Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

What say you??? - Lets Talk About It

who's talking here?

Mojo 8
HuskerFan 3
angel2009 1
masterdag 1
Kristen 2
CMS 1
Blueser oO 3
daisy 2
covan 2
RaginCajun 1
American Citizen 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

HuskerFan --- 15 years ago -

What do YOU think about this story???
Should this classic be changed to suit people of today??? I say NO!
Huck Finn 

RaginCajun --- 15 years ago -

no...it's a classic and was based on the time it was written. As a former high school teacher now turned AF Officer I think it's valuable Americana..just like Upton Sinclair's "The Jungle" which was a period book on the Chicago Meat Packing industry that drove sweeping changes. Today people could look at both and say they had valuable insight into their time and region. What's next? All Quiet on the Western Front? Uncle Tom's Cabin...they need to leave these books alone and be happy kids want to read anything that isn't on a TV or computer screen. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Absolutely not. Read in the context of that time period, it's a great teaching tool. It's also a great piece of literature.

If they do that, they have to change so, so many stories. Little House on the Prarie (Ma Ingalls was a total racist), Uncle Toms Cabin, Gone with the Wind, and on and on. And while we're at it, lets get rid of ever piece of misogynist literature out there, so all the stuff written about women need to go. Little Women, anything by Jane Austen, the Bronte Sisters, and absolutely anything written for women as far as being "Good little keepers of the home".

It's silly. It needs to be remembered as a part of our history, because thats the only way you can keep from repeating those mistakes. 

HuskerFan --- 15 years ago -

I agree with everything you guys have said...this IS a classic and needs to reaman as such. I cant think of one good reason why it should be changed and that word taken out...although I find offense with that name at the time this book was written AND the fact that its not plastered in there...let it stay.
Wait....hhhmmm....if I lead a nationwide protest to have this word removed...do ya think I would get "my reparations...my 40 acres and a mule"??? LOL...we are retiring in a few months and could use this land!!! LOLOLOL

They should leave this book alone! 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

I think their energy is better focused on making changes to pop culture and things that go on NOW, as opposed to points of view that are old, outdated, and not culturally relevant anymore. 

Blueser oO --- 15 years ago -

I think all the old copies should be burned. 

Blueser oO --- 15 years ago -

And yes, I was kidding. Y'all seemed so agreeable and bored, but I can't keep a straight face with that one ;) Classics should be preserved. What about all those nude paintings and statues? Are they going to make statue clothes or paint on some clothes so our youth won't be affected by boobies and abnormally small male genitalia? o_O 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Well, they did just that in St. Peters Basilica, but that is a topic for another day, I think. 

HuskerFan --- 15 years ago -

OH OH...Blue said....(childish teenage giggle) BOOBIES!!
I was SHOCKED when I read that article... 

daisy --- 15 years ago -

Haha..you are too funny Blueser,yep..it is a nanny state.Classics should be left alone but it won't,it happend before and it will happen again.It reminds me of a song don't worry i won't put it on(ain't nothing like the real thing baby).lol 

covan --- 15 years ago -

All very high-minded but the fact is that, because of that word, the book is banned from schools and libraries. Leave it in and our children will never read the book. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I think that political corectness goes to far on many occassions. 

masterdag --- 15 years ago -

Take the word out and you learn nothing about passed times.

While we're at it lets forget about slavery and any other bits and pieces of history and do it all over again. Since we have destroyed evidence of it.

I'm Native American and you would not believe the history that has been omitted or hidden so it could be taught in school. One piece of history fact: Who scalped Who? Who started it? White man did, he got paid for each one he had. Native Americans started doing it in retaliation.

Leave the book as is. Look at the bible and how many times it has been rewritten, almost to the point that the original ideas have been lost. 

angel2009 --- 15 years ago -

Hear hear Darin!! 

daisy --- 15 years ago -

Also Twain was critiquing racism not endorsing it.I also don't know how a black child might feel if it has to read it out in class.But then it comes down to history and slavery and should be taught at school. 

covan --- 15 years ago -

So, some of you support book banning? 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

I don't support book banning, and I'm frankly quite apalled at the books currently on the banned book list. I fully endorse reading banned books and keeping them in circulation, in their original form. Harry Potter? Really? 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Whoops sorry double post 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

(Ma Ingalls was a total racist
Caroline or her mom?

I agree with the DO NOT CHANGE IT part.....our son has read it the way it is written.........

we are on Season 6 of Little House on the Prairie though.........and I watched it as a kid, but notice WAY more now.....maybe you are thinking of Harriet, she is a racist big time 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

No, Caroline. The way she talked about the "Indians", the way she talked about black people. It was indicative of the time, but out of context it's probably hard for a child to understand. I think it's a good opportunity to talk to your kids about the way things and views used to be, vs. what they are now, you know?

Education doesn't stop at school, and simply because a book isn't read at school shouldn't stop a parent from having their child read it at home. But I'm a bit biased, I love books, I love words, and I have been buying and collecting books for my son since before he was born lol. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

The books have a lot more stuff that was sort of glossed over in the series. 

Blueser oO --- 15 years ago -

One piece of history fact: Who scalped Who? Who started it? White man did, he got paid for each one he had. Native Americans started doing it in retaliation.


I never knew that! I feel lied to now, next they will say we never landed on the moon! o_O 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

The way she talked about the "Indians", the way she talked about black people.


We just watched that episode recently....they were certainly afraid of being killed by them (because the Indians said they would) but they defended them, remember? And they had two black people LIVE with them.

Just sayin'

Anyhow, nothing to really debate in that sense but I love that show 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Again, I am not talking about the show, I am talking about the books. They are very different. 

American Citizen --- 15 years ago -

0 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground