Ramstein Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Ramstein bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ramstein/KMC courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Doggone dilemma

who's talking here?

Mojo 1
Bob 1
Melinda 1
Blueser oO 1
Atticus Finch 5
imhere 1
Cloudless 2
dipthong 1
JustM4E 2
Stanley 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Cloudless --- 14 years ago -

Now here is a situation and I’d be real interested if you care to opine, since we don’t have any RYS scams or commissary rants currently in the inventory. Smartass answers allowed, since I dish them out. Since my daughter left Germany for school, she left behind two dogs to dwell with me in the city. One is a young Pekingese, which I would love to get rid of, by the way, although it will break my heart, he’s grown on me. And, her first dog. A 15 year old Corgi. Blind and deaf. Takes heart medication. As part of my daily constitution, I carry her to her food bowl outside each morning and each evening. She finds her way back to her little bed and sleeps most of the day. Still house trained and is never messy. On Sunday morning at 0635 I carry her to her food bowl. About a minute later she is yelping as in terrible pain and then just falls over on her side. Motionless. I go outside and sit with her, she’s barely breathing. I reach into my robe pocket to call the preacher to perform her last rights over the phone. Well, it was serious, okay? It was finally over. I was relieved, but of course saddened. Finally. The dear noble old girl had thrown in the towel. Then her eyes open. She slowly gets up and walks around. Goes back to her food bowl, and finishes. Then she stumbles as always back to her bed. Like it never happened. So. I can either put her to sleep, or come home one day and find that she had another attack, but did not recover. Perhaps a painful attack. And alone. (although we all really die alone, that’s for sure) Or maybe I should be with her and send her off with dignity. If you have a dog, it is a decision you may have to make one day if your dog lives out its years. Ultimately, the decision is mine. I know that. But I am curious. What would you do? Let me ask this with more drama…What…would….you ….do? 

Stanley --- 14 years ago -

First I would take the dog to a good vet to get an assement of what happened and overall health, and to make sure the dog is not suffering.
Also, like people dogs do have feelings
and other senses to rely on if blind or deaf. I believe you should keep the dog, and even if does pass on while you are not home, it still will be in familiar surrondings. 

Melinda --- 14 years ago -

I agree with part of Stanley's reply. If I were in your position I'd take it to the vet. They should be able to at least make an educated guess if the dog is in pain. If they are in pain and will probably have more attacks then I'd put them to sleep. To me it's an easy choice, let them die peacefully and free of pain or what could be a long drawn out painful death. 

Cloudless --- 14 years ago -

Hmmm..very good answers. But she is not in pain. She finds her way out of the little room she has. Does her business. Eats. Goes back. Sleeps most of the day. Vet says, "She's fine, you decide". But does this not lead to a bigger question? What if you were blind and deaf? Silence. No light. Just touch and smell and taste. Is that enough? But a dog cannot think. A dog can love. But dogs cannot think. No thoughts. Just silence. No light. No pain. Just nothing. Every day. Again. No pain. But only existing. A dog does not wait for the end. Only knows the moment. Dogs do not understand the past, nor the future. They love their masters. It is all they have and have ever asked for--nothing more. They trust us to decide. They cannot. They leave this to us. 

imhere --- 14 years ago -

I had to laugh a little about the way you wrote this :-) But this is way to serious to laugh about. You make a good point about dogs not waiting for the end. In your dogs case he is just exsiting. BUT ( and this comes from somebody that has a 12 1/2 year old dog that needs heart medication twice a day) all this dog needs is love. He is content and I'm sure he does show you love - in his own way. He is not suffering, he is living. He is not in pain, why would you wanna 'kill' him? Good luck in your decision :-) 

Atticus Finch --- 14 years ago -

E-U-T-H-A-N-I-Z-E the poor dog! It's the HUMANE thing to do

Atticus the Dog Expert 

Blueser oO --- 14 years ago -

I think you should call your daughter and see what she thinks first! One of my dogs stayed with my Dad back in the states, as per his request. However, if he put her down without consulting me first, there would be a problem... but my Dad would not do that.

And the fact that "But dogs cannot think. No thoughts." is merely your opinion. I have a video of proof that dogs think. That is not the point, contact your daughter and see what she thinks. The dog isn't in pain, and seems to be content to eat and lay around... sounds like a great life to me ;) 

JustM4E --- 14 years ago -

And the fact that "But dogs cannot think. No thoughts." is merely your opinion. I have a video of proof that dogs think.

Exactly!

But cloudless, I have been in your situation and it is definitely a hard one! My sympathy goes out to you...I could not make this decision when the time came. I thought I would have been less selfish but I had my 4 legged son for 17.5 years (a lot of my childhood and all of my adult life, at that time). In the end, I paid quite a bit of money for medications, special foods, and I was going to elect for him to have a surgery (to prolong his life). The German vet in Speyer was very honest with me in that I was being selfish and he was not living a quality life. She basically told me I was throwing money away and taking drastic measures to perhaps prolong his life for months, perhaps, weeks. I really wasn't hearing it at the time. This was truly devastating for me because he went everywhere with me and was there through the good and bad times. But that night I went home, I had to make a decision. I have to tell you, I didn't sleep at all. I just wanted to make sure he wasn't going to get better and I couldn't bear the thought of "killing" my dog who have always been there for me. But he ended up dying on his own the next morning. I never had to decide. :-( Sad, sad topic. Good luck, Cloudless. 

Mojo --- 14 years ago -

If the vet says she isn't suffering, I wouldn't put her down. While it is a peaceful way for them to go, I only feel its necessary when they are suffering. .

If you'd like the info for our vet, let me know. She is wonderful and will give you an honest diagnosis. 

Atticus Finch --- 14 years ago -

What a great QUALITY OF LIFE this dog has being blind, deaf and whatever else. IMHO it's a very cruel thing to do to an animal (prolong its life for a selfish and/or childish reason(s)) because you let human emotion(s) cloud your judgment. JustM4E said it well.... 

Atticus Finch --- 14 years ago -

Any dog -
[IMG]http://i44.tinypic.com/34pxfft.jpg[/IMG] 

Atticus Finch --- 14 years ago -

 

dipthong --- 14 years ago -

Atticus -- Your picture would have shown up, but this site has yet another flaw. The IMG tags have to be in lower case letters. Same tag, only in lower case, looks like this:

0 

Bob --- 14 years ago -

i have to agree with the comment about dogs being able to think. dogs do think and i've see them show the power of reasoning.

as far as being blind and deaf, a dog's most dominant sense is smell. it is able to get around by the way you discribe the daily routine.

as far as not being in pain, that's a hard one to judge even for a vet. most dogs have a very high tollerance for pain.

the thing that really catches my attention is the heart thing. i had to ask my vet directly if the stuff my dog was taking would fix the problem and he said no. it's a tough decision but that's the time to let them go. my dad said do the right thing, i'm here to tell you the right thing sucks but it is the right thing.

i don't know what your dog's heart condition is but there is always a possibility that the weakened heart will not beat hard enough allowing the lungs to fill with fluid. your dog will not die peacefully from a heart attack, it will drown!! not very peaceful to me. i have to agree with the grinch on this one end it now before the animal has to suffer even more. 

Atticus Finch --- 14 years ago -

Thank you "gliding vowel"! 

JustM4E --- 14 years ago -

Thank you "gliding vowel"!

Yep, thanks for posting GV and thanks for finding Mockingbird! That almost brought a tear to my eye (or was it these onions I am cutting), I haven't read that before. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Ramstein Underground