Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

What do you think?

who's talking here?

M'lissa 1
Mojo 2
Fran 7
Liv813 2
WitnessProtectionProgram 1
ashml 3
Melinda 1
Bahet 1
Euro Maker 1
CMS 3
Dani 1
daisy 1
MAD4EUROPE 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Fran --- 16 years ago -

Eberhard von Brauchitsch (lawyer), a Swiss resident, and his wife of 58 years, Helga (a doctor), commited suicide together on September 7, because they were both extremely sick and didn´t want to leave either partner alone in case one would die first.
Their daughter was present when they drank a cocktail that made them both pass at the same time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eberhard_von_Brauchitsch

Do you think this should be legal everywhere, as it is now only in a few countries, like Switzerland?

Do you think it is better to leave this earth while you´re still in great menthal health, but suffering physically?

Would you help anyone you love commiting suicide? 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

And I couldn´t find an English article YET, the only link in English was the Wikipedia one. 

Melinda --- 16 years ago -

While I wouldn't want a loved one to suffer, I'm selfish enough to keep them around for as long as possible. There's also my religious beliefs that prevent me from killing anyone. Self defense is one thing but taking the life of someone who hasn't done me or my family is just something that i couldn't do. even if they wanted to die. I'd carry the guilt around for the rest of my life. 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

I don´t know what I would do to be honest.
I think the guilt of seeing someone suffer, both physically and mentally, watch them in pain day in day out after their spouse they had been with for almost 60 years has passed, would be just as much of a burden to carry. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

If it is their choice, and they are of sound mental standing, I don't think I could keep them suffering. I really think physician assisted suicide should be legal, there are a lot of people that suffer for months and even YEARS before passing "Naturally", and you have to look at quality of life vs. quantity of life in those cases. 

MAD4EUROPE --- 16 years ago -

I couldn't help someone commit suicide. I couldn't live with that on my conscience. If someone is willing to do that to themselves, there nothing I can do about it but I wouldn't partake in it. I don't think we need to give this kind of power to anyone else (Doctors). If someone thinks it time to go then they need to do the deed themselves. 

Bahet --- 16 years ago -

I think physician assisted suicide should absolutely be legal. I couldn't take that role of assisting myself but if someone who is terminally ill wants to die rather than continue to suffer then there should be no law stopping them. 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

Marissa that´s what they said also, according to their daughter, that they made the decision while they were still mentally able to, and fully aware of their choice. 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

Did anyone see the report on this guy who was in a wake coma, and the doctor was about to turn off life support, and before he did, asked him to blink if he wanted to keep on living, and he did three times? I think if it were up to doctors to determine that, a lot wouldn´t bother to actually TRY to communicate with a patient. THAT doctor rocks, though. 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

I want to be euthanized before I need my diapers changed, lose my mind and/or have to live in a nursing home. I just don't see the point of living if you are always in pain and your family has to pay to have someone take care of you because you can't on your own. 

Dani --- 16 years ago -

Did anyone see the report on this guy who was in a wake coma, and the doctor was about to turn off life support, and before he did, asked him to blink if he wanted to keep on living, and he did three times? I think if it were up to doctors to determine that, a lot wouldn´t bother to actually TRY to communicate with a patient. THAT doctor rocks, though. 

Or that doctor sucks... you would think they would try to determine if he could communicate long before they planned to pull the plug.. geez. 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

Well, apparently they did, repeatedly. I have to correct myself, he didn´t "blink", he rolled his eyes to one side.
He couldn´t even blink. 

Mojo --- 16 years ago -

I do support it, but I do believe that the choice should lie with the patient and/or family, not the doctors. 

daisy --- 16 years ago -

This is a tricky one.Euthanasia is in most cases carried out by people who dies ask for it (voluntary).If my Hubby had a terminal illness and had no quality of life and would ask me...yes..i would do it..its about dignity and compassion.I did a none-voluntary euthanasia on my dog last year....you mind be thinking but she is a dog and we shouldn't compare animals with Humans,but she was part of our family and she deserved to be treated with dignity.Trust me it wasn't easy but if i have kept her for a few months longer,it would have been for my own selfish reason. 

CMS --- 16 years ago -

We are able to help our beloved pets to die when they are suffering, when there is no way that they can be saved without extreme measures that would prolong only their quantity of life, and not the quality. Why should our loved ones deserve any less? 

MAD4EUROPE --- 16 years ago -

Actually CMS, I couldn't do that either when my 4-legged son died. He was 17.5 (I had him since he was 13 weeks old) and I was struggling with this decision and the vet was explaining the same thing you said quality vs. quantity. I get that...but then in the back of your head it's like, "maybe there is something else we can do", "maybe ALL the options hasn't been exhausted". And If I didn't do A-Z first before deciding to put my son down I couldn't live with myself. But he actually died the next day after having this conversation with is doctor. This is such a touchy and emotional subject. Who knows what's right! : -( 

Liv813 --- 16 years ago -

I think assisted suicide should be legal. After watching my father suffer for several months and then being taken off of life support only to wait for 8 days until he passed, it was terrible.I know that he did not want to suffer like that and if the option to drink a cocktail were available -- I think he would have opted for that instead. My views changed after going through that last year. Watch You don't know Jack. It's a movie based on Dr. Kevorkian. It's a little slow but it is interesting. And I saw the documentary on that guy who rolled his eyes. 0Here It is fascinating. And sad. 

Euro Maker --- 16 years ago -

Treatment of Animals 

Fran --- 16 years ago -

Liv813, thank you for sharing the link, I was looking for it.
I think the doctors make some excellent points.
Also, like his relative said, how is keeping someone artificially alive NOT playing god? 

CMS --- 16 years ago -

If my mother was living in excrutiating pain, nothing the doctors could do, no hope for a cure... I don't think that I could ethically do things that I knew would prolong her suffering and add a few more days to her life. 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

I can understand living with pain and not wanting too and not wanting to live alone but in all honesty, they weren't in great mental health because if you weren't depressed or whatever you would never want to kill yourself. but don't believe in suicide.... 

Liv813 --- 16 years ago -

I don't know Ashml. I get where you're coming from, but if you couldn't get out of bed, feed yourself, had bed sores to the bone, catheter, no quality of life, but your body wouldn't give up -- would you really want to live like that -- all the while knowing that what you had was inoperable -- the doctors telling you maybe 2 months. Just food for thought. Depressing, morbid food. Sorry 

CMS --- 16 years ago -

My friend's mother just found out she has stage 4 cancer. She has suffered with pain from severe birth defects all her life and is now at the point where the pain from her cancer is not really controlled by meds unless she is drugged into oblivion. There is not a thing they can do for her, and have now sent her home to die.

It is a sad, depressing, morbid subject. It's not all bad that we sometimes ponder on deeper subjects, though. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Here is the perfect case for human compassion.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1582095/Disfigured-French-woman-loses-euthanasia-bid.html

No one will ever know what they want until the time comes to actually make that decision.

People can be mentally sound and know that enough is enough. This women ended up dying alone, all by herself by suicide instead of being surrounded by love and family and passing peacefully with help from a doctor. Her quote fits her and many other situations perfectly and sadly:
"One would not allow an animal to go through what I have endured." 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

Actually I saw someone lived like that, and even though she was in pain she got to see her kids, and her grandkids before she passed..The only way I would want someone to kill me if it would be better (emotionally for my kids) but in all honesty if I had cancer or something where I had "some amount of months to live" I would fight until I was tired. I believe you will go the way you are meant to, so obviously they where meant to die like that but for personal preferance, I wouldn't kill myself just because I would want to see my kids and grandkids and hopefully great grandkids, and currently I am going through some illnesses myself, and if it ever developed into cancer I would try to live as long as possible because of my children. Just how I see it 

ashml --- 16 years ago -

in all honesty it would depend on the situation, the illness and the things they have endured for so long. My personal prefrance though wouldn't be to kill myself. but I do see what people say though even though I wouldn't do it to myself, doesn't mean I think people should suffer. I never said I think its bad or wrong or against it just trying to clarify that 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground