We have USAA for our bank. Is there a place on the economy that will not charge a 3% fee on the ATM for the foreign pull?
I've always done a cash pull at the bank at the KMCC. No fee's to do it there. I know that USAA will do a fee reimbursement if it is a US ATM...will the do it with a German ATM? We want to go on the train today and need Euro for it.
We have an account at Community Bank that has no fees for having the account.
We leave it there for when we want U.S. Dollars. We transfer money to USAA to pay bills as described in the post at my site.
1. Transfer money from AAFES bank to USAA 2. Withdraw EURO from Volksbank ATM 3. Walk into Volksbank and put Euro into account 4. Pay your bills with that Euro
I love my usaa...I hated having another bank. I've only been here a few months...this is all new to me. I'm use to bill paying or writing a check for everything.
Yep. I took $$ from the county bank in Krickenbach. Same results. Since it is local German bank making the exchange rate, it can be done at any German ATM as far as I can tell.
But SCU and CB don't refund foreign transaction fees, I don't think so, anyway.
Here is an example. Say you go to Volksbank with a USAA ATM card, and take money, you won't be charged an ATM fee, and if you are charged a foreign transaction fee, USAA will refund it at the end of the month. CB and SCU will not refund it.
I forgot to mention that although some banks will refund your ATM fees, they may limit how much in fees they will reimburse. And, Service Credit Union requires a balance of $1,500 for them to refund your fees. I don't think Community Bank refunds fees at all.
USAA refunds ATM fees, but there is a limit of $15 per month. That is not really a problem if you use a bank without an ATM fee such as the Volksbank suggested. I cannot confirm whether or not other German banks charge an ATM fee.
The kicker is going to be the International Service Charge. This is not refunded by SCU or CB to the best of my knowledge, but it is refunded with USAA. This charge is based on how much you withdraw, so the more you take, the higher the fee. It is this fee that will kill you.
Before using your ATM card to take money from a German bank that your bank either refunds, or does not charge the international service charge.
I went down today to get this taken care off. There was a bank on my way to the train station. I didn't have a fee and the exchange rate is so much better then at the KMCC. That little bit really adds up!
I think I might have to start doing more things downtown. I don't know if our local bank is a good one to set up accounts. I might have to find another one in town. Might be more of a hassle; but, I can et up my allotment to be more. Just have to up a few things. Thanks for the heads up.
I watched this and there is still a 'fee' but it is built into the exchange rate you get......basically you still get a better rate by trading USD for EURO with an www.xe.com because USAA builds the fee into the price
check your withdrawl the minute you pull it out with USAA card
then 2 days later it is a buck or two higher
it is the foreign transaction fee that MC or whomever owns the debit card that USAA provides charges TO USAA and they never refund that, I have numerous emails debating this with them and they finally explained that it is not refundable........ATM fee yes, fee that MC charges USAA for pulling cash out with their MC backed debit card=no refund
Today I withdrew 200 Euro from the the Service Credit Union's "ugly teller" (ATM)in the KMCC. I was charged $261.06. About an hour later I withdrew 200 Euro from a Volksbank's "ugly teller". The cost was $253.79. The DoD rate for today is $0.7661. The Volksbank/German bank rate was $0.7881. By using a Geldautomat I saved $7.27 today on a 200 Euro withdrawal. However, I was charged a 1% transaction fee ($2.54) for withdrawing from a German bank. This is the only fee charged by Service Credit Union and I will have this fee refunded to my account at the end of the month because I maintain a $1500 account balance. For many folks this account balance amount is not reasonable so I would recommend, as JOFTAA and DakatoCowgirl did, open an account with USAA and take advantage of their credit card. Though $7.27 might not sound/seem like a lot, it does add up over the weeks/months/years!
For Euro/USD conversions at SCU or Community Bank here is a link to the 266 Finance Unit's calculator. http://www.21tsc.army.mil/266Finance/ExchangeCalculator/Default.asp
My bad....ATM/debit card...guess I had credit card on the brain after the wife did her thing at the BX...LOL
I feel ya!
My wife had her credit card stolen while we were in the U.S. I never reported it stolen because the person who stole it was spending less than my wife.
My wife had her credit card stolen while we were in the U.S. I never reported it stolen because the person who stole it was spending less than my wife.
[i]Just to clarify, it's their ATM card. It has a credit card logo, but it is for debit transactions. [/i]
but, any fees assessed by Mastercard for using the debit card will not be refunded
We spend, with rent, utils, shopping on economy, travel, etc probably an AVERAGE of about 2-3k in Euro a month.........so that is a sizeable chunk of change that we would be giving away.........yes, giving away
no more b*tching about the price of gas if every time you pay rent you are giving away $70 just on 1000E for rent
so, you are talking about a card that is from USAA for just cash, from an ATM that won't work as a debit card at all, and has no logo on it? NO Mastercard logo on it?
@Kristen...it sounds that a Visa Credit and ATM/Debit card from Service Credit Union would be one idea to consider providing a). you're eligible for membership and b). you can maintain a balance of $1500. If so, you would have ALL your fees (ISA and ATM transaction fees) returned to you at the end of each month.
I corresponded with them via email a few months back about this for about a week. I also called, but used email so that I would have it in writing. The fee that gets tacked on is passed on because it is what MC charges them (in easy terms vs. the lengthy explanation they went through) is what they pass on.
You can see it, it is not a ton, but it shows up. Five mins after you take out the money, it may say 267USD then two days later there is a buck or so added on. Not a huge deal compared to others, but there is a 'fee'.
If you use xe.com you get more bang for your buck............they still get to keep some of the money, of course, but easier than taking 1000's of E every month out to deposit it to your downtown bank. Just click and transfer, and keep more of your own money.
I'm not trying to be a wiseazz, but have you read this discussion at all?
This entire discussion has been about using an ATM card. Regardless of whether or not it can be used as a debit/credit card or not, we are talking about using it as an ATM card. The card has multiple uses but we are not talking about them.
Regardless of having a Visa or MasterCard logo on it, it can be used as an ATM card. Take it to a German ATM to get Euro. The only fee, if any, will be an ATM fee from a non-USAA bank's ATM. USAA refunds this fee at the end of the month up to a limit as discussed above already.
The card is only used as a debit card if you specifically use it that way. If you were to use the card at KMCC as a debit card, there would still be no fee because USAA does not charge debit card fees.
Go to USAA.COM if you want to get info on their card.
but they give you crap for exchange rate, I won't use either bank on base because of it
I am trying to show you guys how to keep more of your money, I already did my spreadsheets with the SCU and CB rate comparisons and realized they were giving us a crap exchange rate back 2 months after we got here..........
we use a German Bank to pay rent, pay utilities, get our Euro out, etc
[i]Regardless of having a Visa or MasterCard logo on it, it can be used as an ATM card. Take it to a German ATM to get Euro. The only fee, if any, will be an ATM fee from a non-USAA bank's ATM. USAA refunds this fee at the end of the month up to a limit as discussed above already.[/i]
the refund the PER USE AT THE MACHINE FEE not the other fee whether you use it at an ATM downtown or at the KMC for Euro, I see talk of getting good rates for Euro
IF YOU USE your ATM card and it has a MC logo on it, you still pay a fee to MC via USAA. Even when it is not a debit transaction. I will find the emails from them where they explained it all to me........because my 'amount of USD' kept going up overnight/in 2 days when I would get Euro out, and I wanted to know why if I was getting CASH at an ATM why I was getting charged this random other fee that was not an ATM fee
@Kristen...I'm a little slow so bear with me here....I'm assuming you/spouse get paid in US dollars. If so, with whom do you have your funds deposited? If an American financial instution, how do you get US dollars when needed? (I'm in the process of looking at xe.com., as we have large Euro use as well (3-4 K) p/m.) Thanks.
I took out Euro from Volksbank on August 19. It was a transaction for only 10 Euro. Had I done this transaction at an AAFES ATM, it would have cost me as follows:
The date you chose was: 8/19/2010 The Euro to Dollar accomodation rate for 8/19/2010 is: 0.756 The amount you entered is: 10.00 The converted amount = $ 13.23
My USAA statement for that transaction shows a total of $12.99. That is a savings of 24 cents per 10 Euro taken from the ATM.
There are NO INTERNATIONAL FEES with the USAA ATM card. There is NO ATM FEE, either. There are NO FEES, PERIOD.
Maybe I am misunderstanding you. If I used the card as a CREDIT CARD there may be international fees, but not when it is used strictly as an ATM card. I have never had any international fees taken from my account.
Some cards that have the MC or Visa logo on them ask at the time the card is inserted into the ATM if you want to use the card as an ATM card or credit card. Mine does not ask. It can only be used as an ATM card at an ATM. It can only be used as a credit/debit card in a retail store such as at The KMCC.