly 16,000 women giving birth annually at the hospital were immigrants who were in the U.S. illegally, according to one survey cited in the story.
So there's ample evidence that many illegal immigrants give birth in the U.S. every year. But how many of them came to the U.S. with the motivation of giving birth and then leaving?
In interviewing medical practitioners in states on the U.S. Mexico border, we found mixed evidence.
James Dickson, the administrator and CEO of Copper Queen Community Hospital in Bisbee, Ariz., located five miles from the Mexico border, told us that his hospital hasn't offered obstetrical services in a few years, but when it did, he did not see anything like what Graham is describing. "We had some" people who came to have a baby in the U.S., he said, but their goal was not citizenship. It was higher quality treatment or specific services that were unavailable in Mexico.
Salli Gonzalez, a nurse-midwife in Seguin, Texas, who delivers about 30 babies a year, said that in the past two years, she'd seen only one person who would fit Graham's criteria.
On the other hand, Lauren Weber, a midwife in San Diego, said that some patients from Mexico have confided to her that they've temporarily secured a U.S. address and a utility bill, which is typically enough to qualify them for birth-related care paid by California's version of Medicaid.
"There are a million hardworking Hispanic people in San Diego who came here to work and then happened to have a baby," she said. "Then there are people who come over in order to have a baby." She estimated that in the clinic where she works part time, a third to a quarter of her patients have come over for the express purpose of having a baby, and the rest are staying in the U.S. for the longer term, whatever their legal status may be.
Weber also noted that she's treated wealthier patients who get the proper visas and fly to the United States to have a child. They come from such countries as China, Pakistan and India. Less affluent Filipinos have also come on tourist visas, she said, and some affluent Mexicans come to give birth as well.
This is a pattern cited in a series of recent news accounts. One article, by the Associated Press on June 28, 2009, details a "birth package" offered by the Tucson Medical Center in Tucson, Ariz., to affluent Mexican women. "This is not a new phenomena," the Mexican consul general in Tucson, Juan Manuel Calderon Jaimes, told the AP, saying he's seen the practice for almost 30 years. "Many families of means in Sonora send their wives here to give birth because they have the resources to pay for the services."
The article reported that "expectant mothers can either schedule a Caesarean section or arrive a few weeks before their due dates to give birth at TMC. It is one of 13 packages aimed at Mexican families, some of which include a stay at a local resort and shopping excursion. Tucson Medical Center's maternity package costs $2,300 for a vaginal birth with a two-day stay and $4,600 for a Caesarean section and a four-day stay, assuming no complications."
Another article, published in the Washington Post on July 18, 2010, featured a Shanghai-based firm that charges $14,750 for a three-month stay in a center in California. The package includes "two months before the birth and a month after," according to the article. "A room with cable TV and a wireless Internet connection, plus three meals, starts at $35 a day. The doctors and staff all speak Chinese. There are shopping and sightseeing trips. The mothers must pay their own airfare and are responsible for getting a U.S. visa, although (the firm) will help them fill out the application form."
In such cases, it's hard to determine whether mothers-to-be are coming to the U.S. for higher-quality medical treatment or the benefits of citizenship.
Data doesn't support Graham's claim
Immigration data and surveys don't provide much support for Graham's notion that many women are illegally crossing the border in large numbers to have children, then leaving.
First, immigration from Mexico to the U.S. tends to go up and down in tandem with the health of the economy.
According to another Pew Hispanic Center report, immigration from Mexico dropped by about one-third between 2000-2001 and 2002-2003, coinciding with the recession precipitated by the dot-com bust and the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. The numbers climbed back as the economy recovered, rising close to their pre-decline numbers by 2005-2006. Then, the numbers fell again, starting in 2006-2007 (a bit before the current recession began) and have continued to fall as the economy has sputtered.
It should be noted that these are numbers for all immigrants coming from Mexico, legal and illegal combined. But Jeffrey S. Passel, a senior demographer with the Pew Hispanic Center, said that since illegal immigration historically accounts for 80 to 85 percent of all new immigration from Mexico, the trends for all immigrants tend to mirror those for illegal immigrants alone.
"All the data suggests that people come here to work -- especially Mexicans, and especially illegal Mexicans," said Suro. "If people came here because they were looking for work, you would expect to see the flow fluctuate with employment opportunities -- and thatÂ’s what the data shows. If people came here to have babies, the flows would be pretty constant, and they are not."
There's something else you don't see, Suro said. If having a baby was a significant driving factor in illegal immigration, you would expect to see a higher percentage of women of child-bearing age in the U.S. illegally compared to men of the same age. In fact, just the opposite is the case. Numbers from the Pew Hispanic Center show that in four separate age ranges between 20 and 40, undocumented men significantly outnumber undocumented women.
Finally, there's direct testimony from actual immigrants.
Princeton University sociologist Douglas Massey conducted in-depth interviews with 159 Latin American immigrants -- most of whom came to the U.S. illegally -- for a recent book he coauthored with Magaly Sanchez R., Brokered Boundaries: Constructing Immigrant Identity in Anti-Immigrant Times.
When they were asked about their motivations for coming to the U.S., "no one ever mentioned having kids in the U.S." Massey said. "I've been surveying Mexican immigrants to the U.S. for 30 years as part of the Mexican Migration Project. We don't ask people their reasons for migrating because most people cannot really articulate the reasons very well -- you get simple answers like, 'I came for the money,' but that doesn't tell you much because people can want money for all kinds of reasons. But we do ask about their migratory behavior, which we then link to social and economic conditions on both sides of the border. What our work shows is that migrants come in response to labor demand in the U.S. and are motivated by economic problems at home."
Misleading comments
Undoubtedly, citizenship plays some role in the decisions by undocumented immigrants to come to the U.S. After all, they have made a decision to make their future in the United States rather than in their home country, and part of building a better life in the U.S. is having citizenship for their children. But on Fox, Graham termed the practice "drop and leave," which suggests that illegal immigrants are coming here for the primary purpose of having babies with citizenship, then rushing home to wherever they came from.
Graham's comments on this are misleading. While that does appear to be happening with affluent "birth tourists," it's important to understand that those affluent "birth tourists" are not the ones illegally crossing the Rio Grande or the Sonoran desert. They are coming here with the proper legal papers and giving birth. Thus, whatever public policy challenges arise from "birth tourism" are separate and distinct from the public policy challenges of illegal immigration -- which is not at all the impression that Graham gave in his Fox appearance.
Graham tacitly acknowledged this distinction in his follow-up appearance on Van Susteren's show on Aug. 3, 2010, saying, "You have found and I've provided you information about groups that are marketing to Chinese, and Mideastern and European families a 90-day visa package, where you come to America as a tourist. You come to a resort. You have your child at a hospital within the resort. That child is an American citizen. You turn around and leave." But raising this example days later strikes us as an after-the-fact justification.
So let's recap.
It's true that many illegal immigrants are having children in the U.S. However, we are not convinced that "drop and leave" is a phenomenon. The data suggests that the motivator for illegal immigrants is the search for work and a better economic standing over the long term, not quickie citizenship for U.S.-born babies. Graham appears to be conflating two things -- a pattern of wealthy foreigners engaging in "birth tourism" using legal visas, and illegal immigration of poorer people from Mexico. In our view, failing to make the distinction exaggerates the alleged problem and uses inflammatory rhetoric to obscure legitimate policy questions. On balance, we rate his comment Half True.
In theory JOFTAA, that would work. In reality, we have so little resources and money to dedicate to the borders that it's laughable.
In the cities/towns on the borders, where the immigrants are coming in, they are poorer and not as "on the radar". People want to make this out to be some big epidemic where the scary, dirty mexicans are crossing the border to steal their precious health care, when the reality is, they are real live people who are coming to find work and feed their families.
You stop the companies and businesses that hire illegal immigrants because they're cheaper to pay, you enforce those standards, and you are more likely to cut the immigration down quite a bit. You make it hard for them to work without legally crossing, you make it not worth doing.
Until there aren't any jobs, they will continue to cross illegally and work.
I apologize the the general membership for posting actual intellectual material here that does not include bashing bad mommies, tattoos, or piercings. I thought this could be discussed between intelligent people. Aside from Marissa, that seems to be it. And, one person who could not manage to read the entire thing.
Just calling it exactly as it is.
More on this issue... Starts at about the 7 minute 30 second mark.
well I don't like to talk about it just because I am in the middle....yes they want to make better lives for themselves, who are we to stop them? but also is illegal, they are taking jobs because they will take less, they don't pay taxes etc....so I am stuck in the middle. I know a family that came to the united states because of them being tormented by gangs but then you got gangs coming here illegally its one huge mess...and I don't think this will ever stop because they don't have enough man power to control the border.
I think i have the intelligent to adress the issue ,if i switch my brain on,but how long have you got?This would be a discussion over a pint and some lovely food.
I don't think changing the constitution is the answer. Becoming a citizen by being born here is one of the things that make the US awesome, in my opinion.
Ideally it would be to prevent them from coming in, like Joftaa said. And the only way to have enough manpower to patrol the border is to pull all the troops outta the sandbox and then i still don't think there'd be enough.
I think i have the intelligent to adress the issue ,if i switch my brain on,but how long have you got?This would be a discussion over a pint and some lovely food.
Go for it, Daisy. Got an extra pint?
ashml -
I hear you.
This is the way I feel about it. My great, great grandfather took a ship to Ellis Island from Austria. As most immigrants, he got here with nothing more than the clothes on his back.
I was lucky, because I got to meet him. When I met him, he was sitting in on the balcony of his Miami Beach condo enjoying the sea breeze.
It was always driven home to me that doing things the right way, is the best way.
American is a melting pot. Just about everyone here is from someplace else. This begs the question with not wanting more people coming into the country? It isn't about that. It is about ILLEGALS coming into the country.
The illegals are not paying taxes. Instead we are carrying their debts on our backs as citizens who follow the rules. The illegals take the jobs from those of us who want to do it right because they will work for less. Of course they work for less. They are not having 20+% taken out of their pay. If I did not have to pay taxes, I could work for less. But, I am a law abiding citizen who pays my dues. So are you, ashml.
To me, it is not about keeping people out. To me, it is about letting the LEGALS in. Let anyone who wants to come, do so. Just so they follow our rules.
If they want to sneak in, then they should find the consequences harsh. Harsh consequences are what stops others. I am not talking about killing or hurting people. I mean make sure they don't come back.
It is all ideological, I know.
None the less, I was inspired by my great, great grandfather.
If a poor man from Austria can come to the U.S. with nothing and wind up living in a Miami Beach condo, then anyone with the desire to work and follow the rules can do the same.
I also think that part of this is the fault of the U.S. We make it too easy to break the law here and just jump over a border and break our laws. Until this is corrected, things won't change much.
I am adamantly anti illegal immigrant. They take far more than they give back. I realize they just want to make money for their families. So do drug dealers but I'm not going to excuse their criminal behaviours either.
Maybe,just maybe we can all meet up somewhere nice and put name to face?Its just an idea,maybe people know each other already.What do you think ,good idea or bad idea?
Maybe,just maybe we can all meet up somewhere nice and put name to face?Its just an idea,maybe people know each other already.What do you think ,good idea or bad idea?
After school starts again and I am not Mr. Mom, sure. Summer is busy for my family.
You say that illegals take jobs that americans would work. I know FAR too many people that would rather be unemployed than work at McDs or in a field picking blueberries. The illegals don't care where they work as long as they get paid.
Does or did anyone ever watch the show "Border Patrol"? I wonder how some of these people actually come up with $20.000 to have some human traffic person bring them to the US. One father actually paid $10.000 to have his daughter brought to the US, when he could have just gotten a regular visa for her (he was already living in the US). Another one had her teeth pulled out so her face would swell up to make her look more like the picture on her fake I.D. Question, if everyone claims they don't hire people without a SSN, where do all of these illegal immigrants actually work (unless they all commited identity theft), how do they get an apartment, how do they pay bills, there must be some sort of tolerance towards them, because there are far too many to not acknowledge them.
You say that illegals take jobs that americans would work. I know FAR too many people that would rather be unemployed than work at McDs or in a field picking blueberries. The illegals don't care where they work as long as they get paid.
So what? Why do you know so many unemployed people? Just curious.
That doesn't make it right to be here illegally. Not even in the slightest.
I have heard this argument so many times.
Americans don't want to do the work, so give it to someone who will do it.
That doesn't fly.
How about this, instead. Take away the government support from the lazy slob that would rather stay home than work.
Make people accountable for what they receive. If someone is going to receive federal assistance, paid for by working tax payers, then that person needs to prove that he needs it. If work is available, and a person refuses the job, cut off the financial life support. Beggars cannot be choosers. Anyone who is on financial aid due to being jobless needs to be in a database. That database will send unemployed people to places of employment. Either the person works the job or doesn't get more assistance.
When someone does work and get paid, that amount can be deducted from the federal assistance. This will give some relief to those of us paying for the welfare.
I make it sound cut and dry. I know there are nuances to it. But, it is a basic idea.
Obviously there would be exceptions for people who cannot physically do the work. I do not expect some 60yo man with a heart condition to pick strawberries. I do expect some 25yo healthy person to get out there though. I also expect the out of work accountant to be out there too. Minimum wage may not be what they are used to but it's better than nothing at all. If they would rather be unemployed then they can sit home an collect unemployment. That's their right as someone who used to work legally. Once that runs out though get a job wherever you can or go without.
The problem isn't that they don't want to go out and "pick strawberries", the problem is that the owners of the "Strawberry fields" would rather hire an illegal, where they don't have to pay taxes or health care coverage for that illegal. it's cheaper to hire an illegal than an american. Until that part of the problem is addressed, this will continue, ad nauseum.
And if you really want to know where the majority of them are living, they are likely in some sort of transient camp provided, again, by the owner of the proverbial strawberry field, to do the work. And the conditions are atrocious.
JOFTAA, you're coming perilously close to describing Regan's "Welfare Queen", when in reality, they just don't exist like that anymore (or ever, really, but that's not the debate we're having right now).
Our welfare system just isn't set up for the type of situation you want. The minute you get a job, ANY job, it reduces your eligibility. But usually, the job isn't enough to provide you with basic food and shelter. And thus begins an ugly cycle of poverty. Some states have a lot of programs and safety nets set up for people stuck in these cycles, and some states have programs that are so underfunded, the waiting lists are years long. So, really, it isn't a new idea that the welfare system needs reform; the problem is that it can't be done in the fashion you claim.
Ohter Countries have the same problems and the Goverment is trying to adress these issues.Maybe giving them temporarely working visas so they won't have to work in low -wage jobs or have to be sqeezed into a smugglers van.It stops human trafficin and they would pay there taxes.
No, most of them aren't living in transient caps. Most of them are living in cities and neighborhoods and the vast majority are not working in fields at all. They are construction workers, housekeepers, janitors, day laborers, etc.
AZ implemented a law where it is illegal to hire an illegal and any business that knowingly does can be fined or even shut down. The city of Mesa was busted because their night cleaning crew was full of illegals.
Temporary work visas won't do anything except reward them for being criminals. We tried amnesty under Reagan. Now we have a whole new bumper crop demanding we do it again.
Hit the businesses that hire them in the wallet. Deport them when they are found. Enforce the laws already on the books instead of saying "It's too big of a problem!" Drugs are an even bigger problem but no one in power is suggesting we just stop enforcing those laws.
It is not going to be a perfect system. As long as the human element is involved, it will be flawed.
Giving an illegal a temporary work visa is not the answer.
If it is against the law, that is all there is to it. Really simple, folks.
I know my position on this is not the most popular, but I will stick by it.
The American system is setup to cater to laziness. There are more holes in our welfare system than there are in one of those 'love houses' up the road.
We hired a nanny for our son back in the U.S. She came to our house and we paid her. She declared taxes, and we filled out the tax forms as required. Then, one day, she quit. Why? Because she could get more money from the government for having another baby herself. She was using our system to get more money. Our system rewards mothers who cannot afford to provide for their family by giving them more money when they have more kids. And, the amount is exponential. 1 kid = $1 but 2 kids = $5. Double the kids, 5x the money. These figures are not accurate, but that is the jist of it. That is why our nanny quit. Frankly, I don't blame her. If someone wanted to increase my income 5x for having a kid, and I was in that situation, I would jump at it. Well, if I had a uterus. (LOL)
Our system is so damned flawed. What we really need is to fix our own problems. But, as long as their are politicians trying to get reelected, it will continue to be the same old B.S.