Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Santa Clause thing with kids

who's talking here?

Rachel 2
Kristen 7
Euro Maker 7
oszbbk 2
Atticus Finch 1
DOGTRAINER 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

so, our son just this year knows there is no Santa...

when he found out he was MAD--not mad that there is no Santa, but mad he had been LIED to.......

from day one I was kind of up in the air as to whether to even go there with the Santa thing

he also said it is 'stinking blackmail mom'

just a thought for those out there if you have ever considered not using the Santa thing

now, don't get me wrong AND READ THIS CORRECTLY PLEASE....I am NOT saying you are bad if you use the Santa, thing, obviously we did........ I remind him he DID enjoy it--and I also told him it would have been hard for him to understand why his friends believed and he did not, OR he may have ruined it for other kids 

Euro Maker --- 15 years ago -

What in the hell are you talking about?!!!!!

There is no Santa? 

oszbbk --- 15 years ago -

His reaction is kinda funny.

I didn't get to fully enjoy holidays as a child so I knew I would go along with the santa thing from day one. I rode it out til my kids realized the deal. And I always made the older kids play along til the youngest came around to knowing. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

he is a pretty 'unusual' kid......and we have a VERY good relationship, very close, I really never lie to him...so I think he felt betrayed.....

Like I said though, he did have fun while it lasted and I remind him of that 

Euro Maker --- 15 years ago -

There is a huge difference between lying to a kid and playing along with an imaginary character.

How did your child(ren) behave when they figured out the tooth fairy was imaginary? By the time a kid is ten years old (or there about), the tooth fairy may have visited more often than Santa Clause.

It's a fantasy for kids. Not a lie. 

DOGTRAINER --- 15 years ago -

if you have tought your kids, that telling stories about things that are not true are lies, then telling them that a Santa Clause exsists, is a lie ! 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

yeah, we talked about that too, I think a big part was he flat out asked me and was like

'mom, Santa cannot travel that fast' and 'mom, then why do poor kids get nothing if there is a Santa' etc....and I kept making crap up.....so I should have just caved and fessed up when he questioned it

he stopped believing in Easter Bunny and Tooth Fairy long ago too........

he was not very upset about them......said he was kinda creeped out by a 'bunny pooping eggs' anyhow.........plus when he learned more about the reasons for the holidays he gave less of a crap about them 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

yeah, Dogtrainer, that is a part of it, so, once again, we had to talk about lies.......

fun lies, stories

white lies == which he totally gets because I have told him many times if he is not comfy with something, he can white lie his way out of it (my mom won't let me do that, I have to go home now, etc) 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

being a parent of a child that trusts you 100% and having a close relationship like we do can be complicated LOL 

Euro Maker --- 15 years ago -

When my son used to ask us if Santa Clause is real, we never answered with a yes or no. We just asked him if he thought Santa was real. If he said yes, then we would tell him that he was allowed to believe in Santa. By not giving a yes/no answer, and letting him believe what he wanted to, it was no big deal when he realized that Santa was just a pretend character.

It is not as black and white as dogtrainer makes it out to be. I am not saying dogtrainer is not correct. I am just saying that there is a lot of discussion on this subject that can be read if you are really interested.

Take a look at this. 

DOGTRAINER --- 15 years ago -

if you have tought your kids, that telling stories about things that are not true are lies, then telling them that a Santa Clause exsists, is a lie ! ;o) 

Euro Maker --- 15 years ago -

if you have tought your kids, that telling stories about things that are not true are lies, then telling them that a Santa Clause exsists, is a lie ! ;o)

You said that already. Saying it twice does not make it a fact. It is your opinion, and I respect your opinion.

If you are trying to say that any parent who has ever taught their child that telling a story that is not true is a lie, is a liar, then there is a planet full of liars.

Neither of my kids was scarred from believing and then finding out that either The Tooth Fairy or Santa Clause was a fantasy, felt like they were lied to.

How do you feel, DOGTRAINER, about all of the websites that allow kids to write letters to Santa for a fee? How about the websites that allow kids to track Santa across the sky? How about theme parks such as Walt Disney World who have fantasy characters such as Mickey Mouse or Winnie the Pooh? Are these all lies or just harmless fantasy?

Harmless fantasy is not a lie. Even if a parent plays along. That is my opinion. You can respect that or not.

Here is the question presented at another site.

Like I said earlier. It isn't as black and white as you'd like it to be, in my opinion. 

DOGTRAINER --- 15 years ago -

so, our son just this year knows there is no Santa...

when he found out he was MAD--not mad that there is no Santa, but mad he had been LIED to.......


here we go again:
if you have tought your kids, that telling stories about things that are not true are lies, then telling them that a Santa Clause exsists, is a lie !

I´m starting to understand, why some of JOFTAA´s comments are so nerving...
instead of just taking one´s comment word by word and trying to understand what it states, there´s assumptions being made like:
If you are trying to say that any parent who has ever taught their child that telling a story that is not true is a lie, is a liar, then there is a planet full of liars.

that is not what my comment worded, now is it?!

How do you feel, DOGTRAINER, about all of the websites that allow kids to write letters to santa for a fee? How about the websites that allow kids to track Santa across the sky?

IFkids are made believe, that they are following someone live on a web-cam - then that is a lie!
If they are doing this, knowing the truth, then that is no other game than any game, where they collect gems or catch rabbits on a console.

Harmless fantasy is not a lie. That is correct ! Making children believe, that one´s fantasies are the truth - those are lies!

Even if a parent plays along.It´s not like the child came up with that Santa fantasy and a parent is playing along - is it?

That is my opinion. You can respect that or not. I always respect other´s opinion!


Like I said earlier. It isn't as black and white as you'd like it to be In myopinion it is that black and white ;o)

oh..and by the way....some poster had the idea to "write slow" for others to understand what they were trying to say....I like to poste again what I´m trying to say for others to understand ... 

oszbbk --- 15 years ago -

well I see both sides of this and am not saying either way is wrong or right. You allready know how I handled it with my own children. Dogtrainer...I am curious to know what you have/will do with your children. How will you handle these situations? Assuming you celebrate Christmas...or any other holiday that has a make believe character. There are many approaches one could make. 

Euro Maker --- 15 years ago -

If you are trying to say that any parent who has ever taught their child that telling a story that is not true is a lie, is a liar, then there is a planet full of liars.

that is not what my comment worded, now is it?!


That is EXACTLY how you worded it. You very specifically stated that if a parent teaches their kids that a story is true when it isn't, then it is a lie. Is someone who tells a lie not called a liar?

You've posted it several times already.

"if you have tought your kids, that telling stories about things that are not true are lies, then telling them that a Santa Clause exsists, is a lie !"

I did not misinterpret your words at all. I venture to guess that there are MILLIONS of parents who tell their kids that Santa is real. These same parents most likely teach their kids not to lie and teach their children that telling a story that is not true is a lie. By your very own statement, this makes all of these parents liars.

How is my interpretation of what you said a mistake?

Even if a parent plays along.It´s not like the child came up with that Santa fantasy and a parent is playing along - is it?

You keep on saying I am misinterpreting your statements, but you keep repeating the same thing using different words. Now you are saying that since the kids are not the ones making up Santa, it is the parents who are teaching the kids about Santa. I agree. How many parents do you think introduce Santa to their kids and tell their kids that Santa is not real at the same time? This again, by your words, is a lie.

Putting a child on a person's lap who is dressed as Santa, but not telling the child that the person is just in a costume is also a lie by your own words. Or, is omitting information not a lie now?

Question:Did you eat candy today?
Answer: I did not have any chocolate today.

What the answer did not tell you is that the person answering the question ate a bag of caramel candy. Did this person lie by omitting the information of the caramel? No, the person told the truth. But, he also did not answer the question.

All I said is that, in my opinion, the issue is not as black and white as you make it out to be.

I guess my own logic is getting in the way. 

Atticus Finch --- 15 years ago -

Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus
Editorial Page, New York Sun, 1897


We take pleasure in answering thus prominently the communication below, expressing at the same time our great gratification that its faithful author is numbered among the friends of The Sun:

Dear Editor,

I am 8 years old. Some of my little friends say there is no Santa Claus. Papa says, "If you see it in The Sun, it's so." Please tell me the truth, is there a Santa Claus?

Virginia O'Hanlon

Virginia, your little friends are wrong. They have been affected by the skepticism of a skeptical age. They do not believe except what they see. They think that nothing can be which is not comprehensible by their little minds. All minds, Virginia, whether they be men's or children's, are little. In this great universe of ours, man is a mere insect, an ant, in his intellect as compared with the boundless world about him, as measured by the intelligence capable of grasping the whole of truth and knowledge.

Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus. He exists as certainly as love and generosity and devotion exist, and you know that they abound and give to your life its highest beauty and joy. Alas! how dreary would be the world if there were no Santa Claus! It would be as dreary as if there were no Virginias. There would be no childlike faith then, no poetry, no romance to make tolerable this existence. We should have no enjoyment, except in sense and sight. The external light with which childhood fills the world would be extinguished.

Not believe in Santa Claus! You might as well not believe in fairies. You might get your papa to hire men to watch in all the chimneys on Christmas eve to catch Santa Claus, but even if you did not see Santa Claus coming down, what would that prove? Nobody sees Santa Claus, but that is no sign that there is no Santa Claus. The most real things in the world are those that neither children nor men can see. Did you ever see fairies dancing on the lawn? Of course not, but that's no proof that they are not there. Nobody can conceive or imagine all the wonders there are unseen and unseeable in the world.

You tear apart the baby's rattle and see what makes the noise inside, but there is a veil covering the unseen world which not the strongest man, nor even the united strength of all the strongest men that ever lived could tear apart. Only faith, poetry, love, romance, can push aside that curtain and view and picture the supernal beauty and glory beyond. Is it all real? Ah, Virginia, in all this world there is nothing else real and abiding.

No Santa Claus! Thank God! he lives and lives forever. A thousand years from now, Virginia, nay 10 times 10,000 years from now, he will continue to make glad the heart of childhood. 

DOGTRAINER --- 15 years ago -

oszbbk: I told my children the true story of "Nikolaus" - not the Coca Cola Santa Claus that was made up for profit ;o)

And yes, we do celebrate christmas - but I´m not willing to discuss the "make believe" character of christian religion.

JOFTAA:If you are trying to say that any parent who has ever taught their child that telling a story that is not true is a lie, is a liar...that is how you interpreted it, not how I worded it.In fact - if you read this sentence again, it does not make any sence at all....

if you have tought your kids, that telling stories about things that are not true are lies, then telling them that a Santa Clause exsists, is a lie .....that is how I worded it!!

These two sentences have two different meanings - I guess my own logic is getting in the way!!

How many parents do you think introduce Santa to their kids and tell their kids that Santa is not real at the same time? This again, by your words, is a lie.
No, that´s how you interpreted it -
that would be ommiting the truth ;o)

Putting a child on a person's lap who is dressed as Santa, but not telling the child that the person is just in a costume is also a lie by your own words
No, those are your words - it actually is ommiting the truth. If the child would ask you, if he was the real Santa Claus and you answered "YES" - then that would be a lie.

To all parents that have made their children believe, that there is a real Santa Claus: I have no bad feelings against you and I do perfectly understand, that you like to make this season brighter and more exciting for the children. In fact, it puts a smile on my face. I´ve just decided for my own children, to stick to the truth ( and no, I´ve not made them believe in the easter-bunny, the tooth-fairy or any other fairy, wizard, ghost or fantasy figure like Mickey-Mouse or Pooh).

Kristens 5 year old being smart enough to tell a lie (even if it was for more fun and joy) should make us parents think twice, when questions come up like:
How did the baby get into mummies belly?

Frohe Weihnachten ! 

Euro Maker --- 15 years ago -

DOGTRAINER... I noticed how you quoted just about everything I said, yet you still did not answer my question about omissions of truth being a lie or not. 

DOGTRAINER --- 15 years ago -

JOFTAA: yes I did - maybe not clear enough - here:
Putting a child on a person's lap who is dressed as Santa, but not telling the child that the person is just in a costume is also a lie by your own words
No, those are your words - it actually is ommiting the truth. If the child would ask you, if he was the real Santa Claus and you answered "YES" - then that would be a lie. 

Euro Maker --- 15 years ago -

I want to make this clear for myself so there is no misunderstanding.

1. Is omission of pertinent facts considered a lie? Yes or no?

2. In the following scenario, is the answer a lie? YES OR NO?

Question:Did you eat candy today?
Answer: I did not have any chocolate today.


3. I am gathering that you think that omitting the truth is not a lie. Correct? YES OR NO?


All I want, in order to be clear, is a one word answer for each question. I don't want to have this conversation any further until I am clear on your answers. Three questions, three Yes or No answers. Thank you. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Kristens 5 year old being smart enough to tell a lie (even if it was for more fun and joy) should make us parents think twice, when questions come up like:
How did the baby get into mummies belly?



I think part of my mistake is that our older kids already knew when they came to live with us (teen and pre teen foster children)

the other thing is I have not lied to him really when he REALLY asked......I have omitted or skirted the truth, but the last year or so when he said 'mom, how does Santa get around that fast or what do poor kids or kids in the desert of Africa get' etc.......I had made up some stupid story to keep it going.......this is a real confession, I wanted him to still believe, for it to be one of the last fun kid things......I was ok when he gave up the other things, he is growing up........

after he asked a million questions and I had some lame explination (ie 'it's magic' and other BS like that) I finally said OK OK there is no Santa.........and he was so mad at me......

he kind of suspected it for a year or two he said, but never directly asked

AND since I had NOT lied about other things when he directly asked me I think he was not expecting to find out I had basically lied

he asked me when he was about 6 where babies really come from........TOLD him.....like, as in really told him, at 7 he asked for more details, told him more.......at around 8 he asked HOW babies are made and what sex is.........gave him vague answers but no lies......at 9 more sex questions ie. how does the sperm GET to the egg inside you EXACTLY mom..........I told him 'trust me you don't want to know' and finally I caved when he asked and said YES I DO then he was all grossed out, but he knew......

he asks me lots of things, hard questions, things about life, why people do or say things or are mean, why people hate others, why different religions exist, why people cannot just all be peaceful, why people kill, why some people don't want children, why people act mean sometime and nice others (around others) etc.......HARD questions--but I don't blow them off, I hated when my parents did that, and I wondered about that kinda stuff a lot......

anyhow, I lied in a sense, and he does still trust me (day to day actions tell that) but he was pretty upset.......upset at ME no less, not at dad :( 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, I am with you Kristen, and to some extent, Dogtrainer. My son is already the super inquisitive type- he questions everything, wants to know how everything works. Also we are very close. He already has tons of questions about Santa, and they are only going to get more specific. And yes, I feel weird lying to him. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

JOFTAA- is omission of pertinent facts a lie? Yes, if in the situation in question, both parties have an agreed-upon understanding that such facts would be divulged even if not specifically addressed.

Example: cheating on a spouse. If they do not ask you on that particular day if you have had sexual intercourse with someone else, then you are not lying by not telling them, right? Is that how you see it?
Omission of pertinent facts is lying. Your candy example is not an example of omission. The person did not answer the question. This is evasion, and they would certainly be questioned again. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

I am all for evasion. If you can evade instead of lie, do it.

The cases I am thinking about are times when it is best to evade or even lie to keep from hurting feelings though, not when it comes to this stuff. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground