Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Legit?

who's talking here?

Bob 3
Blueser oO 1
Nomen Nescio 2
dipthong 2
JustM4E 3
rtmitchell 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

JustM4E --- 14 years ago -

0

Bob? 

Nomen Nescio --- 14 years ago -

Interesting, and I thank you for the nudge to learn more ;)

Apparently legit, and not the only one...

Letters 

dipthong --- 14 years ago -

Info 

JustM4E --- 14 years ago -

"I remain, your sincere friend"??

I don't know....we still don't know if it's real. Anything can be made up on the internet and in real life for that matter. 

Nomen Nescio --- 14 years ago -

"Mahatma Gandhi's admirers are not in the habit of confronting embarrassing facts about their favourite saint."

Dr Elst research on the ideological development of Hindu revivalism earned him his Ph.D. in Leuven in 1998.


I don't know....we still don't know if it's real. Anything can be made up on the internet and in real life for that matter.

*info* Sorry JM4E - clicked flag when I meant to post the quote above.

Quoted you because I wanted to point out that our Constitution is now in jeopardy. Are you sure that it, too, is real?

Here

Interesting point you make - real life vs the internet. When the virtual world disappears all we'll have left is real life :) 

Blueser oO --- 14 years ago -

Bob?

Why are you asking Bob? Was he around in '39? :P 

JustM4E --- 14 years ago -

Why are you asking Bob? Was he around in '39?

Because he's a history buff and I'm sure he's heard of this subject.

Are you sure that it, too, is real?

Lately, I'm not sure what's real or not...
;-p 

Bob --- 14 years ago -

i've never heard of this. i know hitler did have many supporters (and those who just hoped things would go ok) until he attacked poland.

the mention of "this type of war" makes me wonder about it. the letter was written in jul 39 and hitler did not attack poland until sept 39 so he wasn't engaged in any type of war. the land he occupied till then was all taken without starting a war.

this doesn't mean that gandhi didn't see hitler's actions as a kind of war. 

rtmitchell --- 14 years ago -

Bob, you must be looking at a different letter than I am.

I do not see anywhere in the 1939 letter that says anything about "this type of war"

I see that Gandhi says "you are the one person in the world which can PREVENT a war that may reduce humanity to the savage state"

To me this letter's context shows that it was sent before the attacks begin. Just about everyone knew what HItler wanted at this time and Gandhi is requesting that Hitler consider the worth of his wants. 

dipthong --- 14 years ago -

http://www.geekosystem.com/gandhi-letter-to-hitler/

This link is interesting, as well. It compares signatures.

http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showthread.php?t=408502 

Bob --- 14 years ago -

rtmitchell, ok the wording is "the method of war" it could mean this as using war to get what he wants.

it may be true that some people could read what hitler wanted but not everyone. the british prime minister actually announced to the english people that there would be peace in their lifetime because he had a paper hitler signed. churchill was constantly in trouble at this time because he was the only one in england who believe hitler was going to start a war.

hitler was very careful not to give away too much. he needed to keep the support of the german people. this was more important that the support of the rest of europe. the last thing many of the average german citizens wanted was another war so hitler needed to bring things along slowly.

i realize this was all empty dreams but the people only hoped there wouldn't be another war. 

rtmitchell --- 14 years ago -

rtmitchell, ok the wording is "the method of war" it could mean this as using war to get what he wants.


I agree, but it does not mean that Hitler had already been in war. "The Method of War" is being used in the context of

"Will you listen to the appeal of one that has deliberately shunned the method of war" Otherwise read as "will you listen to my appeal?"

I am just pointing out that there is no reference to a war that was already being fought as in your initial response. I think you may have just misunderstood what Gandhi was saying.

I don't want to see the people asking you for your opinion to repeat what you told them as it would be incorrect. 

Bob --- 14 years ago -

rmitchell, you said "i don't want to see the people asking for your opinion to repeat what you told them as it would be incorrect."

first, it's not opinion, i made a statement based on fact not opinion.

second, if you check the history books you'll see that hitler had already annexed the sudetenland by sending in the wehrmacht (army) to occupy the rest of czechoslovakia that he didn't get as a result of the munich agreement.

sending in a military force to occupy an area is an act of war even if the other side is too weak to put up any resistance.

to look more at the statement "the method of war" it looks like it's being used as waging war instead of finding another solution.

i understand that this is something you will probably never agree with me on. this is also the type of thing that historians argue about for years. either side could be correct. i'm simply putting out the facts i find. for you to bluntly say:

"what you told them as it would be incorrect."

is either ignorance or arrogance. but if it makes you feel better i'm just glad that you know you're right and anyone who thinks differently is wrong. good for you! 

rtmitchell --- 14 years ago -

Bob you clearly do not see that your statements are off the mark of what I am discussing and in the end you are contradicting yourself.

My argument is very simple so please try to follow. I understand it is hard to see someone's point when you don't think you agree with them.

I will not get off track with historians arguments or anything like that. I am simply going off of your contradictory statements. I will make a list. Contradictory statements are in Bold. Key parts of the contradictory statements are bold and underlined.

1. You stated that there was no "war" at the date of this letter.

BOB: "the mention of "this type of war" makes me wonder about it. the letter was written in jul 39 and hitler did not attack poland until sept 39 so he wasn't engaged in any type of war. the land he occupied till then was all taken without starting a war."


You insinuate that Gandhi's "type of ward" statement is indicating that Hitler had started a war. You use this to potentially refute the letter as stating that the timing is off as Hitler "wasn't engaged in any type of war" at this time

2. I am saying that this letter states that Gandhi has simply requested HItler to avoid war and has noted that he (Gandhi) has shunned the method of war to get what he wants. I am saying that this letter is simply a plea not to start a fighting war. So I agree with your initial statement that no war as we would know it was initiated at this point.


3. You now say that Hitler had initiated a type of war because he sent troops to annex Czechoslovakia?

BOB: "second, if you check the history books you'll see that hitler had already annexed the sudetenland by sending in the wehrmacht (army) to occupy the rest of czechoslovakia that he didn't get as a result of the munich agreement.

BOB: "sending in a military force to occupy an area is an act of war even if the other side is too weak to put up any resistance."

4. I am now confused. In my note #1 you state Hitler has not committed any acts of war but in my note #3 you state that he has.

5. I deducted by your statements in the beginning that you may have been confused or you made an error in your typing. Your last post, which I quoted in note #4 simply shows that my deduction was correct.

6. Your statements in note #1 and note #4 completely and irrefutably contradict themselves.

7. I would also like to note that in addition to contradicting yourself completely in this post you have then proceeded to suggest that I am either ignorant or arrogant. I can only guess that my ignorance and arrogance in your eyes is based on the confusion that you created in your postings.


I hope that you enjoy the rest of your weekend and apologize for apparently ruffling your feathers. I am not intending to argue with you just pointing out a few things. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground