Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Guns and gun control (very sad story)

who's talking here?

Mojo 5
Fran 1
GaryKenyon 6
Rachel 9
Melinda 2
Kristen 2
CMS 1
daisy 2
MAD4EUROPE 1
covan 1
Cara fanciulla 3
Lovecheese 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

I know we've talked about guns on here before but I just received this story in my inbox.

What do you think?

By JUAN A. LOZANO, Associated Press Juan A. Lozano, Associated Press – 2 hrs 34 mins ago
HOUSTON – Police are trying to determine how a Houston kindergartener got a loaded gun that he brought to an elementary school, where officials say it accidentally fired when it fell from his pocket as he sat down for lunch, wounding himself and two other students.

Some parents said the incident has made them think twice about safety at the school and they wonder if additional security measures, including extra officers and even metal detectors, are needed. School district officials said extra security would be in place Wednesday to allay parents' fears.

One bullet was fired Tuesday around 10:35 a.m. in the Ross Elementary School cafeteria, spraying fragments at the students, said Houston Independent School District Assistant Police Chief Robert Mock.

"It dropped on the floor, under the table. It was loud, it was so loud," 6-year-old Kennedi Glapion said as she was being picked up from the school by her grandmother.

Houston police spokesman Victor Senties said it was too early in the investigation to tell if any charges would be filed.

Two 6-year-old boys were wounded, including the one who had the gun. The boy who brought the gun was injured in his foot and the other boy was grazed in his leg, said Sam Sarabia, the elementary chief school officer for the Houston school district. A 5-year-old girl was injured in her knee, he said.

The boy who brought the gun might have been injured by the bullet while the other boy and the girl might have been injured by shrapnel, Sarabia said.

All three children were taken to Texas Children's Hospital. One of the boys, Khoran Brown, was treated and released. The girl, Za'Keyah Thomas, and the boy who brought the gun were in stable condition. The name of the boy who brought the gun was not released.

Brown's parents issued a statement through the hospital. "It is a sad situation that this took place but we are thankful our son is in good spirits. He is already asking to get back to school," the statement said.

Many parents who rushed to the school after the shooting said that overall, Ross is a good school and there haven't been similar problems. Still, some parents said additional security measures, such as metal detectors, are needed at the school, which has about 470 students.

"I think every school should have metal detectors just for this reason," said Lucy Becerril, 29, whose 6-year-old son, Carlos, was in the cafeteria during the shooting.

Shawn Dixon, 33, whose 10-year-old daughter Tyra is third-grader at the school, said he would support such security measures.

"Being that this is an elementary school you would think that it would be safe, but now this makes you think nothing is safe," Dixon said.

Sarabia said district officials will be working with parents and the community to address any concerns they might have.

The kindergartner who brought the gun could face disciplinary action, including being sent to an alternative school for up to 180 days, said Houston school district spokesman Norm Uhl. He said no punishment has been decided yet.
 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

I am not against guns or in favor of stricter gun control laws.

A law would not have prevented the child from getting a loaded weapon, since it was the parents who left it in the home like this.

I could go on and on about this, but everybody who knows anything about gun safety knows you don't leave a loaded weapon unattended in a home with kids. Everybody seems to think they have taught their kids, but kids are still young and impulsive and shouldn't be trusted around a loaded weapon.

the parents are at fault, more than anybody else. 

Melinda --- 15 years ago -

That is sad. This is an example of poor parenting in my opinion. I think the parents should be punished.

I grew up around firearms and taking it to school would NEVER have crossed my mind. My parents taught me respect, respect for a life and respect for a deadly weapon. Guns were not toys, even water guns. I don't think we had water guns in our house until my younger brother was 11 or 12 because my parents wanted to be sure that we knew the difference between a toy and a weapon. I would never have messed with a firearm without one of my parents present and helping me. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

A law would not have prevented the child from getting a loaded weapon, since it was the parents who left it in the home like this.




But the idea of gun control is that ownership of guns is MORE CONTROLLED, not that no one can own one. It is just very easy to legally own a gun in most states. That is what most 'gun control' legislation wants to address.

everybody who knows anything about gun safety knows you don't leave a loaded weapon unattended in a home with kids.

You do not have to know this in the US to own a gun. Just about anybody can. Stricter gun control laws would likely not affect you, Mojo, or your family, Melinda. If they were more requirements, including training and classes that had to be updated regularly, that alone would weed out a good deal of people who aren't serious about, and /or willing to take the proper precautions when owning a weapon. 

Melinda --- 15 years ago -

I do think that everyone that wants to own a gun should be required to go through a firearm safety course. My dad made me do it when i was about 10 or so.

I also think gun shows should be HIGHLY regulated. too many people can just walk in there and get a weapon. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

But isn't that the right to bear arms? Who is to say that these people, even with incredibly stringent guidelines, could not have still passed and been able to get a weapon? Just because someone went to the class does not mean that they don't make stupid mistakes. Don't get me wrong, I'm not advocating for these people, but once you start really regulating down rights, then you have basically lost them. That's just my two cents, though... 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Rachel, I agree with the basis of your ideas, but the fact is, nobody is going to go to an individuals home and verify that the firearm is being stored in a safe manner. That is where the breakdown occurs.

You can restrict and regulate all you want, but if somebody does not properly and safely store the weapon in their own home, there isn't anything you can do about it. You can say "You are required to have a gun safe" or "You are required to store the weapon and the ammunition separately", but there is no legal way to go into somebody's privately owned home to verify that it is being done.

That is why I don't think that stricter gun control laws will help the situation. It doesn't affect me, either way. We don't own firearms, and if I chose to, I would either store it away from my home or else store it properly in a gun safe. But that is ME, and really, there are no laws that will prevent a tragedy like this. You make a firearm harder to obtain, people will get them illegaly.

I think that increasing awareness and having mandatory weapons safety courses are a better bet, although in the end, willful ignorance is always going to win out when people think they are above following basic safety precautions. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Stricter regulations would cut down on a lot more accidents and poor handling than you think. Use Germany for an example:

In Germany the possession of any firearm with a fire energy exceeding 7.5 Joule requires a valid firearms ownership license for any particular weapon. The current Federal Weapons Act adopts a two-tiered approach to firearms licensing.

A firearms ownership license (Waffenbesitzkarte) must be obtained before a weapon can be purchased. Owners of multiple firearms need separate ownership licenses for every single firearm they own. It entitles owners to purchase firearms and handle them on their own property and any private property with property owner consent. On public premises, a licensed firearm must be transported unloaded and in a stable, fully enclosing, locked container. A weapons ownership license does not entitle the owner to shoot the weapon or carry it on public premises without the prescribed container. Firearms ownership licenses are valid three years or less, and owners must obtain mandatory insurance and a means to securely store the weapon on their premises (a weapons locker). Blanket ownership licenses are sometimes issued to arms dealers.

A number of criteria must be met before a firearms ownership license is issued:

* age of consent (18 years for rimfire calibers/21 years for higher calibers) (§ 4 WaffG)
* trustworthiness (§ 5 WaffG)
* personal adequacy (§ 6 WaffG)
* expert knowledge (§ 7 WaffG) and
* necessity (§ 8 WaffG) (Necessity is automatically assumed present for licensed hunters and owners of a carry permits (Waffenschein)).

Persons who are

* convicted felons
* have a record of mental disorder or
* are deemed unreliable (which includes people with drug or alcohol addiction histories and known violent or aggressive persons)

are barred from obtaining a firearms ownership license.

Firearms carry permits entitle licensees to publicly carry legally owned weapons, loaded in a concealed or non-concealed manner. A mandatory legal and safety class and shooting proficiency tests are required to obtain such a permit. Carry permits are usually only issued to persons with a particular need for carrying a firearm. This includes licensed hunters, law-enforcement officers, security personnel and persons living under a raised threat-level like celebrities and politicians.

The weapons law does not apply to military use of weapons within the Bundeswehr.

The identity card of German troops contains a term allowing them to carry weapons. Nevertheless, issuance of guns and especially ammunition is also very strictly controlled within the armed forces.



These kinds of regulations do not interfere with a person's "right to bear arms;" they just regulate the ownership. If a person really wants to own a gun here, they can. But it is a process. If you are not willing to go through some steps in order to own a gun, you probably shouldn't have one.

To say weapon regulations wouldn't change anything is like saying there is no need to regulate anything. Look at car seats. They are a pain, and an expense, still most people use them since they have become required by law. Before they were legally required, almost no one used them. They are many examples like this. 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

It's a good thing I'm not trying to get a weapon or CCW permit here in Germamy.

Back home all I need is one form and $10 to get my CCW permit. No extra BS required. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

How is that BS, though? Do you really want ANYbody to be able to get a CCW so easily? Or were you being facetious? 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

To enforce a rule like that in the states, you would have to embrace a much more stringent form of govt than most Americans will embrace. Again, there is no way that it could be enforced without people having their homes inspected. A system like that would never fly in the states.

I am willing to bet that the weapon the child brought to school was registered. The parents probably had a license for it. I am willing to bet they probably just never thought "it could happen to them".

I still maintain that there is absolutely no way you could even pass a gon control law that strict, much less enforce it. The illegal gun market would make a boatload, though.

It's my personal theory that people only use car seats because they are visible and it's something that people can easily be busted for not using. I have seen tons and tons of people not using car seats right, taking their kids out too early because it's too much of a hassle, letting their kids ride in their laps for short trips, etc.

I know that German laws also make it very expensive to even get a gun license. Do you really think that a regulation like that would pass in the states, at all? Do you really think that people would agree to pay upwards of 3k or more for a license, not to mention the gun itself? Not going to happen. Those who still want to own guns illegally here, do. Those who want to store them improperly, do. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

My sister's FIL has a hunting- and weapon license. His guns are properly locked up, and he also got checked before (he had to show the people how his weapons were locked up, ammo had to be stored in another place and so on).
Authorities DO have the right to check that.
I understand there's crime everywhere, but it's not as easy to get a gun here, even illegally, as people think.
And I don't think I'd ever get robbed with a gun here. Whereas I wouldn't wander around in some cities in the US at night without anticipating to return with a couple of more holes in my body.

I absolutely agree with Rachel. 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

Or were you being facetious? 

I come from a state where the motto is "Live Free or Die." What do you think? 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

* trustworthiness (§ 5 WaffG)
* personal adequacy (§ 6 WaffG)



who decides this though, in the US this would not fly

we cannot discriminate or judge people

hell, we cannot racially profile

who would be the powers that 'judge' these things?

then of course they could still turn around and give it to someone else or one person in the house is able to get the gun but the other is not so stable, etc......then there would be appeals to people deemed unfit--$$ in courts for the state vs Joe Blow

there really is no perfect way to do it

Will they REALLY come into your home and check? Doubtful..........that costs more $$ too

I AM NOT saying it is not worth the money, but it is pretty obvious that our country opts to spend money on crazy things and not on important things like this........ 

daisy --- 15 years ago -

Criminals couldn't care less about gun control,it would only be for the law abiding citizen.I think it's dangerous owning a gun if someone has an anger problem.If i have a gun and the criminal knows it,does that mean he will come back with one of these automatic guns? What if my house got burgled and they took that gun and kill somebody?Too many ifs and buts... 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Well of course people will still break laws; they always do. But regulating something cuts down on the amount of accidents, mishandling, etc. To say 'some people will ignore the regulations, so don't do it at all' is quite silly. If we applied that other areas of life, we might as well have no laws and no consequences, since some people will still act inappropriately...

If you are not willing to pay in the thousands to own gun, then you shouldn't have one. I wish we had stricter and more expensive regulations for operating a motor vehicle as well. 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

Well, how about we regulate and tax the f*ck out of fast food, youth sports or anything else that is "dangerous".

Stricter gun laws do nothing to stop gun crime. They only make the LEGAL purchase of guns that much harder for law abiding citizens. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

But that is just not true, GK, evidenced by every other country that has stricter gun control laws, and by all of those that don't have any. 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

South Africa, Columbia, Thailand, Guatemala, Brazil, Estonia, and Mexico all have a higher gun related death rate than the US. And all of those countires have stricter gun laws than the US. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Rachel, the countries you are talking about with stricter gun laws do not have a democratic model of govt, they have a socialist form of govt, which is more invasive, can be more restrictive, and has the ability to pass heavier-handed laws. It's accepted.

They way our govt is set up, it will not happen.

I don't necessarily think it should be more expensive to own a weapon, but I do think there should be required safety courses. However, again, safety courses do nothing to prevent people from leaving a loaded gun laying around the house. 

daisy --- 15 years ago -

There are certain People who should not own a gun:O 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, yeah, I know those kinds of regulations would never pass in most US states. Just arguing for the difference it could make. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

And GK, sure, if you pick countries with notoriously crooked governments, law enforcement and drug cartel issues, which have nothing to do with gun controls there.

How about you pick the ones more similar to the US in other respects: the UK, Germany, Canada, Australia...
a bit more apples to apples. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Still not apples to apples enough; their govts are structured socially, not democratically. That makes a huge difference when it comes to passing restrictive laws. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

I said I know it wouldn't pass in the US anytime soon; just that it can and does work in modern societies, and doesn't trample constitutional right to bear arms, etc. 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

It's a good thing gun laws are not a federal issue and a state issue. 

covan --- 15 years ago -

Some clarification as the po po jumped to some conclusions. The gun did not fire when dropped, the kid was manipulating the slide when it fired into his foot and he dropped the gun. The gun was unknowingly obtained from a family friend, not the parents. 

Cara fanciulla --- 15 years ago -

Current US state Gun laws

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_laws_in_the_United_States_(by_state)#Arizona

This story brought back a lot of bad memories. In the early 70's when we were stationed on the other side of the country, we received a phone call from my mother-in-law in Az. with the tragic news that one of our nephews had been shot in the head by another child in the apartment complex. Great-grandma had been babysitting 4 or 5 of the kids when a six year old next door neighbor boy came out of his apartment with his mother's handgun.
Just playing cowboys...
Tragic situation and loss of life, but what, if any, would have been an appropriate punishment? Scarred a lot of people for life. The grandma never forgave herself and passed away shortly after. Today, Az has some of the strangest gun laws including the concealed-carry permit. I personally would like (including law enforcement) to know who has a gun on them. If you aren't wearing a badge, you don't need a .38 stashed under your jacket. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

So sorry to hear that, a very sad story.

And I agree with you. 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

Let's start making restrictive laws on breeding then.

You have should have to prove that you can be a fit, financially responsible parent who will not bring diseased/developmentally challenged child into this world. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground