Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

More History

who's talking here?

Mojo 1
Carl 1
Fran 7
GaryKenyon 2
Bob 5
CMS 3
daisy 1
covan 1
dontpokethecrazylady 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Bob --- 15 years ago -

I just watched a multi part movie/mini series called Hitler: Rise of Evil (or something like that). Considering all the death and devistation he caused if you could go back in time and assassinate him would you? Please explain your answer. Yes or no doesn't say much. Think about the consequences of your actions depending on your answer. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Hmmmmm that is a good one. I will have to give it some thought before posting a real response. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

Most definitely. I wish what's his name that put the briefcase with the bomb down next to him didn't leave the room, too bad that failed.
Why? What better way to be in every history book worldwide?
Plus, you know...world peace. 

Carl --- 15 years ago -

Valkyrie, I think...... 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

No.

If it wasn't for WWII America never would have become the industrial power that it did become and therefore the super power that we did become. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

You're just borrowing the power from China.
You never know what would have happened for sure though... 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

The US or China never would have become the world powers that they are without World War 2. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

True. Can't really argue that. 

dontpokethecrazylady --- 15 years ago -

Bit of a tough one to answer really. If I said yes, then would the Berlin Wall ever have been built? Would the war in Europe really finished any sooner?
I'm not convinced that his death would've affected the outcomes for America and China, after all America didn't get involved in WWII until Pearl Harbor, and was making bank off the Brits through their lease/lend program. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

another thing to think about before you answer. many historians agree that if the nazis hadn't taken power the communists would have. if hitler would have been assassinated at the wrong point we could have been fighting germany controlled by russia. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

I think it depends on WHEN he would have been killed. In time for another, reasonable German politican to take over, not build concetration camps, and manage to keep his allies and win the war, or when everything was more or less already decided. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

That's what I was trying to say Bob, thanks.
Iron curtain and all. 

dontpokethecrazylady --- 15 years ago -

@ Bob, in many ways that could've have been just as bad as having Hilter in power, when you consider the Gulags and the things that were reported to have happened in them.

I am just going to throw this out there, if I may. Do you think National Socialism itself was a bad political idea or, as in most things, made corrupt from those that ran it? 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I agree with what Fran said about when... At many points I think that he would have just been made into a martyr. Goodness knows there was enough evil centered around him to carry on. 

dontpokethecrazylady --- 15 years ago -

That is true CMS 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

carl, Valkyrie was the name of the movie not the person who planted the bomb. the guy's name was Colonel Claus von Stauffenberg. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

The ironic part is that he was put in place by some politicians because they believed him to be a simple, easy to control person, and they wanted to use him like a puppet. Oh those silly fools. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

dontpokethecrazylady, i think the idea of national socialism isn't bad just like true communism isn't bad. it's the leaders that make it bad. each idiolgy is based on something for everyone and nobody is left out. hitler and the other leaders used the good part to trick the german people into accepting them befor they took control.

personally, i think if the communists would have gained power it would have been worse. they probably wouldn't have killed all the jews and they would have had many more very capable soldiers for fight for them. i am pretty sure that western europe would be speaking russian now. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

von hindenberg was almost forced into appointing him as the chancelor. yes, they did think he could be controlled but they underestimated his powerbase and the steps he would take to gain and keep even more power. 

dontpokethecrazylady --- 15 years ago -

Bob, I just have to say it's a real change to be able to log into a forum where there is intelligent discussion going on. 

daisy --- 15 years ago -

Hmmm...no i wouldn't assasinate Hitler as he was only the puppeter of others,plus i think it would have changed history.How about Stalin,Goebbel or Himmler where those people not far more evil?Anyway timetravel is wrong,have you not seen 'back to the future'.lol 

covan --- 15 years ago -

National socialism was no more socialism than Saddam's Republican guard were republicans. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Daisy, it's funny you should say that. My grandmother, who is a VERY faithful catholic, was telling me when we visited on leave about how the Pope needs more people praying for him, because he's making bad decisions because of the people around him. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I do think that the movement would not have been quite as strong without Hitler. He was a very charismatic person/speaker, which is partially how the whole thing went so far awry. If he had been taken out early enough, maybe it would not have been so bad. Like when he was young, around WWI timeframe or so on. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

My grandfather still has some
WWII papers along with an original signature.
I wonder if it's legal to keep that (or how much I'll get for it on Ebay haha).

Funny side story, he was captured by Americans and locked in a basement with 500 more people. When he checked, there were no guards at the door, and him and two others just left and went on a four day hike home. Was it not for a drunk French guard at the bridge they had to cross, he would have been fukked. That's why he likes French people haha. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground