Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Demjanjuk convicted over Nazi camp deaths

who's talking here?

Fran 2
anne 2
GaryKenyon 1
Bob 2
LongHorn 1
Kristen 4
Texan 1
daisy 1
MAD4EUROPE 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Texan --- 15 years ago -

accomplice to 20,000 deaths but only 5 yrs? How do you come by this sentence? age? being one who follows orders?

I know it has been many years since the crimes were committed but it is still possible to find others.does this sentence do justice? Does the death sentence not apply? yes 5 yrs for a man his age is death but it's about the sentence.Or is it time to just stop hunting these people,many who have just followed orders under fear.I say that not to sound as if i sympathize with him,just a viewpoint.

If justice is what is sought was it found here? 

LongHorn --- 15 years ago -

I think this is crazy!!! Thanks for the article though MAD4 :) The fact is that he did this when he was much younger and under orders to do so. Finding all of the guards to punish them the same is like saying in 70 years from now they are going to try to find all of the people who killed someone in Iraq or Afghanistan. Texan, the Germans (to my knowledge) do not believe in the death sentence. That is why if they do hand over a person to the United States that the US must make a promise to them that the death sentence will not be a punishment. 

anne --- 15 years ago -

i will probably get in trouble for saying this but i have always belived if you take a persons life then you should lose yours .. a eye for a eye and thats what i belive. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

karen, you're right...germany does not use the death sentence. it's true that 5 years could be the same it's very possible he will not serve any time because of his health. some of the defendants from the nuremberg trial, and other similar trials, escaped prision or were released early because of poor health or age.

the defense that he was following orders and was afraid of what would happen if he didn't is very hollow. the death camp guards were all SS troops and very fanatical about what they did. they were taught to hate the people they killed. the way they looked at it is they were the rat catchers killing the rats.

anne, i'll probably catch h3ll for this but who are we to decide to put someone to death? if we do that then we are playing god. i can understand the feelings but the punishment doesn't prevent the crime so in my eyes it's worthless. when we put someone else to death we are lowering ourselves to his level. the death of that person will not bring back your loved one and there have just been too many people on death row who have been released because it was proved they did not commit the crime. this means that we became the murderers. 

daisy --- 15 years ago -

Just to change the subject slightly.Was justice done when Osama Bin laden got executed or should he have been captured and put on trial?..only asking:O 

GaryKenyon --- 15 years ago -

the death camp guards were all SS troops and very fanatical about what they did. they were taught to hate the people they killed. the way they looked at it is they were the rat catchers killing the rats.

This guy wasn't SS though. He was a Soviet POW who was ordered to perform guard duties at Sobibor. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

and again off topic but Germany housed labor camps, all the extermination camps were outside Germany

not that it makes it any better, plenty died at labor camps

camps 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

I think the whole process is more about the state attorney getting 15 minutes of fame than "justice for the victims".

He was following orders. It was a military. If you're in the military you follow orders, especially if you're a POW and glad they didn't kill you.
That doesn't mean what he did was right AT ALL, but really, it's not like he or any other little guard had much choice. They didn't make decisions, they just followed orders.
Yes, maybe he was an a$$hole, maybe he wasn't, but he was just a tiny wheel in the whole machinery. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

kristen, what about dachau? it is right by munich and it was an extermination camp. i realize the web site you provided distinguished between labor and extermination camps but a camp that is built with gas chambers and a furnace to burn the bodies is an extermination camp. the people may have worked there as well but the end result was death.

gary, i didn't know this about him. i just looked him up on the internet, he is ukranian which explains a lot. if you read the history of the german advance through the ukrain you'll find the people there were more than happy to help kill the jews. i don't believe there was any "following orders out of fear". but that's just my opinion. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

yes and Sachsenhausen has both also.......I was just passing along which ones were meant for just extermination etc.......it does clearly show on there that Sachsenhausen had more deaths that even a few extermination camps!

you are right, many died for many reasons at all of them 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

 

MAD4EUROPE --- 15 years ago -

but who are we to decide to put someone to death? if we do that then we are playing god. i can understand the feelings but the punishment doesn't prevent the crime so in my eyes it's worthless.


Wow Bob, I am going to have to disagree here. If you're being put to death then you did something horrific to warrant that CONSEQUENCE. How do we know it's not deterring people. Yes, crime is high BUT what if we didn't have these consequences...how much higher would it be. YES, I believe in the death penalty. I believe that if you take a life, yours should be taken. Will it bring your loved one back? Nope, but it that is irrelevant. There are consequences for crimes and if you commit the crime then you have to pay for it and sometimes it's with your life. I know I'm not crying any tears over it. 

Fran --- 15 years ago -

I agree with the death penalty if there's no
doubt regarding the conviction, and if it's a real cruel crime.
What I don't agree with is the cost of keeping them in the cell for decades until they are actually executed.
If John Doe says "I killed 20 children, loved it, and would do it again in a heartbeat", and all evidence supports this, why not execute him right after the trial is over, or at least not wait decades? 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

because we are idiots 

anne --- 15 years ago -

like i said before i belive in a eye for a eye tooth for a tooth. i dont belive in death row and never had. i think its a waste of tax payers money and if they did the crime then deal with it now not years and years later. but thats just me. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground