Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Parents of Obese Kids

who's talking here?

Mojo 4
Ginee 1
Bob 3
CMS 2
EuroMaker 1
MuzzeltheMerguin 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Ginee --- 15 years ago -

Just read the article. Any thoughts? I'm thinking it's a little extreme. I don't think they should take a child from an otherwise solid home just because he or she is fat especially when they are going to put them into our foster care system.

http://shine.yahoo.com/channel/health/should-parents-lose-custody-of-super-obese-kids-2510149/ 

EuroMaker --- 15 years ago -

Sounds like more Big Brother to me. What's next? Taking kids from homes if government doesn't like the way kids wash their hands before meals? After all, not washing well could spread disease and make kids sick.

Instead of taking the kids from the parents, how about offering the parents counseling on what they could do better? 

MuzzeltheMerguin --- 15 years ago -

I agree with EuroMaker and I think that educating the parent is a better option. Although in some cases the obesity of their child borders on child abuse.

A lot of parents were not taught how to eat properly and don't know and still just need to be properly educated. I have taught myself along with what my parents taught. My parents fed us very well, but fruit was a luxury when I was growing up and I have a hard time putting it in my daily diet. This is an example, I am in no way blaming my parents for my eating habits now as an adult. I am saying old habits die hard.

Those parents who can afford to and the know how on how to feed their children in a healthy manner and don't are the ones that bother me. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

the article does point out that educating the parents in an important part of the process.

what catches my eye is the statement, "But University of Pennsylvania bioethicist Art Caplan said he worries that the debate risks putting too much blame on parents."

i wonder who this person thinks should shoulder the blame. he goes on to say, "Obese children are victims of advertising, marketing, peer pressure and bullying — things a parent can't control".

i guess this means that a child that is a year old can watch and comprehend all the ads and marketing. i'm also sure that all parents allow kids to come to their house when the child is three and put pressure on or bully their kids into eating improperly.

it's time we stopped coddling the parents, and not only on this issue, and make them take responsibility. people are too used to blaming anyone else but themselves. it's never their fault.

no matter what ads are out there or what else happens a child can't drive themselves to the store, or mc donlands to buy what they want. when mom and dad take their kids to mc donalds every night cuz it's easier that has nothing to do with ads aimed at kids or anything else. the parent took the child there, paid for the food, and gave it to the child. it's the parent's fault...period!

i keep waiting for the famous flip wilson line, woo the devil made me do it!!!

but to address the point of taking the child away from the parent. unless it can be proven to be child abuse as mullelthemerguin and euromaker pointed out i think taking the child from the parent could cause deeper problems. children belong with their parents unless the parents are abusing them. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

After reading the article, the quote itself seems like it's being taken way out of context.

What he states is that, just like kids who are starved and malnourished are removed from care, kids who are overfed and suffer from multiple, potentially life-threatening medical conditions that could be managed with proper diet, are the ones that are being talked about here. Not just the chubby kid in your son's class.

These are the most extreme cases, and even the Dr. quoted states that the end goal is education and reconciliation of the family, not permanent removal. But, if the parents aren't willing or don't know how to take the steps to help these kids, and won't take or use the info and help that social services provides, then absolutely, these kids are just as much in danger as underfed/malnourished kids.

I see the correlation. I don't think it's as bad as everybody seems to think. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Yeah, I'm not thinking the chubby kid that you see here or there... I'm thinking about the kids you see on talk shows where the parent is all "I don't know what to do. He'll eat 4 big macs, or take 5 trips up to the dessert table at the all you can eat buffet" Ummm, he's 5. Don't let him eat 4 big macs. Don't buy him 4 big macs. Just like the parents of the 10 year old girls dressed like prostitutes... don't buy her a micro mini skirt! Be a parent!

I'm thinking they would only be doing something like that in extreme cases. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Exactly. The example stated with the 400lb teenager whose mother did nothing to help his situation is exactly who they are targeting, not the chubby kid you see walking around. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

cms, i guess you didn't see the part in the article where the people are concerned about putting too much of the blame on the parents. actually, i'm sure you did, but i wanted to bring this up again. it amazes me how so many parents won't take the responsibility for what happens to their kids.

i've thought about this some more. many times a child that overeats already has issues they are trying to contend with. it seems like it would be more productive to work with the child and the parents to come up with a solution. if you take the child from the parents it could actually cause more harm to the child. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

In which situations, Bob? Because, I can promise, that in any situation where an obese child has been removed, social services has likely been trying to work with/educate the family for quite some time.

While I am not about coddling parents, I do agree that some education needs to be provided. Depending on the socio-economic status, it could very well be that they do not have the right knowledge of how to eat or feed their kids healthy food.

I'm not defending all parents, because if your toddler reaches 100 lbs, either they have a very serious medical condition, or else the parents are incredibly neglectful in allowing the child to reach that weight without some sort of attempt to stop it.

My 10-year old just reached 100 lbs, and he could pass for a 12 or 13 year old. He is just built very big, with huge shoulders and hands and feet. And we keep him active with swim and football and anything else we can, just to keep him active.

So, I agree with you about parents taking responsibility, but there are some circumstances where it could be a case of ignorance that can be remedied. In the cases of willful ignorance where the parents refuse to learn or change or take charge of a situation, I don't particularly agree that they deserve any sympathy. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

i'm just going by the article. this is the first time i've heard of children being taken because of being overweight.

i would hope that there is a lot of work with both the parents and children before they go to this extreme. many people really aren't aware of proper diets and places where bad things hide in what seems like healthy foods. my biggest surprise was to find out how much sugar is in normal katsup!!! tomatoes are supposed to be healthy but they sure screwed them up.

mojo, if you are asking in what situations i think it may be worse to take the child away i'll try to explain. if the child has emotional reasons for overeating and has a good relationship with his/her parents then removing the child might increase the child's emotional distress. this could actually cause the child to overeat even more. i'm not an expert of course but it makes sense. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

It does make sense and I see what you're saying. But, if the parents aren't seeking help for the problem, it's almost the lesser of two evils. Because, if a child is removed, the intent is to provide the child with whatever emotional and physical help they need to learn healthy eating habits, get active, and have a good relationship with food. So the child might be an emotional overeater, and that will be addressed through therapy while working towards a healthy weight and ultimately, recociliation with the parents. They aren't yanking them out and throwing them in fat camps.

It's never just about the food, regardless of what people say. Food is so ingrained with events and things in all cultures, it's hard to separate the two. Cakes for birthdays, graduations, buffets to celebrate, bbq's for holidays, thanksgiving (which is just a holiday dedicated to overeating), and on and on. It really does require a huge change in mentality. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

Bob, I agree completely that these parents should be educated before such a step is taken, however sometimes all the education in the world won't help. I agree that there are generally underlying reasons why this happens, too, and maybe therapy and other resources like that would help. Again, I'm sure this would be done only in extreme situations, and just as in most cases of malnutrition, only a temporary measure. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground