Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Military Pension too Generous?????

who's talking here?

Bob 3
CMS 6
a3569571uu 2
1228 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Bob --- 15 years ago -

the following article says that many feel the military pension system is too generous:

http://www.military.com/news/article/are-military-pensions-too-generous.html?ESRC=airforce.nl

people are trying to compare the civilian world to the military. my answer is to make the people in the civilian world deploy to places where they get shot and blown up. make the civilian world be on standby and recalled 24 hours a day 365 days a year. let the civilian world be separated from their family for year long remote assignments in addition to the year or more deployments. let the civilian world do jobs that require advanced job skills get paid at such terrible rates that they quailfy for food stamps.

i understand there are many former military members in the civilian world and we could leave them out. the ones i'm talking about are the wusses who want to be the ones to make a name to get re-elected by finding money screwing the people who promise to die for their sorry @sses.

i agree with the person mentioned in the article that the pensions and pay as well, for these idiot politicians should be examined and cut first. the really haven't done anything for the country in so long i can't even remember the last time. oh, and smiling, shaking our hands, then bending us over and screwing us doesn't count. 

a3569571uu --- 15 years ago -

I am not necessarily against a new system, however, like many other recent decisions made "on our behalf" this one I fear will not be well thought through and changes will be made and consequences be damned.

That said, the author touches a sharp nerve. Indeed there are responsibilities, dangers as well as perks that only the military enjoys.

I for one do not complain about my pay and have struggled both as an E-4 and lived well at a higher rank.

Politicians are obviously out of touch or they would not spend nearly the money they do to get elected to an office that pays around .1% of what they spend to get the job. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

it's the "changes will be made and consequences be damned" part that bothers me. this will go like every other military change, jump in and see what happens.

this is typical approach, attack the people who protect you. the civilian side has people in this category, namely firemen and policemen. they risk their lives daily but get paid peanuts, in my opinion, for their work.

i've talked with many of the military people around here and i hear very similar things. most of them say that if the retirement systems changes they will get out. this brings to mind another difference between civilians and military, the military can do another stop loss and refuse to let you out. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

It really upsets me. 

1228 --- 15 years ago -

I have one note for all of those who will "get out if the policy changes". I agree I would be pissed too but where in the heck are they going to go? Have they seen the economy? This is about the best time that the GOVT can jack you beat you up spit on you and kick some dirt in your eye and still know that 99.9% will be back at work the next day because they have no other option for employment. But as of today this is irrelevant since for now Panetta is saying he will make 100% sure that all current Active Duty are grandfathered in on the current system. That makes the argument void for all those you speak to that will jump ship with a change.

So at least those joining in the future will have a choice and know what they are in for before hand as opposed to ripping up the current AD's retirement.

I think it is very sad that they want to and will take away the current policy. The problem is that you may not get support within the ranks to keep it. From what I recall only 17% of all AD retire with a minimum of 20 years. That would mean that the new proposed program will be better for 83% of AD while being detrimental to the 17% that could have gotten their full pension.

In short 83% that are not fully committed to the military will get increased benefits. The 17% that are committed to the military will see theirs get cut by upwards of 80%. All in the name of saving the fed a few bucks that could be saved by simply cleaning up wasted funds in the same military.

I remember somebody on this site said they thought they would get more money with the new proposed system than with the old. (their husband was retired after more than 20) It kinda made me laugh as it shows that people dont know how it works and ignorance of the masses is what allows this stuff to happen to us all.

The author of that article is barely worth the time to discuss. What a tool. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

"the new proposed program will be better for 83% of AD while being detrimental to the 17% that could have gotten their full pension."

you make my point perfectly. people who decide to look for greener pastures will reap the benefits while the ones who dedicate a large portion of their lives serving their country will be screwed. somehow i don't see a real positive side to your statement except for those who enlist, take the benefits for school and then jump ship with a pension, no matter how small, at the cost of those who serve the full 20 years. 

1228 --- 15 years ago -

I don't see much of a positive side to it either and didn't intend for there to be one. The only positive could be as you said for those who come in to get an education and earn a pension and pay while getting educated then bail with a free education, free pension and VA benefits. Also the latest news from Panetta is nice for the currently enlisted. Thats about it though, nothing for those committed to serving years from now and and end to the long term draw that the military once had with a dream of retiring at 38-40 yrs old with decent package. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

No positive side for us in it all... My husband hits 19 years next month. 

1228 --- 15 years ago -

No positive side for us in it all... My husband hits 19 years next month. 


The positive for you is that your husband will get his 50% in just over a year. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

IF they don't change it with no grandfather clause. If they change it to one of these dumbazz plans, we won't get much of anything for another 20 years or so. If it stays the same, or if they grandfather us in, then it is all good. 

a3569571uu --- 15 years ago -

1228 could you link the article which discusses in actual dollar amounts what the changes would entail? I have not seen exact (or probable) dollar signs.

I would also add most people who do 20 and get out do not stop working either. If you can retire on 50% more power to you, but even for an E-9 that means only $2700. As an officer say an O-5 that means $4000 at current dollars.

Since most people live up to and above their income (the military no exception and perhaps worse) then retiring at those amounts are not so hot.

The biggest shift I read is that under a new system the amount is finite, in other words what was contributed by the Gov't as well as the individual. Under the current system it would be for life, even if you live an additional 60 years.

THAT is a HUGE difference. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

a356... here is an article that outlines the percentages. Basically, if you get to 20 years, you will receive a 37.5% annuity to your thrift savings plan, but will be unable to touch it until you are 60. Not only will you not make as much, but that is almost 25 years (for some) from the time you retire until you are able to use your retirement.

I'm sure that will be of great comfort to all those retiring from military service and trying to find jobs to support their families.

I'm finding it hard to find anything good about this new idea, aside from the fact that it will give money (eventually) to the people who get out after a few years. 

1228 --- 15 years ago -

and here is a link to the article where Panetta says he wont cut the current retirement from those already enlisted. 

1228 --- 15 years ago -

I'm finding it hard to find anything good about this new idea, aside from the fact that it will give money (eventually) to the people who get out after a few years. 

You must realize that this is not intended to be good for us. It is designed to save money for the Federal Government. So do not look too hard :) 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

I'm not, believe me! Also, the first article that I read (which I can't find at the moment) said they shouldn't grandfather in current members, because it wouldn't save enough money. 

1228 --- 15 years ago -

Also, the first article that I read (which I can't find at the moment) said they shouldn't grandfather in current members, because it wouldn't save enough money. 

Correct, the first article that you read from about 3 or 4 weeks ago said that!

THEN JUST 4 DAYS AGO in response to the big stir up that came from the original articles you read, Panetta says he wont allow it to go through in that manner he will grandfather in current members. 

CMS --- 15 years ago -

It wasn't that long ago, but I'm glad that they are saying that now. Not that I believe it, or anything, but I'm glad. 

1228 --- 15 years ago -

To make it more accessible for you guys

Leon Panetta (the man that these decisions will go through for the next few years)

In his clearest statement on the subject to date, Defense Secretary Leon E. Panetta said today that if the military retirement system changes, it will not affect serving service members.

"I will not break faith," the secretary said during a roundtable meeting with military media representatives in the Pentagon.

Panetta's predecessor, Robert M. Gates, asked the Defense Business Board to look at the military retirement system and make recommendations. The final report is due later this month, but Panetta said he is familiar with the outlines of the proposal.

"I certainly haven't made any decisions" on retirement, he said.

"People who have come into the service, who have put their lives on the line, who have been deployed to the war zones, who fought for this country, who have been promised certain benefits for that -- I'm not going to break faith with what's been promised to them," Panetta said.


It continues on. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground