Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

discussion,

who's talking here?

Mojo 2
Deborah! 1
ashml 5
Kristen 1
Bahet 1
doddlebug 2
Euro Maker 3
Jessie 1
Blueser oO 2
daisy 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

ashml --- 16 years ago -

Note: this would be hypothetical and no name calling

Well I was talking to a friend of mine in the states, and she told me about a woman that had her newborn baby (2 months) in her car seat and out of the blue a dog (rottweiler) starts attacking her while she was walking to her car. This woman beat the crap out of the dog in hopes to protect her newborn baby. The owner (next door) realizes whats going on, somehow gets ahold of the dog. (and bites him in the process) Then he calls the police on HER for hitting his dog crying animal abuse. She of course didn't get in trouble and of course they took the dog because it attacked a woman that was just walking to her car. (never provoked it nothing). The man resumes on yelling at her etc....


ok my friend asked me if I was in the sdame situation what would you do. I told her straight up, a dog attacks me and I feel the only way to protect myself and the family is to hit it, I sure would. I love dogs just as much as the next person but if a large dog attacks me and my children I would do any means possible to protect them. She was like OMG thats HORRIBLE....and got mad..I was like wth? So anywhos the topic of the day is if a large dog attacks you and your children what would YOU do!! 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

oh and my response is like that because of my experiances: My brother and I, at the age of 8 where attacked (my brother was 10) by a rottweiler that jumped its fence and just was set on attacking all the children walking home from school. My brother and I where lucky because in the middle of attacking myself and my brother it set its sights on a 7 year old boy, that boy had to go through massive surgery to reconstruct his face, the dog almost killed him. So that why I would do any means possible to protect my family. (just thought I would add that if anybody would ask or be upset about my response) 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Since this happened in the states, I can tell you that I would have been armed. I am not opening a discussion about guns.

The dog would have been Swiss Cheese before it had a chance to bite me.

Yea. I know. I can hear the mommies yelling now. How could you shoot a gun in the presence of a baby? Bla bla bla.

The answer to that question is easy. I would raise the gun. Point at my target, and then squeeze the trigger. That is how I would shoot a gun in the presence of a baby.

I thought I would nip that one in the bud before the nuts come out of the woodwork. Present company excluded, of course.

Oh, and if I saw this happening to someone else, it would be the same result. The only difference is, I'd have to be very careful about not missing the intended target. I won't put my finger on the trigger until I am absolutely certain that I won't miss.

If I have extra time, I'd put earplugs in the baby's ears prior to sending the dog to its maker. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

^^ I agree ^^ if the dog was attacking like a savage animal, it is a savage animal

would you not shoot a wolf, a bear?

if all it knows or wants to do is attack, then it has to be stopped.......and I am too afraid to beat off a dog, if I had a gun I would shoot it 

Bahet --- 16 years ago -

What cracks me up about the "OMG You'd hit a poor animal! That's awful!" crowd is if it was some doped up bum off the street that attacked them they'd have no problem at all beating the snot out of them. They treat animals better than people. For me, I don't care if it's a neighbor's 5 pound dog, a stray pit-bull, or some crazy street person. Anyone or anything that attacks my kids is going to deal with mama bear. I will hit, kick, stab, bash, bite, whatever it takes to protect my kids. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

yeah thats what I said too LOL..she got so mad she ignored me I was like umm ok. But she doesn't have children either, so yah 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

Depends where I was and where the dog was...if it had lunged at my defenseless, strapped in baby...yep i'd go for it...and do whatever it took and try to demobilize it....I don't carry a gun so thats not an option. A large dog can kill a a by in a matter of seconds.

If it was coming towards us and I had more time id try to be more evasive, cover the baby with my body and get it either on top of the car or in it and safe, again which ever happened first.

Id try to solve it without violence, but honestly if it was a matter of the dog or the baby there is not option...sadly I also find Rottweilers very intimidating, so I guess i'm also biased on that issue.
I'd like to think i'd do all these very wonderful and well thought out and humane things, but with seconds to spare all i'd be thinking about is the baby. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Where is Marissa? She has a rottweiler. The only damage Marissa's dog would do is to slobber on your shoes. He's a big black marshmallow.

But, back at the ranch... It's very easy to say what we'd do in a situation when we're not in that situation.

Things change very quickly when you are running on Adrenalin and instinct. 

Jessie --- 16 years ago -

I would do the same as doddlebug. If it came down to it, you act without thinking. kicking a dog to stop its ATTACK is a perfectly acceptable thing to do. what else are you supposed to do? Let the animal hurt you or the baby?? that is rediculous. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

well according to what I heard, she carrying the baby, walking to her car and BAM dog out of no where jumped her from the side. Even though I was attacked by rottweiler, there are really sweet ones out there. When I was 13 my dad had an army buddy with the sweetiest rottweiler on earth named Duke. He took all commands only in German, the only time he started getting aggressive was when he turned really old and could barely walk, then they just put him down because he was so miserable. 

doddlebug --- 16 years ago -

I'm sure Rottweilers are very wonderful dogs when well trained and treated like all dogs...It's just have a 6 inch scar on my leg from being attacked by one when I was five. Strange dog, don't know the owner, must have got loose, it killed a little dog in the park where we were playing, when my sister tried to intervene it turned on me (not her!!! me, I was just standing there looking scared LOL).
sooooo, try as you might not to be prejudice, when you see one its does get you feeling a little wobbly..even after all this time. Certainly not the dogs fault, but like I say in that split second, i think i would not help my reactions to be kinder. 

Deborah! --- 16 years ago -

Yep, pretty sure I would kill the little bastard. Just like I would any person that attacked me or mine... (As long as I hadn't done anything to provoke it.) 

Blueser oO --- 16 years ago -

bah... I didn't click send yet! 

daisy --- 16 years ago -

I am sure Joftaa must have been'Billy the Kid' in his previous life...hhmmm...anyway i own a 'big marshmellow'too(very sloppy and cuddly)but if he would attack for no apparent reason,than i put him to sleep.The End 

Blueser oO --- 16 years ago -

She was like OMG thats HORRIBLE....and got mad..

Make your friend watch this! Then ask her what she would do ;)

I've had a standoff with a Rottie before, luckily I knew it was there before I got all the way out of my truck :P but it was my job to take care of it lol

Being an animal protection officer also meant dealing with vicious animals and we were trained with collapsible batons how to 'deter' an animal with a pop on the nose and, when that failed, how to 'protect' ourselves with a strike to the head. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

As the owner of two very large dogs (one of them being The Goofiest Rottweiler On The Planet and the other being a nervous wreck of a Mastiff), I wouldn't hesitate do whatever I could to protect my kid or myself. I know with MY dogs, I could grab them and flip them over and be on top of them before they knew what hit. I can't say the same for any other dogs, though.

That being said, I've never been faced with that situation, and unless a person has, I doubt they absolutely can answer the question.

But, I'd probably be doing whatever I could to get the dog away/subdue it. 

daisy --- 16 years ago -

I am sure Joftaa must have been'Billy the Kid' in his previous life...hhmmm...anyway i own a 'big marshmellow'too(very sloppy and cuddly)but if he would attack for no apparent reason,than i put him to sleep.The End 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

I love it when people talk all bada$$ about how they would shoot, when they likely haven't trained to muscle memory, or ever fired under duress, which is a much different situation than just firing at a paper target at the range. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

That being said, I've never been faced with that situation, and unless a person has, I doubt they absolutely can answer the question.

But, I'd probably be doing whatever I could to get the dog away/subdue it.

i have and at 8 (and being so little) with a huge dog on you, you can't do much but when the dog got loose and someone saw him attacking all the elementary school kids they had to track the dog down and shoot it because they couldn't subdue it. Yeah scariest moment of my life is a big ol dog grabbing my brother by the leg flinging him around like a rag doll then when I (stupidly) took a stick to hit it, to try to get it off my brother it turned on me and bit right above my knee, have a huge scar there till this day. I felt so bad for the little boy that was attacked after me, he was a tiny frail thing. Everyone was so surprised he was still alive after what the dog did to him. The owner got in so much trouble and discharged out of the military because come to find out he abused the animal and knew he was aggressive. His excuse was "its a guard dog" I am not scared of dogs unless a dog out of the blue runs up on me. Other than that I am good. LOL 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

But, back at the ranch... It's very easy to say what we'd do in a situation when we're not in that situation.

Things change very quickly when you are running on Adrenalin and instinct.



I love it when people talk all bada$$ about how they would shoot, when they likely haven't trained to muscle memory, or ever fired under duress, which is a much different situation than just firing at a paper target at the range.  

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground