Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Why don't Americans get charged German rates at a doctors office?

who's talking here?

Mojo 1
Bob 2
Yvonne 1
balboa850 1
PAWtoScott 1
Drew66879 1
rtmitchell 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

balboa850 --- 15 years ago -

Just wondering what the breakdown is for foreigners.
Got a bill and they are trying to swindle me for a bunch of undone procedures or never issued medicine. 

Mojo --- 15 years ago -

Never had that problem with the docs we've been to, I'd take it up with that specific office. Sounds like an error on their part. I've found the german docs we've gone to were actually pretty reasonably priced, honestly. But we've been for very routine things, and once for an emergency and everything was spelled out ahead of time (except for the emergency, and that was billed and paid on the spot so no errors later). 

Yvonne --- 15 years ago -

If that's true, go to Tricare and have them break it down for you. Or call the German doc and ask them to explain it please. Also - as a foreigner you will get charged as a private patient since you do not pay into the German national health pot. I have worked for Tricare before and it sometimes helps to let the doctor's office know that you are a "self payer" i.e. are not or only partly covered by a health insurance... According to the German medical billing system, they can apply 3 different rates... and the ones for private patient are obviously the highest. So a little nice smile and asking the doc's cooperation can go a long way.

In general though - when I don't understand or agree with a bill - I pick up the phone and enquire with the place directly. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

you shouldn't be getting the medicine from the doctor. you should get a perscription to get it at a german drug store or maybe you can have it filled on base.

as far as german rates, there is really no such thing. germans, and me, pay a set price for health care base on income. the insurance pays for all necessary procedures. if you need things in excess, crowns, false teeth, glasses, or other things the insurance pays a portion but not all. the german government has done a good job at standardizing these costs as well as normal medical bills.

you need to talk with the doctor about the procedures that weren't done. it sounds like a billing error like mojo said. just make sure to talk with them before you pay the bill. it's easier to get an adjustment then a refund in my experience. 

Drew66879 --- 15 years ago -

I was injured on the job here in Germany. Shattered my elbow really bad. As a DA Civilian, you have workman’s comp, BUT you as an individual have to pay everything up front. The bills were many as everyone submitted a bill separately, and itemized. For an elbow rebuild and the 20 day hospital stay, I paid less than $11k. Had I been in the states I am sure it would have been 4 times that amount and a quicker discharge. I had to forcibly tell the doctor to release me to return to work. They wanted to keep me in the hospital for rehab as well. (As I was a paying customer they would get more hard cash) I was injured the 3rd day on a new job as a director. Not a good first impression for the CG.

I rather enjoy the direct billing now and am fine with submitting my bills to my insurance. The health care costs here are way cheaper than in the states. 

Bob --- 15 years ago -

yvonne brings up a very good point that i didn't even think about with the private insurance rates. it makes sense that if you don't pay into the pot you don't get the benefit of lower rates. 

PAWtoScott --- 15 years ago -

I was seeing a German Neurologist and just got the TriCare bill in the mail yesterday. The bill showed TriCare paid for 2 mental health visits. I have never seen a mental health provider in Germany??? Guess I will go see TriCare and talk to them about this. 

rtmitchell --- 15 years ago -

This is normal in the states as well. Usually though these erroneous bills are paid by your insurance company and not you.

In many cases if you go through your medical bills in the states and find and report your illegitimate charges, your insurance company will split the recovered fees with you! They obviously do not advertise this but it is a standard policy.

You are the only person who could ever tell your insurance company if these appointments and medications were real or not. With that being said your conversation with the insurance company needs to starts with " How much or what percentage of the xxx thousands of dollars that I am about to save you will you give me for spilling the beans?" Work your way up from supervisor to supervisor and If they do not want to budge then just let them know how much they are loosing and to call you once they have changed their minds. I have gotten 50% of $8900 over claimed medical care of a broken arm that did not happen(the broken arm happened just not all of the claimed care). As well as 50% of $13000 in erroneous charges on another case for a head injury.

I did not deserve all of this money by any means but it took me hours of research for me to find out what all of these charges were and compare them to events that either did or did not take place. In the end the insurance company is happy to pay you half as they never would have seen any of it had you not done the work for them.

Now if its on the governments dime I would probably just contact Tri-Care and let them know of the errors just because I dont want them taking my tax dollars.

If it were for me and out of my personal pocket I would become the biggest pain they have seen in some time. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground