Where does it say on rys that all sales are final?? Does it say it? If someone "claims" that something is broken after they buy it,but was actually in working order,then what do you do?
it sounds like you sold somthing to someone and they want you to take it back. tell them that you have your own policy and they should have checked it before they bought it but you were sure it was working. than after you tell them that, you ignore them. but dont be someone who screws other people on purpose, its not nice.
This was actually not my situation,but somebody else's. They sold something that was working, the guy called later on and said it was not working. Now they are showing up at her door demanding their money back! So.....now what?
Did you sell me that item that doesn't work? lol jk this was a while ago. I bought an appliance, got home and it started smoking when I plugged it in... I emailed the seller and they ignored me completely! They also claimed it was an older version of a certain brand and when I got to inspecting it at home, it was a completely different brand! Bah, I'd like to get my hands on her! My fault for trusting a stranger I suppose.
I am guessing that you sold something and the buyer is claiming it doesn't work?
Are you talking about a lot of money? Is it going to be worth the hassles trying to deal with the buyer? Or, just easier to take the loss?
I noticed that most everyone who sells on RYS does not state "as-is" in their ads. If you don't state as-is, there could be an implied warranty. But, for the most part, when buying something used I assume it will be received in working order, but that the warranty is 20/20. That's 20 seconds, or 20 feet out the door, whichever comes first.
Well, not me. This girl sold something a couple days ago, now they are coming back asking for their money back. They even showed up at her door. I'm not sure what the ad said,but I can ask since I cant find it on there.
To me, it is a gray area. If it was picked up in her house, and it was something expensive (like $100), she should have demonstrated it working.
I have purchased electronics a few times, but I never buy without seeing the item working first. If the seller doesn't want to show me, no problem, I just move on without buying it.
Hind site is 20/20, though.
How much is she willing to endure over $100? Giving your friend the benefit of the doubt, is she willing to have this person showing up at her door again? And, possibly again after that?
At what point would you say its harassment for them coming to your door? Seriously, for $100 you'd think they'd want to test it out,but if they didn't,then its kinda their own problem right? Just sayin..
A year ago we purchased 2 AFN boxes. THe add stated perfect working order. THe person wanted us to meet in a parkng lot so we did. We got home and only one worked. With in an hour or 2 we called the guy and he met back up with us and gave us our money back for the one box. It was no harm no foul. No hard time over it. But we did tell him that it said pefect order and the one was not. I guess it just dpends who you are working with and the way the add was written. I am just suprised that if they picked it up at a house they did not ask to check to see if it works. Hmmmmmm.....
i am kind of iffy about this situation....I bought a crib, that in the pcitures shown, it was in tact and put together....she hands me all peices and screws and she went on her way. She totally gave me the wrong screws on purpose. I put it together where it would stand up but flimsy and not safe for a baby...I think it should be common deciency of seller to at least give half money back or something. I think it is kind of mean and rude. but that is just me
I said above, but I don't know the situation, I think if it broke right when the buyer got home then she/he should get her money back, if it was a couple days maybe not so much. I am kind of biased though since what happened to me was a total scam
There is no implied warranty with a private seller beyond expecting something to work unless it is stated "as is". If the seller honestly believes the product to be in working order then it's caveat emptor (buyer beware). If they didn't test it out that's their fault and their problem. If it was a matter of hours or even a day or so I'd suggest taking it back anyhow. However, if it's something they've had for a while or something like an AC unit purchased when it was hot that they now want to return I'd say tough.
Well, there is legally correct and ethically/morally correct. If the buyer did not test the item in normal circumstances, then I believe legally it is their own problem, although if the ad said that it was in perfect working order, that is an implied warranty. The problem that may arise is that if they are upset enough to show up at her house, they may be upset enough to work up her or her husband's chain of command to resolve the issue.
I think the best thing you can do is that before you sell anything to take the time to show the buyer the item with all pro/cons, if any electric item or not . Everybody is in a big hurry , show up take the item , pay and leave . If was me in you're friend situation I will reimburse the money back if the item wasnt tested to the buyer when got sold .
Even with that said, and even if we all agree, how much hassle is this worth? It is $100. I would hope that this is not a life changing amount for anyone, but just refund the money and get rid of the hassle and the possible threat.
Even with 'buyer beware' the purchase took place in the seller's home. The seller should have volunteered to demonstrate it. If the item were delivered, and at the buyers home, then the buyer should test it for sure.
Regardless of who is at fault, regardless of who is wrong, there is the 'hassle factor' to consider for the seller.
There is no implied warranty, regardless of what the ad said. People on RYS are not professional merchants. There is no gray area on that.
I would not refund the money. It is the principle as well as the cash- if your friend KNOWS for sure it worked when she sold it, then she is in the right. Whether it was tested or not, if she is certain it worked, then she will be out $100 by taking it back- that is not fair. It is not her "moral" obligation to lose out, if she did nothing wrong. Yes, it sounds like a hassle, but for an item of that value, I would stand my ground.
If I paid $100 for something and took it home and it did not work, I'd be ticked, too.
Electronics can be finicky. They work one minute, then stop working the next. Even improper handling of the item can cause it to go bad. Static electricity for example can cause electronics to go bad.
We still don't know what was being sold/purchased. Only that it was sold in what we are told is working condition. We have no more reason to distrust the seller as we do the buyer.
This is a simplistic example, but have you ever went into a room and shut off the light, only to walk back into the room and the light stops working? It was working a second ago. It should be working now. This is what happens with things.
There is no reason to doubt that the item was sold in working order. There is also no reason to doubt that it stopped working upon being used for the first time by the buyer.
If you want to make it a question of morality or who is right or wrong, then you risk the constant annoyance and threats. No thank you.
Even assuming that the item was in perfect condition when sold, and even assuming the buyer is a complete liar (not saying this is so), how much crap does the seller want to put up with?
You may want to put up with it, and that is perfectly fine. I am just saying that for myself, I would not want to deal with a stranger who I have no idea as to their mental stability over a small sum of money.
Hmmm, if it was electronic, the buyer may have broken it when the plugged it in to wrong voltage or wrong size transformer... something to keep in mind.
This happened to us and as it was the first time we gave the money back and learned from it.If we were to sell any electric items now,we give the buyer the option to test it first for our own satisfaction and there's.
JOFTAA, this kind of transaction does not fall under that regulation. A person selling items (especially used) is not considered a "commercial" seller.
no implied warranty. She should have verified it worked. I almost sold an Xbox i thought worked until they had me plug it in, surprise it didn't work, must have gotten bumped in the move. So unless she tested it before hand she cant but SURE that it worked, but neither can the seller if they didn't test it out. Both are at fault but JOFTAA for article states implied warranty for buying from a merchant. A merchant isn't just someone who sells something.
OK. I'll buy that the link I posted is not applicable here.
Having said that, I will stick to my previous statement that I would not want to be hassled over $100. Again, this is just my personal feeling. If $100 means a lot to you, then you may not want to give it back. Or, if you feel that you are in the right, and don't care about being hassled, you may not want to refund the money. That is all fine. I am just stating my personal feeling on the matter. I don't want some stranger showing up at my door demanding $100. I'd feel as if I could not leave my kids at home by themselves because this person could show up at the door. Peace of mind is worth $100 to me.
so, now you are taking a different stance on it...........because it is not worth the hassle, not because you are wrong...........
I did get something that I feel was broken recently, I did ask for it to be refunded, but it was not. Sucks, but shit happens, it is yardsales.
if you want to state your personal feelings don't get all 'legal term' happy on it
just state that it is your opinion from the beginning
I really take offense to the fact that you also are implying that $100 is nothing.
There are many of us here that it is nothing to, but to many it is a LOT of money. Please quit saying that it is not a lot of money. I am in my 40's it is not to us, but, to my son, in his 20's it is.
Again, JOFTAA, wow. Proven wrong. Hmmm. At least here you will concede to "link not applicable." I'm not trying to start a war with you or anything, I am just annoyed to see how you act when you are wrong. And since most people on here kinda follow you and your advice, it seems you could be a little more humble.
I was wrong. I said I was wrong. What is your problem now? Seems that some people are not satisfied no matter what.
And, Kristen, I stated the hassle factor before I posted that link. It seems that once again you jumped in without bothering to read the posts.
In my two posts BEFORE the link, I mentioned the hassle factor. Guess you don't want to mention that, eh?
Kristen, I am glad you found the definition of humble. Try some of the pie.
I really take offense to the fact that you also are implying that $100 is nothing.
Show me where I said $100 is not worth anything. In my second post I said $100 is expensive. How is that nothing? You really have a reading comprehension problem. You have made that very clear.
This situation happened to me last week and I did try the item when the buyer show to pick up . It was an used item and sometimes they fail to work properly .Wasnt the buyer fault and wasnt mine but I felt right to reimburse him back hes 50$. I also appologies to him for hes lost time and gas spent to pick up/return .Its common sense .