Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Magic Jack vs Vonage

who's talking here?

Kristen 4
Nicksdad 2
CoffeeLuvr 2
a3401385uu 2
Falfurrias 1
a3211128uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

anyone who has tried both?

which do you prefer?

which is easier to set up?

I don't want to have to be AT my computer while talking on the phone--I know you can forward your calls for no extra feel from Vonage to home phone--can you do that with Magic Jack? Can I have the calls go to my regular phone?

I read about it and it sounds like it goes to the USB port but not sure how it would make my actual REAL phone ring? 

a3401385uu --- 15 years ago -

We have had Vonage for 2 years now and love it. We ordered it before we moved here. You have to (or at least when we ordered it 2 years ago) have a US street address for them to ship the Vonage box to. They also need a street address for 911 calls, even though you do not need to use that here the still ask. So you will have to provide a US mailing address and have that person mail you the kit if you are already here. I love Vonage. I love that when someone leaves a VM it comes right to my email. 

a3401385uu --- 15 years ago -

I forgot to say that with Vonage we do not use it to make calls back to the states because we have a delay when we do...so I end up talking over the person I am talking to and that is annoying. We have unlimited calls to the US on our home phone but for people stateside to contact us as well as creditors we have we LOVE Vonage. 

Nicksdad --- 15 years ago -

You plug a US-style phone with plastic RJ-11 connector into the MagicJack USB device. This phone will have a US phone number assigned by MJ. Yes, you'd have to be at your computer to use it, much like Skype. We like Vonage since you don't have this limitation. I guess MJ would be handy if you traveled a lot with your laptop, though. I'm sure if JOFTAA reads this, he'll chime in with his 2 cents since he is a MJ fan. Never encountered the "talking over" phenomenon on Vonage. We do have to kick the kiddo off the internet for best sound quality when using it since our DSL isn't all that great where we live. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

yes, I did read about MJ extensively but was trying to figure out how I could be doing housework or something if I had a MJ........... 

Nicksdad --- 15 years ago -

Might be possible to buy a 2-handset wireless phone set and plug the master base station into MJ and have the second handset elsewhere in the house. 

Falfurrias --- 15 years ago -

I have both. The Magic Jack is really cheap, but has very poor sound quality. Not to mention you have to leave the computer on all the time to receive/make calls. It is really great for traveling, or if you are on a tight budget

Vonage has a much better sound quality, it costs more, and you can make free calls to several other countries besides the U.S. (including Germany). 

a3211128uu --- 15 years ago -

We have the Magic Jack, and it works just fine most of the time. We have wireless phones with 2 bases and keep the master one plugged in next to the computer and the second one upstairs in our bedroom. There are some places you can't call because MJ doesn't have a contract with certain phone companies. Every once in awhile it won't allow us to call my parent's house phone, but our TKS line won't allow us to call that number either. We've brought this to Magic Jack's attention, and they offered to just give us our money back. So you could always try it and if its not what you want, they'll just refund you your money. Also we can't use the computer that the MJ is plugged into while on the phone or it starts skipping. but we have 2 computers so its usually not an issue. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Ok, thank you SO much 

CoffeeLuvr --- 15 years ago -

I know you were asking about MJ and Vonage but have you heard of Lingo? We have had lingo for 3+ years now and it has worked great. It works much like Vonage. I have used it in S. Korea when I was stationed there then in Germany too with no problems. Just a suggestion if you are looking at VOIPs. http://www.lingo.com/ 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

did you have to have it sent to a family member then sent here etc? 

CoffeeLuvr --- 15 years ago -

I don't know if you are asking me or someone else. We purchased Lingo when we were in Tuscon several years ago. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground